Modi and Rajnath Singh are not just rivals, but adversaries - TOI

If Aditya Sinha knows what he is writing, Modi ji and Rajnath Singh should really find a way to work together.

The patch-up between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and home minister Rajnath Singh is only on the surface. The rift between them did not start with the rumour-mongering about Rajnath’s son Pankaj and the tales-told-in-hushed-tones of how Modi summoned and scolded him.

It’s a personality clash between two ambitious politicians which began in the early days of the NDA-II government. The fact that Rajnath gets to chair cabinet meetings in Modi’s absence, a pseudo-formal designation as number two only barely masks the actual powerlessness that Modi has reduced Rajnath to.

For one thing, Modi operates not through his home minister but through the minister of state for home affairs, Kiren Rijiju, the young MP from Arunachal West whose only previous experience in governance was indirect: he had left BJP in 2009 to join Congress in his home state and serve as an adviser to the re-elected Arunachal chief minister Dorjee Khandu (who died in a helicopter crash a year and a half later).

Since coming to North Block, Rijiju has enjoyed a far higher profile than Rajnath. The junior minister regularly crosses the road over to South Block where he reports directly to Modi.
During the recent clashes on the Assam-Nagaland border, which left nine dead and approximately 10,000 homeless, Rijiju was deputed to visit the area and arrange the deployment of central forces (and also refute Assam chief minister Tarun Gogoi’s politically-motivated charges of inaction). Rijiju has been fielding Parliament questions on Chinese incursions into India; while this may be justified as concerning his state, it is a hot-button issue on which Rajnath has asked the Intelligence Bureau (IB) to urgently and regularly keep him posted. And within the first month of office, Modi sent Rijiju to Bangkok, Thailand, for an Asian ministerial conference on disaster risk reduction. Rijiju actively travels domestically as well, be it to inaugurate a solar plant in Chandigarh or to visit the National Police Academy in Hyderabad.

Rajnath has conspicuously tried to carve a space for himself with regard to India’s oldest political problem, Kashmir. On August 11, in a reply to a Rajya Sabha debate, he said that in order to find a permanent solution to the Kashmir problem, the government was willing to have a dialogue within the ambit of insaniyat (huma-nity) — a formulation made famous by former prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee in April 2003, while extending a hand of friendship out to Pakistan.

The very next day, Modi went to Kargil and harangued Pakistan; a week later he cancelled the foreign secretary talks because their high commissioner had chatted with separatist Kashmiris. Rajnath’s “insaniyat” pledge — again, on the advice of IB — has been dumped in the bin, with a message to Rajnath to boot.

One might wonder whether Modi’s proxy home minister with regard to J&K is party president Amit Shah — Rajnath’s replacement as party president and perceived to be Modi’s alter-ego — seeing as how Shah’s Mission 44, the strategy and aim for the coming J&K assembly election, is driving government policy both on Kashmir and on Pakistan. (Incidentally, the home minister was to visit J&K this weekend, and this has been postponed due to the PM’s trip to Japan.)
Then there is the widely-reported reduced role of Rajnath in the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. ACC decides on all top-level posts in government, PSUs, banks and financial institutions; it comprises the PM, the home minister, and the minister directly concerned with the appointment. ACC meets on file only. Modi has reversed the order of the movement of that file so that he selects the official; there is a token consultation with the concerned minister, and Rajnath signs on what is a fait accompli. This may be in line with Modi’s style of functioning, but it cannot be said to set a healthy trend so far as the consultative functioning of the cabinet is concerned.

The all-important Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) currently has only four members, since Arun Jaitley holds both the finance and the defence portfolios. Jaitley, the closest person in government to Modi but who is perceived by Rajnath as his rival for the number two position in government, outvotes the home minister, so that the CCS is also less consultative than it ought to be. (The other CCS member is foreign minister Sushma Swaraj.)
Personality clashes in government are not new. The first men to hold Modi’s and Rajnath’s posts in independent India, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru and Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, were rivals and had fundamental differences on Kashmir and Tibet (and on the Congress party itself). Yet the two never parted ways or undermined one another; their differences were noted in letters which are now part of our historical record.

Similarly, Vajpayee and his home minister (and later deputy) L K Advani were not always in sync; the Pakistanis have claimed that Advani torpedoed the 2001 Agra summit, where Vajpayee and Pervez Musharraf nearly inked an accord. Yet Vajpayee and Advani never fell out; in fact, the hardliner Advani was deployed to conduct the government’s dialogue — within insaniyat — with the separatist Hurriyat Conference.

