Staring at an abyss

This article is about my Uncle M, a man whom I love and respect very deeply. He is an entrepreneur, making a precision cutting tool for the leather industry for nearly four decades now, and has always held a large share of this small niche market. His company’s annual turnover is a few crore rupees, and it employs about 50 people, almost all blue-collar.
I have never heard of any labour unrest in his factory. What I have seen is a community that he takes care of. Long-time employees have got loans and built homes and given their children fine education. He has always been there for them in medical emergencies. Families of workers who died young have been given every form of help needed.
Throughout his business life, he has had to fight a corrupt inspector raj and tax terrorism. He has faced every problem that a hostile and greedy bureaucracy can pose to an entrepreneur who does not have political connections. Today, close to 80, his knees are giving way, but he can’t keep himself away from his beloved factory even for a day, though his son now runs the operations.

A week ago, he called me. For the first time in my life, I saw his spirit weakened. Faced with complex and ever-changing tax regulations, and the onslaught of cheap Chinese products, he seemed to be close to the end of his tether. His voice sounded different.
No, this article is not really about my Uncle M. It is about the hundreds of thousands of entrepreneurs like him who built honest businesses from scratch against all odds, who provide far more jobs than big companies (and possibly take far better care of their employees), and who form the very core of the Indian economy. They are never profiled in the media like our e-startup millennials, and possibly don’t even know what “venture capital" means. Many of them, like my uncle, also export to the developed world, even though they can hardly speak two grammatically correct sentences in English. But these are the people who move our gross domestic product (GDP), who shift our social indicators by skilling millions of people and raising them up the economic ladder.
Taken as a whole, these businessmen from unfashionable manufacturing industries contribute more to society than the biggies with their mandated corporate social responsibility budgets and slick public awareness campaigns. And right now, they are hurting more than at any time they can recall.

After that call from Uncle M, I spoke to some chartered accountants, people who know such entrepreneurs closely. Rarely have I seen such consensus of opinion. This is what I learnt.
The goods and services tax (GST) system in India is a complete mess. Its forms are very difficult to fill, especially for small businessmen, who have to hire people just to do this, thus adding to the costs. Plus, the forms keep changing, as do regulations, sowing confusion all around. Total digitization has created massive problems, from connectivity and tech-familiarity issues on the businessman side, and server crashes and software malfunctions on the government side. And, at any point in time, substantial working capital is stuck in the form of unpaid GST claims.
Meanwhile, the overall tax regime has turned increasingly nasty. Every taxman in the country is chasing unrealistically steep targets, so queries on returns filed are soaring. And, even after you get a message from the tax department that it is satisfied with your clarification, you may get another one saying, no, it has been “suo motorejected". The brunt of all this, of course, is borne by the small businessman.

Add to this, China. From the lathe machine to the agarbatti (incensestick), Chinese goods are killing Indian enterprises, especially at the small and micro level. Not signing the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership treaty was the right move, but that is just a small step. Vastly more needs to be done to help our entrepreneurs survive. We must fight this warhard with China.
The dominant talk in India is about job creation, but we should first be talking about saving existing jobs in the country. We should be talking about the 50 families dependent on my uncle, and the 50 families dependent on each of the hundreds of thousands of other businessmen like him—because businesses and factories are shutting down. And many businessmen are persisting only because, either they still haven’t entirely given up, or they cannot abandon the people who have trusted them for their livelihoods for so long.
By making these businessmen waste enormous time, energy and money on GST and other tax issues, and not moving fast to save them from drowning in the rising Chinese tide, the government is doing more than just damaging the economy; it is breaking the spirit of people who actually have their skin in the game called India.

