Start Up Policy Chainges by Harish of GT

The Startup policy needs a rethink and reboot to make it more effective and impact startups in a material way. The government should explore why the scheme is not making a direct impact on the lives of startups the way it was anticipated.
Startups, especially in the technology sector, are a key differentiator for India’s economic growth and prosperity. The ambitious Startup India policy was expected to make life easy for startups and help further encourage the young population to become entrepreneurs.

But the response to the policy, which was announced in January, has been lukewarm. As per news reports, about 400 applications were received by the interministerial board, of which 189 have been considered, 148 have been asked to submit proper documents and 10 rejected. Thirty have been asked to give additional information and only one has been approved. Clearly this is less than a drop in the ocean. Startups appear to find the process bureaucratic and cumbersome or do not see the benefit of registering for approval and benefits under the policy.

The policy needs to be tweaked in two areas to make it broad-based and impact the largest number of startups. Doing this will also improve the ease of doing business.

One of the biggest hurdles in India is the plethora of laws that companies have to deal with and even more daunting is the number of these laws with potential for inspections and harassment.
The startup policy, which is applicable to companies with revenue of up to Rs 25 crore and that are no more than five years old, permits self-certification and no inspection under nine laws in the area of labour and environment.
This is a real boon for companies as it enables them to focus on business and growth till they have achieved some scale and have the resources to comply. This benefit is available only to approved startups.

There are two changes required to broadbase this. The number of laws needs to be expanded to include other acts like the Factories Act, Shops and Establishments and Employees’ State Insurance Act.

This policy of self-certification under these laws should be applicable to all startups. The definition of a startup could be any business so long as it is incorporated as a company or LLP within the previous five years, has a turnover of less than Rs 25 crore and not promoted by any existing business group. There will obviously be a few bad apples who may misuse such a policy and the government needs to find other ways to deal with them.

There is a need to enable companies to close down when the business model fails or cash dries. While businesses and business models fail the entrepreneurs typically will want to try newer and different businesses.

We also know most successful global
entrepreneurs of today succeeded in their second or third attempt. Today closing a company requires getting noobjection certificates from multiple government departments confirming no dues and that typically takes 18 to 36 months of running around.

To resolve this the startup policy or the bankruptcy law could be modified so that all startups may be permitted to close down within 45-60 days through a simple process with a singlewindow approach. They need not necessarily declare the company or the founders bankrupt.

Some of the other measures like tax breaks and funding support (which is really not material because a company which is in startup stage is unlikely to make profits) can be restricted to those who come through the present process.

These suggestions, along with implementing the other elements of what has been promised so far, will enable India to achieve the goals the PM talked about when the policy was announced. more  

View all 7 comments Below 7 comments
There is no dearth of ideas but it seems the startups backed, supported and started by the kins and relatives of 'big sharks' in the industrial or service sector who have tremendous and well-established influence in the bureaucratic circles working in the departments dealing with various approvals, licenses and permissions required to set up a startup, only see the light of the day and become successful. I have not come across many success stories of the startups by 'a common man or woman' in India. Various loan and other assistance schemes started and run by various Ministries, etc. are misused by unscrupulous people. Genuine ones are not able to convert their ideas into reality! In any case, it is a very good and important subject for discussion and I am sure something bright will come out of the healthy discussion. more  
On certain points I agree with you Naina yet It is important to check the start ups as defaulters grow much higher by the time they start producing profits. Mr. Saikia is also right that we just do not care about the environment and overlook the environ-safety concerns practically in every field. more  
Naina,s right but I think self certification and no inspection for Environmental issues may spell doom because it,s an issue that concerns the well being of our very planet and there must be some kind of monitoring on this serious issue. more  
I am of the opinion that the start up policy be handled at cener level til the unit starts giving production . more  
I have been puzzled by new generation software based start ups signing deals in Billions (not even millions) in less than 1 to 2 years. This is concept to execution and revenue yielding stage. Manufacturing startups may take 3 to 5 years from concept (new design/ product). So just because PM Modi gave a call for START UP, it can only be small start ups (like TINY UNITS, not even SSIs) which can happen in less than 1 year.  Anyone trying big in short time, will also collapse immediately for not doing home work properly. So have patience, perseverance, passion (above all), permission (legal),and 4 P's of marketing Guru KOTLER= Price, Place, Product, Promotion. From: Naina Mittal To: Sent: Tuesday, 28 June 2016 7:47 PM Subject: New post "Start Up Policy Chainges ..." in [Start Up/Doing Business in India] more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • GST filing

      Still GST system is not 100 % user/official friendly. there are news that so much money (in lacs) collected by fraudulent GST bills. I am a GST registered vendor. The company turn over is almo...

      By Subramanian Venkataraman
    • Taxation Issues faced by Startups: Inputs Sought

      Many of you know how LocalCircles had worked with the Government in 2019 on resolution of angel tax issues under Section 56 (2)(viib) of the Income Tax act. Once again, the Government h...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Why no penalty an dprosecution for govt

      Now our IT portal has become sick being suffering babu virus or extortion virus. McA site never works on last days and people have to pay penalties for mistakes of govt. Now professionals are wasti...

    • Income Tax Return Filing Portal

      What about income tax return filing date? Any extension thereof? As of today, I am not able to file the return . Has any one else file the income tax return? Has Portal issue been solved? I have al...

      By Hasmukh Sangani
    • Grass root experience

      I have been doing and promoting small business for the last 30 years. The real problem is that the ministers and their secretaries don't have practical experience and they look for 5 trillion dolla...

    • Why do Ministers refrain from engaging with businesses

      I find it quite interesting that the ministers want to deal only with tata adani ambani and not the real msme and startups. Why is the msme minister (appointed this week Narayan Rane) his secretary...

      By Aditi Mitra
    • Why such mismanagement

      FICCI the industry association has written to Centre saying most of 40000 ventilators manufactured under PM Cares Fund last year are lying unused at government facilities. Mainly due to negligence ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Word of caution to Indian small entrepreneurs

      Friends this is Aditya from New Jersey. A friend of mine from Brazil recently lost 3 members of his family back home to Covid. The P1 variant is most dangerous of all and is now invading neighbors ...

      By Aditya Sharma
    • simplifying procedures for easy business

      none of the administrators who are lucky to get into govt seats have practical field experience and they are not aware of the strains of small entrepreneurs. They always imagine that any entrepren...

      By Subramanian Venkataraman
    • Some Traders evading gst

      I agree with the other post. Traders have a strike today against GST. Many traders basically are still selling supplies in cash and then sell the bill later to some other entity for a pr...

      By SN Mittal
    • Traders and their strike

      The traders of India are simply fooling the world and doing a strike on GST. I am sorry to say but 80% of even medium size traders jump on every opportunity to do buisness without receipt with comm...

      By Shikha Chhabra
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)