NRIs and demonetisation - bikram vohra

I think this is articulated much better by Bikram Vohra ji then I could have.

Of all the absurd rules and regulations that have come out of this demonetisation exercise, the one on Monday about compelling NRIs to fill currency forms at the airport must rank unequivocally in first place. I had said there is roughly Rs 150 billion floating about the 30 million Indian diaspora at an average of Rs 5,000 per person kept to make it easier to reach home and have a little start-off spending money.

Clearly, these billions do not count. After exhausting the deadline of 30 December without even bringing up the issue, the government's new six-month extension up to June has been turned into a nightmare.
Imagine landing at the airport at 2 am, bleary-eyed and jet-lagged, family in tow, standing in line for immigration, then being united with your luggage and then going to Customs and asking for a form to fill, after which the officer will stamp it while you hang around in the queue. After he has counted your notes which must not exceed Rs 25,000 he will give you this piece of paper at his leisure… which could be hours.
Shudder at the thought of three Gulf flights landing at the same time.

Now, bringing back your legitimate money - allowed by law - has become a 'declaration at Customs' thing: That historical citadel where so many have fallen (and still fall) victim to the hostile and often unreasonable and whimsical invasion of their luggage and their peace of mind.
You will then go to the Reserve Bank of India with that piece of paper and stand in another queue at one of the specially earmarked branches in your city (not all of them are authorised to collect the currency), where after you have exhausted the whole day shoving your IDs over the counter and proving you were not involved in the Great Train Robbery and are ready to shoot yourself, you may get a chance to deposit the dead bodies of the Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes. RIP.
Who thought this up? It stinks of hubris and arrogance that you would make it so difficult to collect these sums indicating how flush you must be with funds. The government might as well put up a sign saying, "NRI deposits don't count, push off".
Which is exactly what people will do. They will push off. It is a psychological fact that people at airports want to get the hell out of there. They walk faster, they push and shove and lose all their manners just to jump the queues. This mental breakdown starts at the aircraft itself and is predicated to the scientific fact that most passengers are claustrophobic and actually suffer from a degree of a fear of flying. Hence, the need to get out fast.
In this state, why would we hang about at odd hours for such paltry sums of money. For a maximum of $400 and a mean average of $75 if that.They will simply throw that money away.
Not even the labourers who are easy prey and bullied into submission even by the police at Indian airports are going to waste their time being badly treated at Customs when they are already nervous about being hauled over the coals and intimidated to be relieved of their money. They cannot even fill their embarkation form, how are they going to explain that 'Maa ne teen saal pehle shagun ke liye do hazaar diye tha (my mother had given me Rs 2,000 three years ago for good luck)' to the bully in uniform.
Fine, you have so much unearthed wealth you can afford to overlook a few billions here and a few billions there, but what goes against the grain of common sense is that it just 'goes against the grain of common sense' and again makes one contemplate the seriousness of this initiative that the government will not make it easier to collect the white, pure, washed-in-detergent money that NRIs are bringing in.
To not want the money is a breathtaking conceit.
Stand in line at Customs to give back three or four notes before the sun comes up.
Are you kidding? more  

