AAP - Draining of Hope by Santosh Desai

Hope can be a stubborn thing. In the face of mounting evidence to the contrary, hope can find a way to continue to believe in an idea that it holds dear. When challenged with unpalatable facts, hope uses a multitude of strategies to stay afloat. It discounts the magnitude of the evidence, re-calibrates its original expectations, adjusts to compromises in the name of realism, finds new reasons to believe when the old ones start running out, and clutches at straws of any kind that appear to be within grasp. And only then, with a death rattle, it drains itself empty, leaving behind nothing but the rancid taste of humiliation amongst the believers for having had the audacity to hope.
For the AAP, the journey downwards began with the decision to convert a powerful and popular movement into a political party. This meant that it had to part ways with the fountainhead of the movement, Anna Hazare, which was seen to be just as well, for his leadership, rooted as it was in a very limited worldview, could not have helped sustain the movement. The decision to become a political party was justified on the grounds that there seemed to be no other route to change given the existing political system.

Then came the first Delhi elections, and the stronger-than-expected showing of the party that made the idea of coming to power within reach. Of course this meant accepting the support of the Congress, something which Kejriwal has expressly and repeatedly ruled out. The compromise was again deemed necessary; after all, how could the party deliver a new order if it shied away from power?

Then came the 49 day rule of the party with some high and many low points. The Kejriwal dharna and the drama around Somnath Bharti’s ridiculous antics were put down to the lack of experience. The decision to resign prematurely and contest elections nationally, santoand to go up against Narendra Modi in Varanasi was attributed to bad strategy. For all the things that were going wrong, there was still a sense of hope that it was trying to work out a new approach in its own chaotic and highly public way.

The 2015 landslide victory seemed like proof that the AAP experiment had survived. Kejriwal fashioned a victory out of a truly original script against overwhelming odds and gave rise to an expectation that something transformational was on the cards. Politically, Kejriwal seemed to have forged a connection with the urban poor that gave the party a solid base. This was seen to justify a shift in the party’s move away from its anti-corruption plank as well the downplaying of the idea of transforming politics itself.
But the only transformation that was visible lay within the party. In purging Yogendra Yadav and Prashant Bhushan from the party, not only did Kejriwal eject a side of the party that held it to its idealistic moorings, but he did so in a manner that was authoritarian and boorish. There was no grace in his actions, nor the semblance of a higher purpose. It seemed to only about consolidating power, and for a lot of original believers, this was a deeply disillusioning moment and the AAP experiment with idealism seemed all but over. There was still some hope that armed with a huge mandate, the government would deliver on its promise of fundamental and transformational change.

But that doesn’t seem to be happening. The new government seems to be embroiled in petty squabbles and sordid controversies involving its representatives. It is true that the AAP and Kejriwal, have come under sustained attack from several quarters, including the media. It is also true that it has reason to feel aggrieved by the way in which the central government through the instrument of Najeeb Jung has sought to strangulate its ability to govern. But the AAP is hardly blameless in all of this. Its natural mode of functioning is confrontational, and there is an air of determined immaturity in the way in which it picks its fights. Also, it has shown a distressing ability to bask in the very political culture it has decried. Till the Supreme Court decreed otherwise, AAP ads routinely wore the faces of its leaders, and it has not been shy of using public funds to showcase its ‘achievements’.

Which brings us to what is effectively the last straw. The new ad released by the Aam Aadmi Party does what all its earlier actions could not. It decisively proves the skeptics right and buries the ideals that gave rise to the party deep enough so as to not be the source of any trouble in the future. As many have pointed out, the ad is a deformed product of a mindset that is so obsessed with itself that it has lost touch with reality. The personality cult it attempts to build would put the current regime to shame — in this world, there is no AAP, there isn’t even a Kejriwal Sarkar, there is only Kejriwal. And if you are the kind of person who likes some variety, there is some Arvind in there too. That it is deeply sexist and unbelievably regressive just completes the picture. More alarmingly, it reveals how easily overweening victimhood, when married with a sense of impregnable self-righteousness can morph into the legitimizing of autocratic impulses.
As a text, the AAP ad is deeply clarifying for it tells us how the party imagines itself at its best; no vested interests or critics can be blamed here. No excuses are possible now nor can this reality be reframed in way that makes it more palatable. The AAP will live on, for politically the party still has some gas in its tank. But it is now just that, another political party with a wannabe messiah as leader. The hope that it had evoked lived, it survived many ups and downs and now it is decisively dead. more  

