Kejriwal and Tata Nano - Similarities

The election frenzy is now over and the euphoria over the new government has also settled in. Looking from a marketing lens, it seems some veteran political brands got a makeover (it paid off well), some political brands fell big time and one of the newest kids on the block with a huge buzz around it, fell flat on the customers (read voters).

The recent election results force us to mull over what went wrong with one of the promising brands of the Indian political landscape, Arvind Kejriwal. Kejriwal's performance in politics in the last one year has some resemblances with one of the biggest brand failures in the country, Tata Nano.

Nano promised to change and revolutionise India's automobile market in a big way. Kejriwal appeared as the man who can change the political landscape. Both Nano and Kejriwal changed their battlefields, but not quite the way they had expected.


The initial performance of Arvind Kejriwal and Tata Nano: The similarities

For the starters, let's establish the lacklustre performance of both these brands - Nano and Kejriwal. Nano was launched with much fanfare in 2009 and received a record-breaking booking of 2.06 lakh units at Rs one lakh per unit. The rest of the people who booked the car had the option to cancel their bookings or buy it at a higher price. Oops, wasn't it touted as Rs 1 lakh car for two years? So why should only a select few get the privilege?

Cut to the political scene: Arvind Kejriwal gets a huge response in Delhi state elections in 2013 with 28 seats to his Aam Aadmi Party. He forms the government with outside support from the Congress but lasts only for 49 days and resigns. Didn't he promise the Delhi voters so many changes in the state in return for their votes? But suddenly he changed his mind (much like the Nano management changed its mind about the price) and the voters felt cheated and they remembered this in the national elections (just like the people gave a cold response to Nano over the last six years).

Today, both Nano and Kejriwal have had a dismal performance. Tata Nano has managed to sell 2.5 lakh units (Source: Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers, SIAM, reports) in the last six years since its launch in 2009; not to forget that the company has the capacity to produce 2.5 lakh units per year and that's what the initial target was.

Arvind Kejriwal got just over two lakh votes in Varanasi and lost to Narendra Modi by more than 3.7 lakh votes. AAP's performance, too, was nowhere respectful with victory in only four seats out of 432 seats that it contested.

The big fallacy: 'Jo dikhta hai wo bikta hai'

Besides the dismal performance, another common thread between Kejriwal and Nano has been the big built up and hype around them for months before their launch/polls, courtesy excellent public relations (PR), below-the-line activities and the media. Everyone was talking about Nano back in 2009 at the time of its launch. Similarly, everyone was talking about Kejriwal during the elections (in fact, even after the elections).

This reiterates the biggest marketing rule: Consumers (or voters) can't be won over only with great PR and media attention. 'Jo dikhta hai wo bikta hai'? Well, not really for Kejriwal or Nano!

Consumers/voters don't forgive or forget broken promises

Nano came into existence with its tag price of Rs one lakh. But that was offered only to a select few customers. Kejriwal sold people the dream of honest and outstanding governance in Delhi. He broke his promise in 49 days when he resigned. Voters viewed this as an opportunistic decision.

Misread the market

Nano's marketing team touted the product as the common man's car, rather the car for the less privileged. Their target audience were the small town families. Their marketing focused on creating big buzz in the mainstream and social media and other tactics, creating big buzz in the metros. Not much was done to reach the primary target audience. The brand misread the market.

Kejriwal touted himself as the leader of the common man. He and his team created big buzz in Delhi and a few other big cities and thought they can win the elections based on that buzz. They believed if Delhi voted for them in the state elections, the entire nation will also vote for them in general elections.

Marketing lesson: Creating buzz in the big towns will not win battles in the heartland of the country.

