AAP and Power Companies

Everything Mr. Ashutosh writes about the AAP perseverance to ensure that the power companies run by Reliance and Tatas were subjected to an audit by the CAG is true. It is absurd for either the Congress or the BJP to now claim that they had the same policy.

According to the first reports of the CAG audit, the culpability of the Sheila Dikshit Government in the (estimated) 8,000 crore fraud seems to be well-established. It cannot be a coincidence that every time important policy decisions were to be taken, the government-nominated Directors on the Board, according to the CAG report, were conveniently absent. Not once but several times. Why should any Government permit such obviously pro-company behavior from its nominees? This is clearly connivance.

Ashutosh is also right in criticizing the BJP and Congress demand for a CBI probe into the CAG findings. When there is prima facie evidence, the companies concerned should be directly charged and prosecuted. There could be an independent inquiry into one aspect of the report, that is, the nexus between the companies, the then ruling party leaders and a section of the bureaucrats, so as to identify and prosecute the individuals involved.

However, two important issues emerge from the AAP position as articulated by Mr. Ashutosh which require reconsideration by the AAP leadership if it is not to be an exercise in self-praise.

The first is a fundamental issue of his party's approach towards the responsibility of the Government in the provisioning of essential services to the people. The AAP position is "it was not against the privatization of electricity, but companies should not be allowed to loot in the name of privatization." Thus there is no difference in the policy approach towards supplying electricity in the Capital between the AAP, the BJP and the Congress. They are all agreed that it should be handed over to private companies, and certainly none of them will say that they are for loot in the name of privatization.

AAP has further articulated its position by asking the Centre to cancel the-long term contracts with the Reliance and Tata Discoms (power distribution companies) and allow the AAP Government to give the contract to other companies, who presumably would not "loot" and agree to terms more reasonable to consumers.

AAP support to Congress and BJP policies of privatization of essential services flies in the face of global experience about privatization in the electricity sector.

There is more than adequate literature available of the experience of the dozens of countries which in the 80s and 90s started the privatization processes of electricity generation and distribution. The general reasoning to push privatization was similar to that used to privatize the Delhi Vidyut Board: to improve "economic efficiency", to "rationalize" (read retrench) the workforce, to improve technology, to check wastage in transmission, to ensure correct meter measurement of use of electricity etc. all in the name of reform.

But as described by analyst Sharon Beder ten years ago "The blackouts from California to Buenos Aires to Auckland, government bailouts to companies in California and Britain, electricity rationing in Brazil, and the fact that it is too expensive for millions of people from India to South Africa" soon showed up the fallacy of the privatization reasoning. In the light of global experience, the very institution which had been pushing for privatization, the World Bank had to admit in its report in 2013 " It is difficult to find consistently beneficial effects of the reforms actually implemented in many countries." (quoted in David Hall, Global Experience with Electricity Liberalisation, Dec. 2009).

In the light of post-privatization realities, many countries which had been at the forefront of handing over publicly-held power utilities to the private sector are reversing the processes of privatization and taking over the companies. These include countries in Latin America like Bolivia, Chile, Argentina, Brazil and also many provinces in the United States and municipalities in Germany.

In India, we have the example of the failure of the privatization of electricity distribution in Odisha, which was the earliest state in India to privatize. Four distribution companies were created and privatized in 1999, with US-based AES Transpower taking over one, while BSES (Now Anil Ambani's Reliance Infra) took over the three other discoms.

AES walked out in 2001, after refusing to restore transmission and distribution lines to rural areas after the Orissa cyclone. Recently, the state power regulator - Orissa Electricity Regulatory Commission - revoked the licenses of Anil Ambani-owned Reliance Infra for gross failure, stating, "Even after 15 years of operation, the licensees have consistently failed to run the enterprise in a commercially sustainable manner." The Odisha government, a strong votary of privatization, had to follow their advice. Remember when Mumbai was flooded in 2005? The areas where private power companies operated remained in darkness for seven days. State-owned utilities provided power within 24 hours.

Why does AAP not pay heed to these experiences? It is a myth being sold by AAP that it is going to find private companies which will act differently.

A differential rate for electricity users with cheaper rates for those below a particular cutoff - in the case of Delhi, 400 units - certainly brings relief to the poorer sections. After Delhi under AAP took this step, it has led to the halving of the bills for such users. But this will not protect such users against the inevitable rise of prices if electricity remains in the hands of private companies.

