Doing Business Issue - Transgender Extortion

I am in Residents of Noida circle and one of the issues being discussed here is extortion of businesses/companies by transgenders and businesses are seeking assistance from district magistrate and police as they have transgenders at their doors every day asking for 21,000. This is twice a year phenomenon, i think holi and diwali.

It is a problem for business today and will continue to be. The police has not been able to address it and even DM hasnt been able to stop the extortion.

Question is - can we in India tackle this menace in a more organized way. Giving 500/1000 twice a year is ok for most but paying 42000 a year as extortion money is difficult.

Is Govt doing some kind of training programs for them. Why cant they work in factories, skilled under skill india. Why cant they be car mechanics. Are they just lazy fellows or has no one approached them to get skilled, learn something and make a living.

May be it needs a national discussion and then some policies and steps. more  

View all 15 comments Below 15 comments
A true Government, a representative of Citizens, irrespective of it is run by any party, an end must be brought to such practices at what ever cost and effort. This is a shame for all those Police Officers and Bureaucrats and the Law implementing authorities who take OATH to stand by the Constitution and take salary day after day and then show a back to the justice, decency and the LAW at large. A serious view should be taken of this at the highest level by the HOME MINISTER and The PRIME MINISTER and The Chief Ministers. Why they should not meet together and discuss and support each other with follow up actions at regular intervals. Thank you. On Sun, Feb 5, 2017 at 2:50 AM, Aditya Goyal wrote: > more  
Can GOI has a rule where such extortion has strict punishments more  
North India is having his problem because they have a custom to honor them on many occasions. It is very difficult to remove it. People have been pampering them so it is difficult. more  
Its a reality and harassment of all commuters across Delhi roads.The problem of NOIDA is a bit bigger,because of transgender Government in the State of UP.It goes without saying that the situation is equally worst across India.The people, who happens to depend on the socially recognised hefty alms have become extortionists.Now, ritual for some has turned into extortion for many in broader day lights. The menace has to be stopped. It is also true that a lot of criminals also find their livelihood in the cover of transgenders.More so, now as transgenders are recognised as third gender by the Central Government,many things for the sustained livelihood and social recgnition in usual course be arranged primarily by and with the help of Central and State Governments and also by and with the help of social help groups,religious groups as well as caste and sub-caste organisations in the field of education, skill imparting, permanent settlement, legacy and succession, dispute resolution etc. more  
There should be a determined bid to wipe out organised beggary. Only this will address this vexatious issue and also other crimes like kidnapping and mutilating children to use as beggars or drugging babies to hire out to women begging at junctions etc. from vehicles. People should not yield to such extortion and must stand firm. Only then can society develop free of such menaces. L.Kalavathi Retd. Bank Official Chennai, Tamilnadu, India 6th Feb 2017 more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Will many CAs may have to close soon

      Many CA, CS and CMA Professionals have to either change work or close their practice after this attached circular.

      By Ajay Dutta
    • Google is a pathetic company

      Google India hiked the rate of business mail by 350 %. With fear of recession looming and when msme are struggling this is not the right thing to do. It will cost msme sector 5000 crore per year...

      By Vishal Khanna
    • GST filing

      Still GST system is not 100 % user/official friendly. there are news that so much money (in lacs) collected by fraudulent GST bills. I am a GST registered vendor. The company turn over is almo...

      By Subramanian Venkataraman
    • Taxation Issues faced by Startups: Inputs Sought

      Many of you know how LocalCircles had worked with the Government in 2019 on resolution of angel tax issues under Section 56 (2)(viib) of the Income Tax act. Once again, the Government h...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Why no penalty an dprosecution for govt

      Now our IT portal has become sick being suffering babu virus or extortion virus. McA site never works on last days and people have to pay penalties for mistakes of govt. Now professionals are wasti...

    • Income Tax Return Filing Portal

      What about income tax return filing date? Any extension thereof? As of today, I am not able to file the return . Has any one else file the income tax return? Has Portal issue been solved? I have al...

      By Hasmukh Sangani
    • Grass root experience

      I have been doing and promoting small business for the last 30 years. The real problem is that the ministers and their secretaries don't have practical experience and they look for 5 trillion dolla...

    • Why do Ministers refrain from engaging with businesses

      I find it quite interesting that the ministers want to deal only with tata adani ambani and not the real msme and startups. Why is the msme minister (appointed this week Narayan Rane) his secretary...

      By Aditi Mitra
    • Why such mismanagement

      FICCI the industry association has written to Centre saying most of 40000 ventilators manufactured under PM Cares Fund last year are lying unused at government facilities. Mainly due to negligence ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Word of caution to Indian small entrepreneurs

      Friends this is Aditya from New Jersey. A friend of mine from Brazil recently lost 3 members of his family back home to Covid. The P1 variant is most dangerous of all and is now invading neighbors ...

      By Aditya Sharma
    • simplifying procedures for easy business

      none of the administrators who are lucky to get into govt seats have practical field experience and they are not aware of the strains of small entrepreneurs. They always imagine that any entrepren...

      By Subramanian Venkataraman
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)