View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
Ji, NRIs live overseas. We have to spend USD1-2,000 per person to come & deposit our cash. We contribute a lot to Indian economy. We simple kept cash-in-hand, as it is convenient to use them upon landing - it is not black money. We like to come to India but not everyone can come often. You are tell us to throw our SBNs away. We keep some cash in India as it is not convenient to go to bank before flight to deposit, so we use it as and when we come. IT IS NOT BLACK MONEY. At least I can proof source of funds as I withdrew Rs5lkahs from my account and had some balance in hand. Why should we co-operate, tell the govt to cooperate & be flexible. more  
As for NRIs in North America, it is certainly not worth it to travel to India just for changing old notes. The airfare itself is several times the Rs25,000 that has been allowed to be exchanged. more  
I think paper work is okay that's why they can take care and make sure that black money not able to enter in the system again, but why do they are not corporating OCi and PIO holders to accept the same rules which is for NRIs. So far NRI and OCI/PIO does not treated differently expect few conditions like voting, govt jobs, agriculture land, but why for demonetisation this rules are completely different for NRIs vs Oci/PIO individuals. more  
I wonder why some of the NRI's are fighting so hard for this paltry sum of money. Why can't they realize how poor people here in India have stood in the queue for withdrawing rs 2000/- from ATM. Why they are so much concerned in filling the form at the custom and declaring how much cash they are carrying? It is well known now how some of the Indians have converted their black money into white by asking others poor workers to deposit cash in their account in lakhs and taking their ATM cards with PIN with them as security? This is apprehended by the Govt that some people can take advantage of giving this extension to NRI's and if they are not asked to declare at the custom while landing that they had actually carried the cash with them abroad, what is the guarantee that they will not deposit cash kept with hoarders of black money with them in India or in lockers since they knew that Govt is going to give extension to NRI's for depositing cash.? Putting this condition of declaring the currency at customs was another master stroke by RBI against such mal practices going on in the country. I hope, NRI's will cooperate on this. I myself had been NRI for more than 30 years and very well aware of how much cash is required to be carried with them while going abroad to meet some contingencies while they land in India on vacation etc. more  
Asha Rathi has made an exhausting analysis. As NRI, I have had no problem depositing money from old currency by 30/12, and my has not asked for evidence from airport customs stamp copy, as I have evidence of when I withdrew 1 lac Inr in last 3 yrs. HDFC & Citi banks have assisted. Try them to reduce any worries, as all demolition. Is to find illegal funds. I hope I have given hope more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Seeking help with the Indian Visa

      Dear External Affairs Minister Mrs. Swaraj We appeal to your good nature. I am an Indian-born US Citizen and almost all of my extended family is in India. I am married to a Ka...

      By Anurag Kabra
    • Dear Members, I am a NRI, until now did not opened any NRI bank account, all of my earning send to India to my father account for saving. Kindly advise how it will consider legally, the savings are...

      By Mohamed Jafar Ali Ismail Mian
    • Cousin with Cash

      My cousin in chicago is visiting india this week and he has 24500 in old cash, landing in chennai. Where should she be going to exchange the money?

      By Mukta Somani
    • Ambassadors in India and abroad

      I have a suggestion. Can local circles or ministry of external affairs please invite all ambasaddors of foreign countries or their offices and india's ambassadors in foreign countries to this circl...

      By Laxmi Jindal
    • OCI & old currency notes

      Just found out today that I am unable to change my old Rupee currency as a OCI card holder. Only NRI are allowed to do this and i thought I was same as a NRI. In future will have to think seri...

      By Mohinder Singh

      wrote the below appeal to RBI : From: <> Date: Sat, Jan 28, 2017 at 7:20 PM Subject: NRI CLARIFICATION Pleas...

      By Mayur Vora

      We are coming to Mumbai on 1st Feb to go to RBI to deposit Old Notes. SEEK CLARIFICATIONS My parents were from India. I was born in India but brought to Singapore when I was 3 month...

      By Mayur Vora

      I am a Singapore citizen. I am holding an OCI (converted from PIO by law). According to my bank I am a NRI. So I need confirmation that I can deposit my old notes to RBI, as under NRI rules. C...

      By Mayur Vora
    • Rs25,000 only

      Rs25,000 allowed by NRI to bring into India is just too little. It should be at least 1lakh. This is the amount usually in hand. Why, becuase 1lakh in India for NrIs fly off our wallet like a bulle...

      By Mayur Vora
    • NRIS in fix

      There are some new rules now where NRIs before they can deposit their money need clearance from custome officials at airport. This is ridculous. If someone has 60000 of gifts money in a ...

      By Asha Rathi
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)