New Housing Society's Mafia action

Hi, I have a shop in Mumbai in a new building which after quite a long period of time could manage to form the Society. However, without forming Society the Adhoc committee had been charging the maintenance and I had been paying. Subsequently the Committee members changed, bank accounts also changed without any notice or info. So stopped paying rent. After more than a year or so, the Committee members stopped to allow the usage of toilet to the shop owners. The Committee members were not available to even talk. Finally, recently when they formed the society, they are asking for the maintenance since past few years although property tax and other similar taxes were paid by the show owners themselves. Now, since Society has got registered, the members are threatening to not to issue the Share Certificates which is crucial for everyone. Is it legal to ask for past period without providing any service. Appreciate if can get right guidance to take action because I was genuinely willing to pay but never got any response from the committee members and never received any kind of service. So now I am not willing to pay for the past. Please advise. more  

I agree with Anil Sharma. No need to pay for the past when the society was not in existence more  
Never initiate action at the impotent Registrar's office. Let the other side i.e. the Managing Committee approach him. Nothing is going to happen if you do not pay up. Respond only when required to. Remember this principle.

Quote
from the manual published by the government:
Housing Society is such type of society where the members of the society stay with their family day and night in each others’ close contact/company. This type of close contact is not found in any other type of society. Therefore it is experienced that the complaints of Housing societies arise out of human nature, behaviour, egoism, anger, greed etc. Therefore provisions made in laws, bye-laws are not sufficient to solve their problems but knowledge of human nature, behavior is necessary.
While taking decisions of day to day working of the Co-operative Society, it is necessary to take decision as per co-operative law, rules and similarly provisions in the bye laws. However while applying meaning in that regard, and while doing development work on the society level, different decisions was taken in various societies and thereby complaints arise.
Unquote

Quote
72. FINAL AUTHORITY OF SOCIETY.
Subject to the provisions in this Act and the rules, the final authority of authority every society shall vest in the general body of members in general meeting, summoned in such a manner as may be specified in the bye-laws.
Unquote

If there is any office which is corrupt, not necessarily only by money, it is the Registrar's, right up to the top. The Managing Committee prevails there. The MCS Act is such. The gravest of grave defaults of the Managing Committee are ignored by the Registrar.

Neither the Registrar nor the Govt. wants to take any responsibility for smooth functioning of any society according to the law laid down by itself. This law is used only to harass the individual flat owner / shop owner, who does not have the resources nor the time to fight this corrupt organisation. The common pool of contributions is held by the society from which it can spend, not the member.

Keep your correspondence perfect. Be assured, nothing will happen. Truth does not prevail there. This is my experience for the last decade. more  
Correct please. more  
Society can charge only after it was formed. All the past payments made, the record thereof and the bank accounts balance need to be transferred to the new society formed. They can then charge you only for the interim period in which the payments were not made / collected. They have to prepare the account statements accordingly. If you have borne some expenses on behalf of the society then those can be deducted. All these things need to be discussed.
If they are not ready to discuss then approach the registrar and lodge a complaint. Also send a registered letter to the society of your concerns with a cc to registrar.
Always keep a written record of all the communication with the society. more  
Approach Registrar of Societies. It had power to decide the dispute. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Request your help and wealth of knowledge on Legal Matters

      I filed a SLP in the year 2015 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India against at Criminal Petition which was against me. The SLP was filed by me online as party in person. I was infor...

      By Anil Kumar Singh
      /
    • Received a fake INR 2000 Currency from HDFC Bank ATM

      Dear All, after shifting to Mumbai temporarily in March, I received a fake INR 2000 currency note from an HDFC bank ATM in the Govandi area in Mumbai on May 1, 2019. I realized about it after 3-4 ...

      By Kunwar Rajeev Singh
      /
    • M/s.Shopclues.com CEO issued a NBW by Secunderabad Criminal Courts for offences Punishable U/s.420

      Dear Readers and leagal experts, A case has been filed in the local magistrates court at Secunderabad against M/s.Shopclues.Com for offences punishable under section 420 for cheating. I had p...

      By Anil Kumar Singh
      /
    • can a appeal be file again against order of if the case is dismissed again by Hon'ble Supreme court?

      Sir, A Complaint case was filed by a women against an advocate praticing at Tis Hazari court in 2015 after 21 months of the incident happened in 2013. Police filed FIR and advocate filed a Complain...

      By Iqbal Singh
      /
    • Indian Legal System

      Need urgent advise from all my respected legal eagle friends in this group regarding the following: 1) Can a judge of the HC admit a case simply on the basis of it being a matter of an e...

      By VIKAS BHAKRI
      /
    • Motor Insurance Renewal w/o my knowledge by new owner under my name

      I sold my car in Jan 2017 to a dealership in Noida Sector-8 for an exchange value when buying a new vehicle. After 2.9 years of this transaction, I received a motor insurance certificate at my addr...

      By Akhil P Walia
      /
    • Need help/Suggestion

      I am buying a running restaurant from individual. Paying him a heavy refundable deposit and also a small amount every month as royalty for the business. Shop owner is different with whom I will do ...

      By Ashutosh Jajodia
      /
    • Consumer protection

      Rs. 875/- paid to Amazon.pay for Airtel postpaid bill on 08th sept.2019 has not been credited by Biller resulting in default requiring another payment if Rs.875/- ?? Amazon need to compensate ...

      By Surrender Singal
      /
    • Advocate help required in NCDRC against builder jaypee.

      Advocate required for fighting case in NCDRC against jaypee builder on behalf of association for a very clear case of deficiency in service and extortion in the name of maintenance charges. We have...

      By Pravesh Saini
      /
    • Re registration of 15+ years old vehicles

      What is the legal position on re registration of more than 15 years old vehicles. Is it compulsory to re register the vehicle after 15 years in case there is no plan to use it? If the veh...

      By Mustafa P V
      /
    • Legal Advice on Property BuyBack Agreement & Mou

      Hi, Would anyone here will be able to help with the draft or guidance on property buyback agreement & mou offered by a real estate developer to an investor. Thanks

      By Anonymous Circle member
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)