Why question credibility of the panel on Sterlite issue ?

The Hindu (dated 29th November,2018 ) has prominently published the views of a former Judge, questioning the credibility of the panel , appointed by NGT to investigate about the Sterlite closure order issued by Government of Tamil Nadu. The former judge has said uncharitably that the chief of the panel is not credit worthy. These are unfair remarks, particularly when it has been said by a former judge.

Further, the former judge has suggested name of other judges for including in the panel, whom he considers as having credibility. Why has he no included his name also in the recommended judges?.

While there are allegations about a few Judges , which may be motivated or otherwise, , no one should question their credibility unless proven guilty by a court of law. Position of judges is an unenviable job, as they can not please all.

The former judge has said that the Sterlite Industries has continued operation in the absence of renewal consent from Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board. The ground reality is that every Industry has to get consent renewal from Tamil Nadu Pollution Control every year. In many cases, Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board does not give consent order or otherwise in time. In such cases, there is no alternative for industry other than considering the absence of withdrawal of permission to be treated as “Deemed Consent” until Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board gives it’s firm order. Many industries are operating in such conditions in Tamil Nadu today.

The former judge has said that NGT can not interfere in policy decision of Tamil Nadu Government. In 1999, Tamil Nadu Government ordered closure of Sterlite, Supreme court over turned the order. In 2013 , Tamil Nadu Government ordered closure of Sterlite. NGT overturned it. Subsequently, Supreme Court allowed operation of the unit, after imposing fine . No one raised such “ policy decision versus Judiciary decision “ issue at that time. In recent time, judiciary has been questioning several policy decisions of the governments. No one has found fault with this and many have welcomed this. Why raise new objection now ?

It is easy to order closure of any industry by. the Government at any time due to one reason or the other. But, keeping it running by applying appropriate remedial measures is a challenging task, that competent Government should tackle.

N.S.Venkataraman
Director
Nandini Consultancy Centre
www.nandinichemical.com more  

View all 8 comments Below 8 comments
Sterlite Company has been in operation for over a decade and has been the backbone of Industrial activity of the Tuticorin town. Livelihood of thousands of families is dependant on this company's running. A full fledged office of TNPCB is also functioning in this town for so many years. They have been "visiting" the plant and its peripherals frequently and filing their reports (after enjoying the Company's hospitality). Why has this scare of Ecological Damage sprung up now..??.. What was TNPCB doing all along..??..In these days of "rising unemployment" levels, do we need thousands of additions to the growing list of unemployed in TN..??... Further, Sterlite must have pumped in thousands and thousands of Crores of their money into the setting up of this plant..!!.. Nobody can tell them to " WIND UP " and GO ELSEWHERE ", just like that..!!.. I JUST HOPE THAT THE COMPANY SITS WITH THE TN GOVT. AND THE UNION GOVT REPRESENTATIVES IN A COOL ATMOSPHERE AND FIND A SOLUTION AND.....RUN THE PLANT IN TUTICORIN...!! more  
Not surprised. Recent developments have clearly shown that judges are not above populism. Thankfully, NGT appears to be handling this sensitive issue in the best judicial manner possible; suggesting strong checks and balances to protect environment, while letting Sterlite operate. However, Govt of TN will most likely pander to populism and drag this right up to the Supreme Court. Until then, the future remains bleak for the people dependent on Sterlite more  
we have to see the track record of the former Judge's Educational qualifications, which school he studies, which college he studies, in which Law Associates, he worked etc. This would give a much better clear picture of this Judge and who, which forces are behind him. more  
If they have judged him for that post without looking at all these you said and more to see to be seen, then Not my lord my God only can save us.

By the by the professional code and deceipline more  
Any industry that deals with chemicals,metals and like are likely to result in pollution and contamination. That is the reason that we have Pollution Control Board It is their duty to suggest safe guard measures and ensure that they are implemented accordingly If not take remedial action If this is not accepted, there can be no industry that can function Similar industries are still functioning in India and we need to know as to what was there methods for pollution control and ensure that they are enabled in this industry in dispute. Generally when such industries are approved there must have been a rule to cordon of that area with in which no residential complex be allowed with in a radius of 10 miles This must have been the case for many of such industries when it was allowed to be setup But over a period this is violated with our officials and becomes problem Mr Parandhaman must fight with pollution control board and monitor instituting safety measures

When we have employment problems it is not wise to shut down industries just like that

Of late when we do not have a strong leaders, each and every one wants to become popular and raises issues They are not willing to give solution It is more of Politics that makes this as an issue more  
Credibility of Indian government officials is nil am planning to post my case in WikiLeaks about Indian administration more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • SAFETY

      it is very sad that the child has died. the CM GIVES 10 LAKHS,THE GOVT GIVES 10 LAKHS, HONBLE STALIN GIVES 10 LAKHS. THIS IS VERY BAD. THIS MONEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN GIVEN TO POOR CHILDREN FOR TH...

      By ADINARAYANAN SUNDARAM
      /
    • AIDMK having erotic dance performers in rallies

      This is a shame. As bye-election rallies get underway in Tamil Nadu’s Nanguneri and Vikravandi, the ruling party is pulling all the stops to attract crowds to its election rallies....

      By Reeta Kumar
      /
    • MR. MODI’S REFERENCE TO TAMIL SAYING IN U N SPEECH

      Prime Minister Modi did great honour to Tamil traditions and culture by quoting the Tamil scholar Poonkundranar who said several centuries back about the universal outlook of Tamil philosophy. Has ...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • WILL FOREIGN VISITS OF MINISTERS BRING INVESTMENT FROM ABROAD ?

      Several ministers of Tamil Nadu government are visiting foreign countries claiming that they are doing so to get project investments in Tamil Nadu. Further, it is said that the ministers are going ...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Corruption in Tamil Nadu in last 12 months: Inputs Sought

      LocalCircles has just embarked on its annual India Corruption Survey. As we conduct this survey, we wanted to check what has been your experience in the last 12 months (Sep 2018 - Aug 2019) in rega...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • What Tamil Nadu students think on three language formula in schools ?

      Nandini Voice For The Deprived , a Chennai based not for profit organisation, organised essay competition for college and school students in Tamil Nadu on the following subject . &l...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • krishna water for chennai

      this post is regarding krishna water to chennai.there has been heavy rain in maharashtra and all the dams have been filled and excess water has been released.even the dams of karnataka and AP shoul...

      By Vilas Salunkhe
      /
    • Chennai water coverage by NPR

      One of Chennai's biggest reservoirs, Chembarambakkam Lake, is now a cracked, windswept mud flat. There are swarms of insects as big as hummingbirds, stray goats nibbling at dust-coated shrubs and w...

      By Reeta Kumar
      /
    • Lots of water arriving

      Lots of water has reached the city today at around 2 pm today as a train with 50 tank wagons (BTPN), with 50,000 litres of water in each, left Jolarpettai at 7.20 am.

      By Reeta Kumar
      /
    • IS IT JUSTIFIABLE TO GIVE AWAY CENTRAL GOVERNMENT JOBS IN T.N. TO CITIZENS OF OTHER STATES :

      I have attached a Video in Tamil , if you understand kindly respond to the problems and step motherly treatment meted out to the Job Seekers in Tamil nadu . I have also seen in the Toll ...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
    • Dig borewells in Tamil Nadu

      With Tamil Nadu going through severe drought, the feasibility of digging borewells in vacant lands should be taken up on war footing. An opportunity is given below as an example. ...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)