Vehicle Scrappage Policy: Inputs Sought

Very good idea of the government which in line with the rules on air pollution of International Maritime Organization for the merchant ship.
I suggest complete scrapping of the vehicle after certain specific time period. This is due to the reason that technology is changing fast than we expect. To my mind ten years is maximum for any owner of commercial or privet vehicle to scrap their vehicle. Both diesel and petrol engines emanate dangerous fumes such as carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, Sulphur dioxide and oxides of nitrogen whether they are new or old. The new cars are within the limit of the norms but as soon as used for certain period the ignition process deteriorate due to various factors which the owners are not aware off.
I fully agree giving them some incentive for scrapping their vehicles. more  

View all 14 comments Below 14 comments
Buying automotive fuel is becoming unnerving day by day. Petrol and diesel prices have hit the roof. They scare away buyers from the mobility market. Automakers are compelled to develop new options to spare customers from an unrelenting government with incessant price hikes burning holes in every citizen’s pocket. Beside being cheaper, CNG prices are far more consistent than fluctuating petrol prices. Also, the average mileage of CNG vehicles is better than that of diesel/petrol driven vehicles. With safety issues raised,CNG tanks come with a tight seal, which reduces the possibility of explosion while refuelling or in the event of a spill. It could be the future as at present, millions of vehicles are already powered by natural gas throughout the world and more companies and municipalities are joining the CNG movement every day. Apart from being a clean fuel, CNG is economical also as it has zero lead and is non-corrosive, non-dilutive and non-contaminating. It also helps in increasing the life of the engine, and requires less regular maintenance. Overall, emissions are reduced considerably as compared to diesel. Putting cleaner vehicles on the roads is key to tackling one of the worst air pollution problems in the world. The toxic air costs the country as much as 8.5% of its gross domestic product, according to World Bank calculations, as well as shortening the lives of citizens. A lot of work has to be done in coming months to make this scrappage policy successful.A big hurdle is a lack of infrastructure to handle scrapping or recycling millions of vehicles. Unless and until we know what the carrot to scrap vehicles is, it’s difficult to say how beneficial the policy will be. Autoworkers face uncertain future in an era of electric cars - automakers face pressure to abandon internal combustion engines to fight climate change. The likelihood is growing that auto workers who for decades built machines that run on petroleum will need to do different work in the next decade - or they might not have jobs. As shift of making from internal combustion to electric power goes, jobs that now make pistons and fuel injectors will be supplanted by the assembly of battery packs and electric motors. For auto workers, that future could be perilous. Factories will need fewer workers, mainly because electric vehicles contain fewer moving parts than petroleum-run vehicles. In addition, many union jobs could shift to lower pay as automakers buy EV parts from supply companies or form separate ventures to build components. Most vulnerable in the transition will be workers at plants that make transmissions and engines for petrol and diesel vehicles.There are just less parts, so of course it stands to reason that there is going to be less labor. This could be the beginning of that transition - it's not going to be just in the vehicle space. The number of jobs lost will likely reach into the thousands, though no one knows precisely. And those losses will be made up, at least partly, by the green economy, from work building electric vehicle parts and charging stations to jobs created by wind and solar electricity generation. All internal combustion-related jobs will vanish is not likely. One can exclude heavier trucks in EV goal. And some manufacturers will keep making gas-electric hybrids. Every major industrial transformation has resulted in lost jobs and new work. Auto workers could be retrained to make electric parts and assemble EVs. more  
Automakers cashed into the era of cheap diesel, a fuel that was highly subsidised by the government, say 20 years back, manufacturing cars that run on diesel, increasing pollution. There are several manufacturers everyone knows. Nothing was done in making their vehicles cleaner burning, but only enjoying profits. Better they, who are in some ways responsible now do the reverse. more  
Agree completely. Today's commercial gains being made with tomorrow's environment, with responsibility now must be with makers of these automobiles. Kaushikk ji, that is true so they choose with their money their kind of vehicles. Also because environmentally benign vehicles would be costlier requiring technological research such as the one replacing carburettor with multipoint fuel injection system, that drastically cleaned up emissions. Now just name based perception drive the market. Nothing "sporty" in a SUV - sports utility vehicle, for example. But see their sales drive up through commercial positioning! Never mind the pollution. more  
The more efficient combustion of fuel in any vehicle depends mainly on fuel to air ratio, the bore size of the jet in the carburettors n the four strok engines ,so the partial combustion of hydrocarbon is minimised and less carbon monoxide is produced. more  
Can someone answer a specific question - What are the quantities of CO2, CO and NOx in litres/kg produced when one litre each of petrol, diesel are consumed in a car? more  
It depends on the condition of specific cars engines. So if you want to know just check your PUC certificate it gives you both the desired concentration n actual emitted from your car's engine. more  
Scrappage law takes the engine, components, chassis and the entire automobile as one, whereas every component or assembly unit within the system, may be replaced modularly, with new ones, extending vehicle's life. When so much metal goes into production of cars, then replace whatever needs replacing, and save resources. As Mr. Kishore has rightly said, "A poorly maintained new veh will pollute more than a well maintained old vehicle, age has no bearing on pollution. If the owner replaces the old engine with a new one at the end of 15 years the veh will not pollute." Policy needs tweaking, with ultimate aim in making vehicles safe while also being free from pollution. more  
Ashish ji, I wrote the same thing in the beginning, that the car manufacturers should provide upgradation to comply with standards. I think our fellow citizens have more money to spend.
Jai Hind more  
The environment has to be kept clean and some sacrifice has to be done. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Forced scraping of vehicles based on age only is unjustified

      This relates to blanket order of Hon Supreme court and National Green Tribunal to scrap all vehicles by age, irrespective of its condition, which is unjustified and severe penalty for vehicle owner...

      By NK SOMANI
      /
    • Stubs burning

      I don’t understand why the agricultural ministry in Punjab and Haryana can not buy the machines required to remove the stubs and lease them to the farmers as per their needs.

      By Periagaram Shankar
      /
    • Trees per head - lets act...

      As per #UN report, Trees Per Head in Various Countries Are as Follows: Canada : 8953 Russia: 4461 USA: 716 China: 102 *India: 28* Needless to say what we a...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • Farmers back in action

      See AQI - 592 this morning. Farmers back in action as the administrators stay busy in elections. Can we please have a very pointed discussion on this subject. Nei...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • Worlds most polluted cities

      Most are in India and the beauty is we arent doing anything to fix core issues.

      By Satvik Singh
      /
    • Strategy to control Air pollution in Delhi

      Every year we experience Delhi as a Gas Chamber specially in Winter and Delhi Government wake up on receipt of caution notice from Supreme Court and then react with few conventional make shift ini...

      By Dr Achintya Kumar Chowdhury
      /
    • Air Quality

      I want to know whom to contact in the case of people chopping of trees and the local authorities doing nothing about. Thank you

      By Rohini Dua
      /
    • Air Quality Issue

      It is easy to blame the govt. and others, but it is always nice to find a solution for the problem with our own or collective expertise. Let us get to the bottom of the real problem. Which is missi...

      By Sunil Kulkarni
      /
    • Failed Accountability - Pollution

      it is pathetic that our communities, politicians and civic leadership including CPCB and SPCB prefers to blame each other rather than taking positive steps to correct it. I wonder how all such poli...

      By Arvind Pamecha
      /
    • Garden at every apartment roof top

      I had an another how about government should not any apartments map without gardens at their roof top roofs of societies are of no one at in most of the apartment no one is allowed to use that so i...

      By Amit Tiwary
      /
Share
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)