Co-operation Department's

What is the sense of Co-operation Department's existence, when it has all the required laws at its disposal but no will to implement them. The very purpose for which the department is created, is defeated.
The case on hand is:
The very existence of the society is questioned for the last 8 years, but to no avail. Absolute arbitrariness in management since its inception is its hallmark. However, the Dy. Registrar has never questioned this society. For several years, there was no Committee. Subsequently, it was taken over with vested interest of self-redevelopment.

Notice under Section 79(3) of MCS Act was issued to the society. It treated this notice with utter contempt and ignored. However, the Co-operation Department is not moved at all. There is no action by it.

So is the case with the Municipal Corporation. It entertains the society's application of self-redevelopment with gusto by enforcing Section 354 of of the BMC Act, neglecting the Mumbai High Court's order on rehabilitation of its existing members.

But none of the above authorities are moved.

Thereby, I can safely conclude that co-operation exists only for manipulations and that the Co-operation Department is defunct, when it comes to self-redevelopment. more  

View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
Rules are made but the watch on its implementation is very poor. more  
The Worst part is to Protection of Illegal acts and activities by intentional and deliberate negligence's, in-spite personal visits, reminders, complaints.
Moreover there is No alternate remedial measures available.

As against this, any of illegal acts and activities required to be initiated the same personnel's acts so swiftly to astonish the total acts and activities.

A simple example is the statutory Compliance s requited to be complied by the Management - which are NOT complied - wherein the Actions initiated against few swiftly and drastically, whereas thous societies who Obey the DEMANDS will be speared for Years together.

That is WHY the total Dept is in doldrums - be it Co-op. Banks or Co-op. societies.

In case in Hand - advisable to Move to Bombay High Court instead of wasting time, efforts and money in the manner presently adopted. The Results are well before you. more  
The Govt. introduced the M-20 Bond under Rule 58A. This was one more farce.

Every Managing Committee was required to execute a bond and send intimation of the execution of the Bond to the respective Registrar. If it does not, that committee stands disqualified.

How many of the hundreds of societies registered execute such bonds? The courts decided that all decisions taken by such committees would be illegal. However every society had a committee and it functioned.

Subsequently, the Govt. introduced a notification that committee members would not be required to execute this bond. But again, members disqualified due to the earlier condition, could not contest election.

This folly leads to the suffering of the disputed members, because the committee is vindictive and the Dy. Registrar defunct.

What is the role of the concerned Dy. Registrar? How many committees did he declare as illegal?

The simple conclusion is that the govt wants to retain power in its hand but not enforce it, even after the irregularity being pointed out. more  
The amendment of the MCS Act and its regular updates are nothing but another farce.
When there is no strength of staff to monitor the implementation of the Act in its proper sense and every matter, including enforcement and elections, is conducted by people outside the govt. employment, what is the sanctity of their reports?
A video recording of the election process is required to be done. Who is to store this video? The Registrar or the society? What is the authenticity of this and who is to certify this? Obviously, the costs will have to be borne by the society.
The Govt. appointed auditors also play their role. When the audit is conducted and queries made by the auditor, the auditor should be satisfied. Once he has certified the audit, should the auditor not be held responsible for the report? If he certifies something wrong, what is the consequence to the auditor?
Does the auditor check the strength of the members vis-a-vis the share capital? Why should he not be responsible if the Share capital is described as Rs. 2,750/-(11 members@ 5 shares of Rs. 50 each per member) and member strength as 10. The Dy. Registrar and the Audit Department carries on like this for 37 years. What is the purpose of the Audit Department and separate Commissioner?
Are we really being covered by the Act? Does it make sense to the Govt. itself. The Co-operation Department is nothing but a Tamasha to ensure that the disputing member is always persecuted.
The Co-operation Department is inert when such discrepancies are brought to its notice.

Why should the cost of running this department be borne by the public? more  
Recent court decisions has diluted consent requirement of members as well. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • 2190 cases today

      Total new cases in Maharashtra in last 24 hours 2190. Attached details. Total deaths in state in last 24 hours 105 Total deaths due to coronavirus in Maharashtra 1897

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Highest ever COVID 19 count in Maharashtra

      MAHARASHTRA #COVID19 update for May 24: New cases: 3041 (highest) Total cases: 50231 New deaths: 58 Total deaths: 1635 Total tests: 362,862 New tests: 14,8...

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Maharashtra covid 19 Treatment Price Cap Notification

      If anyone or their family friends have to go to a hospital, you need to save and share this link which has full notification of Govt of Maharashtra on how much hospitals can charge for covid19. 80%...

      By Seema Shah
    • Super sincere thanks to LocalCircles

      I want to thank localcircles and all its members for taking up my complaints about exorbitant charges for covid19 treatment by Mumbai hospitals and even conducting polls. I am pleased to...

      By Seema Shah
    • Hospital loot under COvid 19

      This Attached is a hospital in Mumbai. They have exhibited the tariff card in the lobby for the convenience of the public, of course to avoid a fight post discharge. profusely if you a...

      By Sobhita D
    • Detailed Lockdown 4 Rules

      Attached everyone. Please see and share your concerns. The page shared by Mr. Deshmukh is also in there

      By Seema Shah
    • By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • लोग अप्नने निजी बिमारी की जानकारी क्यो whatsup ग्रुप पर या जाहीर करे?

      BMC ने 60 साल के बुजूर्गो का नाम ओर 40-60 के भीतर के लोगो का नाम ओर बिमारी के लक्षण का आवेदन मांगा है. पर हाऊसिंग सोसायटी अपने whatups ग्रुप के जारिये नामकण मांग रहा है ये कहा तक उचित है?

      By Ravindra Gandhile
    • Maharashtra Lockdown Extended

      Attached circular friends. Maharashtra has extended lockdown till 31st.

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Maharashtra in bad state

      Sad to read Seema Shahs friends story. Pathetic private hospitals of Mumbai and apathy of administration who just wont pass clear orders and enforce Maharashtra recordEd 1576 new Covid-...

      By Shivani Khiste
    • Under reporting of covid 19 cases

      Yes. I think you are right. In USA, even probable deaths due to corona is also included in the counting, whereas in India, even death due to corona unless confirmed by authorised agency before deat...

      By Hasmukh Sangani
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)