MSP cannot continue

Real growth happen when every corner grow up. A high rise building and its occupants may never lead comfortable peaceful life near slum area in which occupants are hardly availing minimum basic amenities. Every thing is possible but needs selfless thinking & dedication. more  

Rich Preview Image
MSP cannot continue
There is a good write up in Financial Express today (below) on why MSP can no longer continue. It will be a mistake for the Govt to yield to farmers demands. It will make India bankrupt in the medium to long term. Can polls be done in our circle to get public pulse on the issue. CNN news did an internal survey last week which was one sided (their own COI) and garbaged by activists and other media. LocalCircles has the credibility. It should do the poll and bring out reality. Give due representation to farmers also. One of the suggestions made to get Punjab’s agitating farmers to the negotiating table is that the government give a written assurance – presumably, this will be part of some law – to farmers that their crops will be procured at the MSP. It is not clear if this will get the farmers to call off their four-week-old gherao of the capital, but on the face of it, the proposal seems a reasonable one. After all, if the government is, year after year, announcing an MSP for 23 crops, it might as well promise to ensure farmers get this amount; why else is an MSP announced? This is an argument several Congress leaders have been making for a long time, as have various farm leaders, and one variant of this is that all below-MSP trade be made illegal. The problem lies in the fact that MSP is a historical hypocrisy since, apart from a few crops in a few states, no farmer gets MSP even today; if you include cotton and sugarcane as well, less than 10% of all farmers get their crops procured by government agencies, the rest take their chances in various mandis. Every politician knows this, but everyone keeps up the charade; presumably, the Modi government also went along for fear of upsetting the applecart except that, with the demand that a legal assurance be given for MSP procurement, it is in danger of tripping up badly. That should be a lesson for all politicians. In case the MSP is guaranteed, and that will have to be for all crops and across the country – and once this is given, those growing other crops like fruits and vegetables will also demand MSP – the impact will be huge. The impact will differ from crop to crop, and even mandi to mandi, but given the difference between mandi prices and MSPs range between 20 and 50%, the cost to the government can run into several lakh crore rupees every year. Since the government will probably pay this in the form of gap-payments to private traders who will buy the crops, the cost can go up even more. Once traders know they will get more money if the mandi price goes down, they will create fictitious trades to do this. In other words, this will bring back the waste/theft that dogged government spending in the years before Aadhaar-based checks were introduced. This money, whether or not the states share the costs with the Centre, can only come from saving elsewhere; it is likely that, with subsidies rising dramatically, government investment in the agriculture sector on creating fresh irrigation facilities, for instance, will take a beating. To the extent consumers are willing to pay more, this will lead to increased costs for consumers; to the extent consumers don’t buy the crops, this will hurt trade. But the impact could be a lot more. Once MSPs rise above global prices, as has happened for wheat, this means export demand will dry up completely; when procurement prices of items like cotton are raised too much, this will also hit exports of processed goods like readymade garments or textiles. Excess stocks of wheat and rice that FCI is forced to carry even today due to open-ended procurement in a few states are worth around Rs 150,000 crore today; this will rise dramatically when other crops – and other states – are to be added to the list where compulsory procurement has to be undertaken. Presumably, that is why the government is trying to avoid giving farmers an assurance on compulsory MSP-linked procurement or gap-payments. The lesson here is clear: when reforms are put off for too long, and this applies to the APMC reforms of the Modi government as well, they come back to bite you.
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Vaccination means Masks not needed - Indian Leaders

      Many Indian leaders are setting a very wrong example for the public by not wearing masks in meetings that are held indoors. Attached are some of the leaders like health ministers petroleum minister...

      By Shikha Chhabra
      /
    • State Tourism Industry: Inputs on Issues

      State Tourism in India if organized effectively can be a huge revenue and employment generator. However, due to limited understanding, no bench marking, poor processes, lots of corruption, huge VIP...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Mask and Social Distancing Compliance falls going into Festive Season

      Thanks to all of you who participated in the recent Mask and Social Distancing Compliance Survey. Below is the link to the survey report:

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Wake up FSSAI

      The U.S. FDA yday gave restaurant chains and packaged food companies a goal of reducing sodium levels by an average of 12% - part of its attempt to clamp down on preventable health issues like high...

      By Radhika Maheshwari
      /
    • Remdesivir maker was raking in black money

      Income tax dept raided hetero pharmaceuticals in hyderabad the maker of remdesivir. They found the attached (142 crores of black money) Get this last year LocalCircles had raised issue o...

      By Sarika Bansal
      /
    • Tomato and Onion Prices

      Last year LocalCircles took up the issue of price rise when per kg price of tomato hit 60 and onion hit 25. This year tomato is 75 and onion is 50. Kindly survey what people are paying and tell the...

      By RN Chopra
      /
    • Suicidal act by people and Mumbai airport managers

      Every member must carefully carefully see these images of Munbai airport this morning. People here have lost it and I have a feeling every airport will soon be looking like this. And if this contin...

      By Aditi Gupta
      /
    • Long Covid Survey

      Yesterday the WHO has defined what long covid is and attached are the details and summary in news paper. I suggest the best use of localcircles is sharing of experience. Can we all share...

      By Sanjana Agarwal
      /
    • Rising Prices of Fruits and Veggies

      Friends, Arjun here from Lucknow. See attached how prices are rising as festival time is coming. Please share experience in your town. Are prices rising there too for fruits t...

      By Arjun Singh
      /
    • Online Gaming must be banned in all states

      I am just super super thrilled to share that the efforts of LocalCircles have yielded results in Karnataka and these online games involving money including likes of fantasy cricket and sports have ...

      By SN Mittal
      /
    • About 7 crore Indians are currently hesitant to take the vaccine

      Thanks to each of you who participated in the last Covid vaccine hesitancy survey. Below is the study reportThe Vac...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
Share
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)