Acche Din article by Abheek Barman
By election results in 10 states and 36 seats are out and it is a stunning setback to the BJP government led by Narendra Modi and party president Amit Shah. In Uttar Pradesh, where 11 assembly seats, all held by the BJP went to polls, the party lost nine, a slap when even losing a single seat was thought to be a major loss of face, given the constructed reality of a Modi ‘wave’ sweeping the nation.
The BJP’s politics in the Hindi heartland has increasingly centered on communalization, dividing Hindu against Muslim and pitting bulldogs like Gorakhpur MP Adityanath against all minorities. Well, the verdict is out: even in western UP, which has been the most communally polarized area, the BJP has drawn a blank. Indian voters are wiser than so-called leaders and will not be moved by fraudulent claims of some ‘love jihad’.
Elsewhere, the Congress has rubbed the BJP’s nose in the ground by winning three of four seats in Rajasthan and even winning a couple of seats in Modi’s Gujarat. These are states were the BJP was supposed to be invulnerable, with no other party able to wrest even a single seat from it. Well, so much for a Modi wave.
But the BJP has started winning in states where it had no toehold earlier. It won a seat in Bengal and one in Assam. This means that while it is losing out in the heartland, its traditional base, it could extend its reach to the east. This might not last: after all, Bengal and Assam politics are played very differently from the BJP-RSS playbook.
This verdict against the Modi-ruled BJP can create great changes. It could, for example, reset the equation with its ally, the Shiv Sena, in Maharashtra just before a crucial assembly election. The Sena has been smarting from insults from the BJP: apparently the new leadership under Amit Shah believes it is dispensible and the BJP can win in Maharashtra on its own.
After Modi’s Lok Sabha triumph, three rounds of by elections have taken place and the results for the BJP have been an unequivocal disaster in every phase. Acchhe din – better days were promised – but Indian voters have wisened up to the divergence between that and the reality of growing inflation, communal tension and loss of livelihoods that have happened in the last few months since Modi came to power.
The results – in stark electoral terms from Uttarakhand, Bihar, Karnataka, UP, Gujarat and Rajasthan – are there for all to see. more
The BJP’s politics in the Hindi heartland has increasingly centered on communalization, dividing Hindu against Muslim and pitting bulldogs like Gorakhpur MP Adityanath against all minorities. Well, the verdict is out: even in western UP, which has been the most communally polarized area, the BJP has drawn a blank. Indian voters are wiser than so-called leaders and will not be moved by fraudulent claims of some ‘love jihad’.
Elsewhere, the Congress has rubbed the BJP’s nose in the ground by winning three of four seats in Rajasthan and even winning a couple of seats in Modi’s Gujarat. These are states were the BJP was supposed to be invulnerable, with no other party able to wrest even a single seat from it. Well, so much for a Modi wave.
But the BJP has started winning in states where it had no toehold earlier. It won a seat in Bengal and one in Assam. This means that while it is losing out in the heartland, its traditional base, it could extend its reach to the east. This might not last: after all, Bengal and Assam politics are played very differently from the BJP-RSS playbook.
This verdict against the Modi-ruled BJP can create great changes. It could, for example, reset the equation with its ally, the Shiv Sena, in Maharashtra just before a crucial assembly election. The Sena has been smarting from insults from the BJP: apparently the new leadership under Amit Shah believes it is dispensible and the BJP can win in Maharashtra on its own.
After Modi’s Lok Sabha triumph, three rounds of by elections have taken place and the results for the BJP have been an unequivocal disaster in every phase. Acchhe din – better days were promised – but Indian voters have wisened up to the divergence between that and the reality of growing inflation, communal tension and loss of livelihoods that have happened in the last few months since Modi came to power.
The results – in stark electoral terms from Uttarakhand, Bihar, Karnataka, UP, Gujarat and Rajasthan – are there for all to see. more
Viewed by 963
View all 10 comments Below 10 comments
Yes 'ACHHE DIN AA CHUKE HAIN but there are bad days for common person. There is openly murder of humanity/truth/justice/mothers and so on........ There is universal that every unjustice follows justice, every dark moment follow brightness/lightening moment. So now it is time of darkness, unjustice, hate, crimes, criminals, rogues. It will be followed by decent moment like time of Lord Ramchandra or Lord Krishna or truth, justice, honesty and so on... Please wait for some more time. Time is powerful. It will open the closed eyes of people that which is right and which is wrong. Have a patience. Good luck On Tue, Sep 16, 2014 at 6:45 PM, Seema Mehra wrote: > more
Sep 22
A very fine article, which exposes the capitalistic leanings of Modiji & the BJP. But Maharashtra & Haryana elections could be very different as anti-incumbancy factor is a serious matter and there is no third alternative. So be prepared for a lot of BJP tom-toming after the declaration of the election results of those two states. more
Sep 17
The Parliamentary Election results were based on anti-incumbency rather than any face of Modi and Advani. These byelection results are telling vividly the same story. In Parliamentary Election UPA was to go and it went. Credit went not to anti-incumbency, even not to BJP rather to Mr. Modi. It was only AAP which was voted on hope of Honesty, Rectitude, Performance and Governance and it proved when elevated to power albeit in only 49 days. more
Sep 17
What a humiliating defeat for NaMo/ Amit Shah in the by polls in all the states, including Rehana of Banaras, so far. I fully agree with Sh Jagdish Singh that all credit goes to AK. FIR has already been lodged against BJP MLA in Delhi for contesting with false reserve category certificate (and I think AAP has lodged complain with EC to cancel his ticket & initiating n.a. against him.) Now it is certain that BJP's MLA count will fall to 27, equal to that of AAP. Then how the LG can invite BJP to form Govt in Delhi? Our preveous PM Sh Manmohan Singh might have been a dummy PM, but did not sell false promises. We cannot forget loot in Gujrat: Snatching poor farmer's land and selling to Adani @Rs1/sqm Loan of Rs 50000 crore to Tata Nano @0.1% interest, & every Nano car sold is financed by Rs 50000/- by Gujrat Govt. So far communalisation is concerned I still recollect what Mr Derrick Oberoi of TMC said for NaMo in contest to NaMo-Gujrat riot 2002, when NaMo went to WB for marketing for BJP, for LS polls with Rs50000/- crore at his disposal borrowed from Ambanis/Adanis and standby Helicopter provided by them. More AACCHHE DIN AHEAD FOR NaMo/ Amit Shah/BJP, WAITING AT MAHA, HARYANA ASSEMBLY POLLS. Subrata Guha more
Sep 16