Rajnath is ambitious and according to those close to him, he wants to make his mark with something substantial. Modi’s suffocatingly tight grip on government makes that unlikely. Recent cooing aside, the chasm between the two looks only to grow. more  

View all 13 comments Below 13 comments
Maybe too much is being made of the rift between PM and HM. Modi is not a fool! He does everything with a reason. Therefore, if he is giving more opportunities to Rijiju,there must be some calculation behind it. Let us wait and watch and not add to the rumour mill. more  
Please read the latest news here:
TNN | Sep 2, 2014, 04.08 AM IST
NEW DELHI: Union minister of state for home Kiren Rijiju on Monday rejected the suggestion that he enjoyed a higher profile than his senior, Union home minister Rajnath Singh.

He clarified that he worked under the "complete understanding, coordination, cooperation and guidance" of the latter.

Responding to an article in TOI titled, "Separated at birth", Rijiju said, "I carry out all works in the ministry as per work allocation which is approved by the home minister. I also enjoy full confidence of my home minister at official level and at a personal level since a long time."

Denying that Prime Minister Narendra Modi's alleged preference to send Rijiju to Bangkok for a conference and their frequent meetings was on account of the PM's preference of Rijiju over Rajnath, the junior minister said the PM's approval of his tour was strictly as per rules.

"PM being the head of the government, ministers may be required to call on him for political and other purposes," he added. He said factually incorrect reports appeared to be aimed at "creating a misunderstanding in cordial relations which I enjoy" with Rajnath Singh. more  
Those who are young may not recall the political development in 1978 when Janata Party came to power.It started with Indira Gandhi arrest on excesses during emergency.Mr Charan Singh was the Home minister and on this issue the mistrust was created between Charan Singh and then PM Morarji Desai. If the present government does not learn from history then BJP will be history. more  
Yes, Modi and Rajnath Ji are together. There is nothing wrong between them more  
The difference between Modi & Rajnath Singh is that while Modi has delivered, Rajnath Singh is yet to do so. Rajnath Singh cannot therefore claim to be even half as good as Modiji. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Hiow to deal with motivated agitators and terrorists ?

      For the last several days, some members of the Islamic group have been agitating against CAA. Now they are blocking roads in Delhi, Chennai and other places, though the government has assured that ...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Lessons for bjp

      3 lessons for BJP after Delhi: 1) Ideological issues must be supplemented by a solid governance agenda 2) There has to be a vibrant local unit with mohalla presence, & not mer...

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • Divisive campaigns have no place in aspirationals

      It was बिजली, पानी, शिक्षा, सुरक्षा chunav till a few weeks ago & then Shaheenbagh became the centrepiece of BJP’s campaign.For weeks women of shaheenbagh were demonised.If exit poll num...

      By Sonal Das
      /
    • Rahul Gandhi is an idiot

      Today Rahul Gandhi said; Ye jo Narendra Modi bhashan de raha hai, 6 mahine baad ye ghar se bahar nahi nikal payega. Hindustan ke yuva isko aisa danda marenge, isko samjha denge ki Hindustan k...

      By Shikha Jain
      /
    • Shameful news 18 India

      You ask a CM in power to prove that he cares about Hanuman and ask him to sing hanuman chalisa live. Well handled Kejriwal ji. Fan of u again in last 2 years. Worth watching everyone

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • WHY NOT CLOSE DOWN THE FOUR TROUBLESOME UNIVERSITIES S FOR SOME TIME

      J N U , Jadhavpur University , Jamia Millia Islamia and Aligarh are now under the control of student politicians who have no interest in pursuit of studies. Obviously, they are guided and funde...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • BAN POLYGAMY FOR WOMEN EMPOWERMENT

      Polygamy ( the practice or custom of having more than one wife at the same time by a man) is one of the worst forms of oppression against women from time immemorial. While such practi...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • LET NOT INDIANS FALL IN TRAP OF TERRORISTS, MOTIVATED ACTIVISTS AND POLITICIANS

      Ever since the Indian parliament passed Citizenship Amendment Act, section of muslims and motivated activists/ politicians supported by section of media have been carrying on a campaign to paint t...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Is strike the be all and end all of trade union movement ?

      The constituents of united platform of trade unions namely AITUC , HMS, CITU , AIUTUC , SEWA , AICCTU , LPF , UTUC and a few others have decided to go on All India strike on 8th January...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Wall Street Journal on Modi government today

      India has projected itself for three decades as a bright spot in a tough neighborhood. But 2019 may turn out to be the year it became a trouble spot, depending on the answers to two questions.

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari
      /
    • Mr. MODI ON RIGHT TRACK – NEED CREDIBLE SPOKESPERSONS

      During the last 6 years, after assuming the position as Prime Minister of India, there is no doubt that Mr.Narendra Modi has been striving hard to decisively improve the conditions in India in sev...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
Share
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)