These entrepreneurs form the bedrock of our economy, and give it a literal solidity. Their children may study business administration abroad, but they come back home and take charge of their factories. Now, many of them are being discouraged by their parents to return.
We have an extreme crisis on hand and time is running out fast. more  

View all 11 comments Below 11 comments
Modi governments' increasing dependency on corrupt, useless bureaucracy has ensured that things don't change but get worse & worse. Modi Govt. failure on multiple fronts & like Man Mohan Singh he doesn't realise that he will be soon thrown out by people whose patience is giving away. People laugh when he mentions "NEW INDIA"!!!!! more  
GST's purpose is noble. However the implementation is bad because the implementing govt. Agencies had created a complex structure without taking into account the practical problems. Even now let, the planning and implementation is to be handed over to entrepreneurs. Govt msy collect the tax and leave the monitoring to them. more  
An apt and succinct description which fits exactly on many of the entrepreneurs of 60s and 70s. They are Bhishmapitamas who have faced the corrupt Babu-Raj for their entire life and and facing the errant system of GST.
The main problem of the Revenue bureaucracy is that they take every one as an evader and they have to be trained to treat that honesty is the rule and exemption is evasion. more  
I think, only the illegal entrepreneurs will have the problem. If the business is running with proper care there is nothing to worry. Just guide him where to fill-in the details and its all done. No need to worry and blame the government. There may be some hardships, but they are temporary only. In long-run, I think, it will benefit everyone. It is not an easy to task to implement GST. Lot of oppositions .....but still we could do it. A sapling is planted and it will take time to give fruits. Corruption is like a cancer... it will take time to get it cure. more  
Mr Jain`s statement that GST is badly implemented and hurting industries is far from true. I have been running an SME for the last 28 years and Im very happy with the new tax regime. Earlier there were a plethora of taxes which used to add upto more than 30%. Getting modvat refund was extremely difficult. Now it has become far more simple. Manipulation by factory owners has become difficult and hence all this opposition and negative propaganda against it by CAs.
GST is one of the best things that has happened in the last four years. I can vouch that all honest businessmen are happy with this. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • GSt penalty killed me and my business since its inception

      i paid more than 1.5Lakh as penalty for late payment since GST Implementation. we can not afford for C A for filing my turn over last year was 23 lakh what profit one expect . am 47 years cant get ...

      By Anthony Raj
    • Corruption and Entrepreneurship - Issues

      Below are the key issues identified by you on corruption faced by entrepreneurs in India. Kindly review the same and share other specific areas where you have faced corruption as an entrepreneur/st...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • GST

      GST from the start is not user friendly as far as MSMEs are concerned. On one side low key MSMEs who can not afford auditors are fined for late filing returns and on otherside companies who employ ...

      By Subramanian Venkataraman
    • Is India turning anti foreign investment by Bloomberg

      In most places, government ministers would be happy to hear that someone intends to invest a billion dollars in their country. Not in today’s India. Late last week, Inc.’s Je...

      By Rajesh Suri
    • Banks want Bailouts

      Just like telecom companies, banks now have asked the government for funds to support the payments ecosystem now that they can no longer charge merchants a fee for using the Unified Payments Interf...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Anonymous Data of Consumers

      Very interesting survey by localcircles in economic times today. Businesses are split about sharing their customers anonymised data with Govt. I am curious who are willing to share? What if tomorro...

      By Shikha Chhabra
    • Fixing the economy steps via budget

      GDP is at 42-year low & markets at all-time high, banks flush with funds but not lending, farm income collapsjng while govt-spend on farm is up. Doing business rank is up but investment Is down...

      By Sujata Singh

      Well questioned the Amazon Chief by the Minister . This was not the situation earlier as India would always hesitate to Challenge . Earlier withdrawing / Post Poning y from RCEP [Regiona...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
    • Govt saying no to Investment yesterday

      The Govt yesterday looked down upon 1 Billion Amazon investment. China reaches $10000 per capita income. India is just around $2000/. That is the gap we need to bridge. Going by the cur...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • State of Indian Economy

      What last CEA is presenting seems like the economy is not in recession but depression. Can all of u look at these 4 charts and share inputs on why they are accurate or inaccurate. Please no anecdot...

      By Nikita Merchant
    • How Govt makes it difficult to do business

      Local administration gets a private company to make an app. No one knows about it. Then sends notices to pay 50000 to 8000 companies for not registering on the app. Attached.

      By Ajay Dutta
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)