Nano has not really been able to redeem itself and the sales of the brand have been on a downslide (30,000 units approx in FY 2010, 70,432 units in FY 2011, 74,527 units in FY 2012 and 21,109 units in FY 2014, Source: SIAM). The question is: Can Kejriwal redeem himself in the eyes of voters and do what Nano couldn't? more  

View all 16 comments Below 16 comments
Your are not touching the bottom of the issue. The euphemism and simile
used by you may justify a fact on other periodical level in unlike
circumstances. Arvind Kejriwal and AAP have been adorned with 28 MLAs and 4
MPs at debut while even BJP overwhelmed with success this time had had to
struggle from 2 M.P in 1984 to a prolific 282 in 2014. You can sense how
high Kejriwal and party will fly in right context. Failure of Naino may be
translated in to a success if TATA group emulate the strategies adopted by
Ambanis and Adanis vis-a- vis Modi ji. more  
Well said/define @ SUbrata Guha Ji more  
100 percent agree with Mr. Subrata Guha

Sent from BlackBerry® on Airtel more  
Respected Madam,
U have very well compared AK with Tata Nano.But many vital points u have missed out.Some of them are as below:1. Gujrat Govt has given a loan of Rs 50000 crore to Tata Nano @ 0.1% interest./no funding by corporate houses unlike Modiji/BJP, SPENDING rS10000/- CRORE FOR IMAGE BUILDING, what about AK?2. Every Tata Nano car sold, Rs 50000/- is paid by Gujrat Govt./what about AK?3. Best Governance by AK in those 49 days in last 60 yrs since independence, that too not having majority and having no Jadurappa or Nitin Gadkari like talented persons with him to help./Tata Nano enjoying free bees from Gujrat Govt.

IT WILL TAKE SOMETIME MORE FOR US TO UNDERSTAND, ACCEPT HONEST/TRANSPARENT CLEAN TRACK RECORD PERSONS LIKE AK, BECAUSE WE R USED TO SLAVERY.Madam don't worry about AK, he can take care of himself (who left the job of an IT commissioner & u have not compared this most vital point with Tata Nano ), but people r gradually coming to know what AK said "our Govt is run by Ambanis/Adanis and not the ellected BJP/Cong Govts.
Subrata Guha

From: support@localcirclesmail.com
To: subu_guha@hotmail.com
Subject: New post "Kejriwal and Tata Nano - ..." in [Aam Aadmi Party Delhi/NCR]
Date: Thu, 12 Jun 2014 10:32:23 +0000 more  
Madam, good evaluation. Are you a Marketing Guru or Political Pundit. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • HAS PAKISTAN’S FUTURE BECOME QUESTION MARK ?

      The most serious problem faced by Pakistan today is due to the state of it’s economy, which appear to have become beyond redemption due to accumulated issues caused by mis governance and high...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • WILL HOWDY MODI SERVE ANY PURPOSE ?

      Howdy Modi in Houston gets huge publicity in India. But, it is doubtful whether American media would give it similar importance. President Trump is going out of the way to keep Mr. Modi in good hum...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Article 370 eliminated

      Congratulations to Modi Government. 1st bold decision. Do work on the economy though...

      By Sheetal Jain
      /
    • RTI amendment

      Please find attached and fight the misinformation campaign.

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • Is it time for yet another demonetisation ?

      In 2016,when Prime Minister Narendra Modi demonetised high value currency notes of Rs. 1000 and Rs. 500, it shocked the nation as all the country men were caught unaware of. Mr. Modi explained that...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Will the $5 trillion economy be possible for India by 2024 ?

      After receiving massive mandate in recent parliament election and getting second term as Prime Minister of India, Mr. Narendra Modi with his characteristic courage of conviction and confidence and...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
      /
    • Congress politicians may cross over to BJP

      candidates whose name I am hearing in Delhi Jyotiraditya Scindia Shashi Tharoor Milind Deora If anyone knows more, share.

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • Invitation for Swearing in Ceremony

      Modi ji gave attached invites to all VIPs, party workers, kins of party workers deceased in west bengal. For the next big event half the invites should be reserved for common citizens (s...

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • 1984 vs 2019

      Blue turns Orange. If Modi Govt does good work and Congress/3rd fromt rebuilds itself, one can assume it will take 35 years for Orange to turn Blue/Diff colour again

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • Muslims Support Modi as much

      Just watch people watch. Amazing Mandate!!!!

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
    • Media people must never go this low

      Unless they are desperately looking for a ticket

      By Rajesh Suri
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)