View all 15 comments Below 15 comments
It is not clear why some people are busy to prove that Kejriwal has failed to deliver and provide good governance, after all people of Delhi have voted AAP in power. If people can tolerate bad governance of congress and other other political parties in states and center for decades why the netas of other parties are so concerned for the people of Delhi under AAP. Let the people who voted them in power take decision themselves. more  
I agree with the views expressed above. Mr. kejriwal has not been concentrating on the work of better governance. He is simply picking up fights with the LG and the BJP to sustain the party. The promises made Mr. Kejriwal were practically impossible even for any full pledged State to materialise. What he would ultimately do, he will shift the burden of not fulfilling the promises on the Central Government led by BJP. He is simply giving now an impression to the people of Delhi that he is a NOT PERFORMER, he is simply a showman and as he himself says "he is an anarchist.
He promised to bring down the Power (electricity) tariff, on the contrary rates of electricity
have been raised by 4% to 6% plus service tax.
Water charges for the first 700 litres per day were waived, but in very many colonies there is acute shortage of water.
I wish somebody shakes up Mr. Kejriwal from his day dreaming, and put him on the right track. more  
They say democracy is collective wisdom. It is worrying to see that it can easily be collective stupidity as well. Some times we give 67/70 to people who are currently demonstrating that they neither the capability nor the habit of constructive action.

We keep talking about whether AAP will give sleepless nights to BJP or Kejriwal v/s Modi. The basic question we should be mulling over is whether Delhi citizenry is better after the new government took over or not. How does it matter whether Kejriwal brings Jung to his knees or vice versa. or for that matter they are able to catch a few corrupt (that is not a bad idea though). The crux of discussions should be; Does Delhi become more clean, has better infra, has better governance, attracts more white collar industry (say become a financial or software hub)? But you cant catch any of the AAP people ever talking about substantive things.

I may be wrong but my preference is for people who can give us assurance about availability of electricity rather than 200 rupees discount, synergistic governance rather than proving that they can bring everybody to their knees, more jobs rather than fighting over who will pay the salaries for employees already on rolls. It is one thing to talk of honesty but practicing it by throwing out your own Lokpal reeks of sophistry.

Hope AAP comes back to their original mandate of 'party with a difference' with sight on Swaraj and honesty. more  
We don't want AAP giving sleepless nights to BJP, but wish to have ourselves sound sleep. Kejriwal has proved that Governess is not his pie. He has started shrieking aloud like empty vessel. I regret joing his party and working for him in elections. He is enjoying no sense of any purpose. Look at TSRs. Aren't they fleecing and intimidating us, the passengers? The Elect bills mounting. regular Water promised, nowhere to be seen. Employment or regularisation of casual employees, housing promised. Where are they? Encroachment of roads and footpaths is rampant. Did anyone felt any difference in Delhi after the change, save some skeletons are tumbling down his own cup board. more  
The people of Delhi have blundered by throwing their weight with the most anarchist AAP and they will have to face the music for that....the previous experience of 49 days in the govt. should have drawn more sense with the voters to cast their franchise sensibly... by the way this loud rhetoric of cheap electricity and water which cannot be accomplished by any standards and even if it works out...at whose cost will it be,,,,it would simply be at the cost of the tax payers..is that a solution???? As one of the writers has sensibly put if more bluntly..that we don't have the system of impeachment in our Constitution..thus these exchanges are meaningless....and the harsh fact remains that our National Capital is at the mercy of a bunch of anarchist fraudsters, incompetent and bogus team of ministers. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Stadium Naming

      Terrible idea to name Motera Stadium after PM Modi. Congress set an awful practice of naming stadiuma, universities, airports, roads & even planetariums after Indira, Rajiv, Sanjay & Nehru....

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari

      The anti Modi campaign is now becoming vicious and full of feelings of hate against him. With hate campaigners becoming determined and getting media publicity, there is anxiety now developin...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      The so called farmers, by indulging in unprecedented violent acts in Delhi ,have made India’s enemies happy. As usual, those who instigated the innocent farmers and made them agit...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      The agitation by section of farmers and their associates in Punjab against the recently enacted farm laws in Parliament by Government of India have been now going on for over 45 days, with no s...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
    • Why India need Mr. Modi

      Having been elected with clear majority two times, Prime Minister Modi clearly sees himself as a man of destiny. Obviously, he has firm convictions with regard to economic and social policy and...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
    • Is the protest against Farm Bill appropriate ?

      The demand over the several decades by various political parties and agricultural economists have been that the exploitation by the middle men (trading houses) should be put down by enacting stro...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      It is high time that the journalists and activists should take a good look at their own image in the society and search their conscience whether they have always been neutral and unprejudiced.

      By N.S. Venkataraman
    • Government should be committed to population control

      Today, what stands between India and high prosperity index is the huge population, which still continues to increase at alarming level. To control the population growth, Prime Minister M...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      When the world was attacked by COVID 19 and with no proven drug/vaccine available xfor treating the infected people, social distancing between individuals was advocated as immediate solution to sol...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      Now, it appears that both the governments and the public are tired of lockdown. It appears that people have reconciled themselves to live with COVID 19, just as they have been living wi...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      It is highly depressing to read news about the local people’s objection to bury / cremate the corona infected deceased persons in their locality. This is happening all over India and par...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)