WHY INTERVIEW FOR ANNA UNIVERSITY VICE CHANCELLOR SELECTION ?

It is reported that ten candidates including five professors from Anna University and two from IIT madras have been shortlisted and would be called for an interview on August,9, 2021, for selecting the Vice chancellor of Anna University.

All the candidates are senior academicians with long track record.Calling them for interview and selecting one and rejecting others inevitably would lead to a feeling of humiliation amongst the “rejected “ candidates. Obviously, the “rejected” candidates would be frustrated and would wonder as to what their students would think about them and how society would rate their academic track record in future.

It is widely rumoured that several posts of Vice Chancellors in Tamil Nadu universities have been filled in the past on the basis of recommendations from politicians in power. A few of the Vice chancellors have also faced charges of corruption and nepotism, largely due to political connections. All in all, many people have started wondering whether Vice Chancellors are political appointments.

To avoid such situation in future , it is necessary that selection must be decided on fixed criteria , which should be based on qualification and track record only. On the other hand, when the selections are made on the basis of interview, it is quite possible that there could be selection made on the basis of whimsical views of the panel members , who conduct the interview and who may be prejudiced for whatever reasons.

It is particularly surprising that a retired IAS officer is one of the members of the interview committee, who has no academic track record.

The most desirable method of selecting a Vice Chancellor is that a selection panel consisting of former Vice chancellors who have not faced any charges should study the track record of the candidates and obtain the details of their vision for the future growth of the university , provided in their written statements.

It is absolutely necessary that a face to face interview should be avoided, which inevitably make the panel members much “bigger” than those seeking Vice Chancellor post. In practice, it is possible that the person seeking the Vice Chancellor’s post may be “bigger” in credentials than the panel members.

The sad episode with regard to the earlier Vice Chancellor M.K.Surappa is a case study of how even a person with a strong academic record could be humiliated by politicians and bureaucrats.

No wonder that the post of Vice Chancellors in Tamil Nadu universities do not command the type of public esteem that the former Vice chancellor of Madras University Dr A.L. Mudaliar commanded. He served as Vice Chancellor of Madras University for several years and brought great glory to the post, which have now been lost in Tamil Nadu.

The selection of the Vice Chancellors by conducting interview and based on views of the panel members is an arbitrary method of selection and do not inspire confidence that the selection has been made in a fair manner.

N.S.Venkataraman
Trustee
Nandini voice for The Deprived more  

View all 9 comments Below 9 comments
Well! Clearly defined skills & qualification should be criteria fir selection, professors who apply should be meeting 90%, then a panel of 5 academically qualified includes past VC from other states has interactions with short listed 10 candidates - based on weightage provided for each criteria the Chancellor takes the decision & submits to govt with a detailed note why a particular candidate was selected. This transparent process helps in selection of VC. more  
Any interview, short comings are bound to be there. Then how to go about. Unless selection committee is not biased and transparent, it is next to impossible to ensure fair selection. more  
Totally agree with NSV views more  
It should be transparent. more  
It is not appropriate to think that the rejected Candidates will be dejected and feel humiliated in front of their students. As a Learned gentlemen they should accept the truth and their position in the Interview. Such discussion should be avoided nrespectfully. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Tamil loving politician and veshti

      Why our Tamil loving politicians do not wear Tamil Nadu attire ( veshti ) when they go abroad and instead use western dress ? N.S.Venkataraman Nandini Voice for The Deprived

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • CHIEF MINISTER AS CHANCELLOR !

      The resolution passed by Tamil Nadu Assembly to withdraw the powers of Governor to act as Chancellor of the Universities and probably to make the Chief Minister as the Chancellor would certainly l...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • tamilnadu budget

      the t n finance minister has laid down a road map for reducing the deficit.every public utitlity co.in the country is facing losses inspite of the fact that the during mr modi's first govt.in 2014,...

      By Suresh Dasarathy
      /
    • The Hindu Business Line newspaper

      Increasingly finding that this news paper favours industry lobbyists and brands. Have stopped our subscription from today. Love to hear from everyone what they think of this paper and if they still...

      By Reeta Kumar
      /
    • Let not Tamil Nadu government oppose neutrino project

      It is unfortunate that present Tamil Nadu government has said that neutrino project should not be implemented in Tamil Nadu. Several very important projects in Tamil Nadu have been given...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • NEET controversy

      without going into the merits or demerits of NEET,it is to be observed that the governor had returned the bill citing that the scrapping of NEET in tamilnadu is against the interest of the students...

      By Suresh Dasarathy
      /
    • WHY DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN JALLIKATTU AND TEMPLE ENTRY

      Jallikattu is permitted if the players get vaccinated twice and audience get vaccinated two times. Why not put the same conditions for temple entry with devotees permitted if they would get vac...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • NEET AND TAMIL NADU GOVERNOR

      Tamil Nadu government and some political parties have accused Tamil Nadu governor for not forwarding the resolution by the assembly demanding repeal of NEET examination in Tamil Nadu , to the Presi...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • T N Government's bad decision on appointment of vice chancellors

      It is shocking to know that Tamil Nadu government has decided to directly appoint the Vice Chancellors of universities in Tamil Nadu, giving up the present procedure of Governor (Chancellor) appo...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • THERE HAS BEEN SOME HUE AND CRY ABOUT THE ACTIVITIES OF THE PRESENT HINDU RELIGIOUS AND CHARITABLE

      ENDOWMENTS DEPARTMENT: There is one Area wherein they have been restoring the Lands back to the Temples, or getting the rightful share of Rentals, which was overtly being exploited by Pr...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
    • Is Tamil Nadu government secular ?

      A government can be considered secular, if it would not interfere in religious matters and treat all religions on par. Based on this definition, can we consider the present Tamil Nadu government as...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
Share
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)