SEBI-What is Wrong ?

Like the Income Tax, where there are slabs for different incomes, SEBI never thought on similar lines.

Small investors of 20-30 years ago, who then had bought one or two tradable lots of listed shares and had kept them in joint names with one’s spouse, son, daughter (as the case may be), for safety purpose, is now a senior citizen facing problem even for opening Demat account in the names in which the shares stand.

SEBI does NOT distinguish between small investors with one-two tradable lots in physical condition and those who hold a sizable percentage of stocks.

Because, the dividend gets credited into the First Holder’s name, SEBI should have allowed dematerialization of physical shares held in joint names to the Demat account in the first holder’s name, provided that the initial holding when bought, was one or two tradable lots (which might have increased later due to Bonus shares)

But then…. SEBI is a regulator with a Mindset, which does NOT understand the common citizen. So, it shall never be done, because, what about the stocks and dividends so transferred to IEPF, because this facility was NOT allowed?

In case SEBI wishes to solve the problem, there is one solution, though :

SEBI should ask all those companies, who have transferred either shares, or dividend or both to IEPF, to re-assess the situation, help the conversion to first holder’s name, as well as to provide any other help required, so that the legal owners do NOT suffer.

Unless the companies are given the responsibility, it could never be done, as the employee look for some kick-back and delay the matter on purpose. Unfortunately, such persons get SEBI’s support for the reasons known only to SEBI. more  

Small investors of 40-50 years ago, who then had bought shares on assurance of our political / Economic / Stock Exchange experts that this investment not only will give decent returns but will help in nation building.

Now keeping future in mind we kept shares in joint names with one’s spouse, son, daughter (as the case may be), for safety purpose, is now a senior citizen facing problem even for opening Demat account in the names in which the shares stand.

Now we are facing multiple problems such as --

1] How to get shares demated unless SEBI modifies provision i.e. should allow dematerialisation of physical shares held in joint names to the Demat account in the first holder’s name.

2] SEBI's web should contain all company's name who at any time was in trade list of any stock exchange whether [ then ] Bombay / Calcutta / Delhi /Madras etc. etc. besides other names related / connected to this original co. which arose due to any sort of action i.e. merger / demerger / consolidation etc. so that any investor writing any name after visiting that page should get present details along-with old details of that co. [ along with who was then registrar and who is presently ]

This web page should be developed in such manner which do not force seniors to feel waste of time - what I mean simple as this will help investors to pursue the case effectively otherwise we are not in a position to keep track of old investments.

This web page should also contain name of those co. which vanished OR liquidated

3]Due to age and passage of time signatures is bound to differ but certainly style,manner,flow and language will match. Hence there should be certain relaxation in these type of cases.

4] Due to unavailability of physical shares SEBI should make mandatory for co. to accept affidavit on 10/- stamp paper and rest exercises should be on plain paper besides FIR should be waived and advt. if necessary then it's exp. should be borne by co.

Now why I insist for above please note seniors have no so much energy to comply all - as every step requires frequent visit besides expenses [ please note those who have retired from pvt. firms do not have pension hence they have little source of income ]. Secondly 10/- stamp paper carries same weight as 500/- stamp paper.

3] Further please note that after paying all due taxes every year besides controlling our so many needs we invested in shares ignoring other investment such as Land / Gold / FD etc. keeping in mind nation building but gradually government started imposing tax on its' income [income arises due to long term share investment ] then after repeated representation small investors got relief not in all cases but over dividend income and LTCG which again last year got disturbed
though I have suggested method which will garner not only more income but will also provide relief to genuine long term investors.

In view of above if we try unitedly then only we can expect relief.

G D Binani
7976870397 / 9829129011 more  
Sr.ctzn,s who hold a couple of shares for decades are now compelled to go for Demat. Demat is not done that easily.Even after all these struggles , no trading. The only main reason is upon demise the nominee or the 2nd holder can have it transferred easily. Now the Bankers are charging for keeping in Demat. The SEBI should to to redress the issues for such ctzn's. Maybe SEBI can have an undertaking for non-sale during their life time. Else the maintanance charges seems a penalty. more  
Small investors are basically buying shares as investment to future and not like business to trade , buy and earn quick money. Bulk buyers may be of some other category. It is necessary that small investors are given basic benefits and concession for investing and also some incentives for future trading more  
This is a practical problem.To over come this ,I was forced to open two new Demat a/c and convert physical shares in to electronic mode. Even the share Transfer Agency harass for "signature not matching ", and one has to fulfill their requirements. more  

Related Posts

    • Income tax return

      Yes. The people going abroad faces this issue. This need to be solved by government. Previously we used to get form 16 and TDS return from banks maximum by second week of may. I do not understand w...

      By Hasmukh Sangani
    • Don’t leave your family with these 3 things post death

      Confusion. After you are gone, your next of kin will spend the most amount of time figuring out issues linked to money. Bank accounts, fixed deposits, pension, Public Provident Fund, post office de...

      By Aditi Jain
    • Banks & Senior Citizens

      Many Banks have separate “Senior Citizen Savings account” for the Senior Citizen. Great. My Question : If the banks have details of PAN and Aadhar of each of the account holder, both o...

      By Mangesh Anaokar
    • डीमेट समस्या

      हमें पिछले हर समय पर हमारे राजनीतिक / आर्थिक / स्टॉक एक्सचेंज विशेषज्ञों ने यही समझाया की शेयरों में निवेश न केवल अच्छा रिटर्न देगा बल्कि राष्ट्र निर्माण में मदद करेगा। उनकी सलाह को ध्यान में रख...

      By G D Binani
    • Dematerialisation Problems

      Are All problems for dematerialization extremely simple and investors are fools, not to understand the procedures…. NO. Are All problems for dematerialization of Physical shares related onl...

      By Mangesh Anaokar
    • Dematerialisation of physical shares

      The Securities Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on June 8, 2018 issued a new set of amendments under the Sebi Regulations 2018. This amendment, starting April 1, 2019, will not allow investors holdin...

      By Mohit Jain
    • Demat share conversion survey

      Looks like localcircles has taken this up on our request. Many many thanks. I am confident this will atleast be considered for extension now.

      By Aditi Jain
    • फ़िज़िकल शेयर

      शेयर बाजार में निवेश करने वाले लाखों निवेशकों के पास अभी फिजिकल फॉर्म में ही कंपनियों के शेयर पड़े हैं. इस समय देश में करीब 5.30 लाख करोड़ रुपये के शेयर फिजिकल फॉर्म में हैं. फिजिकल फॉर्म में पड़े ...

      By Satvik Singh
    • Converting paper shares to demat

      A request to SEBI on behalf of many senior people who are holding paper shares in companies. Many are still struggling to them converted into demat shares as companies not responding in some cases....

      By Aditi Jain
    • Year end Tax Saving info and tips...

      For those below age 60, the income up to Rs 2.5 lakh is exempted from income tax. Thereafter, income between Rs 2,50,001 and Rs 5,00,00 is taxed at 5 per cent. On income between Rs 5,00,001 and Rs ...

      By Aditi Jain
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)