LC your cant charge above MRP movement is working

Great case study circles. Here in hyderabad meridian restaurant charged a consumer 10 rs over MRP and had to pay a fine of INR 25000. All legal metrology controllers must wake up to implement this asap

Consumer dispute forum has directed the Meridian Restaurant, Punjagutta, to pay Rs. 25,000 as compensation to a customer for charging Rs 10 extra for a water bottle.

Complaint Mohammed Mohsin resident of Balanagar on July 13, 2019, went to Meridian Restaurant for supper. However, the restaurant charged Rs.10 extra on Kinley Water bottle.

The complainant alleged that instead of Rs.20 MRP, the opposite party collected Rs.30. He alleged that the attitude of the employees was very rude.

The complainant approached the Commission claiming compensation and costs.

The restaurant however denied all the allegations. The opposite party submitted that as per the judgment of Apex Court in "The Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Association of India Vs Union of India and others in civil appeal No.21790/2017, they are entitled to collect the excess amount".

The opposite party further submitted that there is no deficiency on their part and prayed to dismiss the complaint.

After examining the documents and evidence provided by both the parties, the forum observed that, the opposite party who admitted the collection of excess amount of Rs.10 on M.R.P. defended the same by relying on Apex Court Judgment.

The forum said that para 15 of Apex Court Judgment reads

"3. Applicability of chapter: - The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to:

a) Packages of commodities containing a quantity of more than 25 kg or 25 liters excluding cement and fertilizer sold in bags up to 50 kg and,

b) Packaged commodities meant for industrial consumers or institutional consumers. Explanation: - For the purpose of this rule: -

(i) "Institutional consumer" means the institution who buy packaged commodities directly from the manufacturer for use by that institution".

"The opposite party relies on the above judgment and did not file any proof to show that it will come under the purview of institutional consumer. Moreover, the opposite party also failed to establish that it purchased the commodity i.e., Kinley mineral water bottle directly from the manufacturer" said the forum.

The forum also added in the absence of any clarification as observed by the apex court they cannot interpret the apex court judgment in the particular case in hand. "We are under the considered view that the order of the apex court was misinterpreted as per their convenience and as such the point is answered accordingly in favor of the complainant," said the forum.

The forum ordered the restaurant to refund Rs.10 collected from the complainant together with interest at 12 percent from 13 July 2019 till the date of realization. The forum also asked to pay an amount of Rs.20,000 towards compensation for causing inconvenience and mental agony to the complainant and pay Rs.5000 towards costs of litigation. more  

View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
Local Circle is doing their bit, but enforcement of MRP in country should be imposed. more  
Lets see.

Hotels provide service in addition to water bottle - chair in a nice restaurant, air conditioning, waiter to bring the bottle to the table, etc etc.
Can all this be offered for Rs. 20?

MRP should not apply in hotel/restaurant premises, where there is an element of service and other addons (nowadays it is expensive to sanitize the seating).

MRP is OK if one is buying from a shop to take away and consume elsewhere.

What if hotels refuse to serve by 'bottle' and only serve by 'glass'?

Consumers have the option not to buy at the price on the menu or not to visit a hotel/restaurant if it is beyond their means.

Otherwise even beggars would visit 5 Star properties 'to buy water bottle at Rs. 20 and use their toilets, airconditioned lounge etc

Consumer rights should be reasonable.

Just my thoughts.

Would like to see a discussion on Consumer Responsibilities and Duties. more  
Very interesting case. Thanks for posting.

Can you give the details of the location of the commission and case/ruling number? more  
Which commission was approached by the complainant Md. Mohsin ? more  
When customer goes to a 5 Star Hotel will he expect to pay Rs. 20 for a bottle of water? more  
Unfortunately that is the mind set we all have and don't complain. Instead, like Mr. Mohsin, we should complain if any rule is not followed whether it is 5 star hotel or any other hotel more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Oxymeter loot by websites and shops

      See attached classic example of how sellers have been profiteering from consumers. Wake up call legal metrology controllers. If u are still taking salaries, then u must act.

      By Asha Rathi
      /
    • MRP of Remdesivir reduced

      Thanks to all the good efforts of your circles on remdesivir black marketing menace and overcharging, GOI has intervened Nd MRP of Remdesivir has been lowered. Availability though is a different ma...

      By Sarika Bansal
      /
    • Punishment for charging over MRP

      If a trader has charged me above MRP and I have receipt and packaging to prove the same, what is the process to file complaint and what is the penalty/punishment he will face?

      By Konkona Sen
      /
    • UNFAIR PRACTICE OF INFLATED MRP PRINTED ON GENERIC MEDICINE

      The government of India & the Ministery Of Health needs to stop the malpractice of printing inflated MRP on generic medicine. A generic medicine that has an MRP of Rs.120. can be purchased from...

      By NAVNEET SARIN
      /
    • Fictitious MRP practice continues

      See attached product called special pillow cover packaged product with selling price of INR 699. For everyone’s reference I am sharing the label of the product which displays MRP o...

      By Sarika Bansal
      /
    • Nykaaa portal charging more than MRP

      Lot of women who order through portals like nykaa and myntra dont actually check receipt mrp and tags/label on product. See attached recent case with me. Mrp 160 charged 183. Problem is...

      By Gouri D
      /
    • Multiple Quantity price online is an issue

      See attached Printed MRP of 1 pen Rs. 400; So MRP of 3pens Rs.1200. Amazon seller onlinestationeryshop claims 3 pens' MRP Rs.1500, Post discount price 1380. Thus seller is charging Rs.180 more than...

      By Meeta Sinha
      /
    • Price Vs Quantity of Products

      Dear Learned Reader, Wishing everyone a very happy & prosperous New Year 2021. I wish to bring to your kind notice that after the breakout of Covid19 most of the manufacturer ...

      By Anoop Kishore Bhatnagar
      /
    • Flipkart sellers listing products above MRP

      See MRP of 179.50 listed as 278. Can such sellers who mislead consumers be booked by legal metrology?

      By Preeti Kumar
      /
    • Apple charging GST over MRP

      Apple website in India and its employees seem clueless about mrp and that gst cannot be charged above mrp. See attached mrp on invoice 4900 box 4500. Can legal metrology folks book them ...

      By Ankita Jain
      /
Share
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)