The second question that arises is has the AAP or the Delhi Government dialogued with Delhi-ites on its support to privatization? It would appear that the democratic exercises that AAP projects as its USP are confined or limited to selective issues that do not require a fundamental change in the policy frameworks of the Congress or the BJP.

It is only when electricity is seen as an essential service and is the responsibility of the Government that the loot of thousands of crores of rupees as exposed by CAG will not be repeated. The AAP and the Delhi Government should take the only logical step, which is to re- takeover the electricity utilities. Essential services for the well-being of the people cannot be held ransom to the profit-hungry private companies.

The above is written by Brinda Karat of CPI(M) more  

View all 11 comments Below 11 comments
The only solution available with communist team is government take-over and government subsidy. They can't think that a proper rule based system can allow private players to perform much better.

There is no doubt about the corruption indulged in by governments, but the answer is not government take over. If there can be corruption in private company due to government patronage, what is to prevent corruption when government is running the show?

The answer is simple - bring transparency in the operation of such monopolistic entities. They have to compulsorily get their accounts audited by CAG and publish the results. Government take over is going back to the good old days of license raj and artificial scarcity. more  
Comparing Govt. workforce of America with our Govt. employees is a far fetched idea. In our country any thing which has a govt. stamp on it, is inefficient, time consuming i.e. delay, cost escalation and poor quality. That is not the case with America or with other countries. Secondly, our communists politicians have still not learned their lessons despite communism being rejected through out the world including its original country Russia.
Now as far as privatisation is concerned , the same workforce was inherited by these private companies. Yes Congress govt. has given too much leeway to these private companies which should not have been done but vested interests were there. AAP also understands this problem and trying to rectify the wrong doings of past by staying with private operators but also by keeping a tight control over them. They should be allowed to earn their profit but not loot.At the same time the generation and distribution of power should also improve so that general public could be benefitted. more  
Dear mam their is a one way to stop crrouption to deport the persons
to check the meters frequntly the were govt employees and on six
months contract and pay them the salary after two months as a result
their market goodwill report also comes and if found guilty make
provisons for inprisionment for 14 years secondly put the meters
outside of the house and put a pole on the infront of the house that
will decrease the electricity theft and give the readers a printing
machine which will delever the bills hand to hand and electricty
department file monthly/quarterly report to the cag which will audit
by the cag persons such all this things decrease the corrupction level

On 8/24/15, Ranjana Sharma <support@localcirclesmail.com> wrote:
> more  
The rot is not only in Govt. companies. Private companies have also allied with govt. ethics in order to remain competitive and profitable. I am very disappointed to see company like TATA with unethical business practices.
The govt. companies are inefficient and corrupt, private companies are solely profit driven. No fair competition is possible if the private companies are required to bid for public utility services.
What then is the solution?
We can think of citizen pressure groups , social audit and NGO with diverse experts acting as watch dog. But they will have to face relentless pressure from Govt.s and crony capitalist. Black sheep among NGO are also not ruled out. more  
Loot by Private Discom parties - I do not know, since CAG has pointed out some thing is definitely fishy. But it is well known - loot has to be shared by every body. But going back to old system - may be a good idea. But can any body tell me - any Government body running efficiently? Railways, IOC, AI, DSIDC, ITDC, MTNL. If I have to appreciate - perhaps Delhi metro only. SO RIGHT REGULATOR IS MUST. MY QUESTION WHAT REGULATOR WAS DOING. WHY EVERY BODY WANTS TO PUNISH TATA / AMBANI, WHY NOT REGULATORS AND REGULATORS ONLY? If theft is reported in your factory - in spite of highly paid security staff. Management is responsible, some personal interest is involved. WHY THE GREAT PEOPLE MADE SUCH GOOD, VERY GOOD REGULATOR. Same argument - I would like to put, now I understand - lot of scams have been reported in parliament, TV and lots of committees have been formed. Good, very good. But - rules remain the same. So if I have to pocket money - I have taken care of very thing. No problem, form committees, does not matter. I have done by job and I am the expert in my field of corruption. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts


      Now, it appears that both the governments and the public are tired of lockdown. It appears that people have reconciled themselves to live with COVID 19, just as they have been living wi...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      It is highly depressing to read news about the local people’s objection to bury / cremate the corona infected deceased persons in their locality. This is happening all over India and par...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      A team of management professional, technologists , trader with long experience in their respective field have put their heads together and arrived at suggestions for lifting the lockdown in the f...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      As we celebrate International women’s Day, it is surprising that no one seem to be talking about the practice of polygamy where one man marries several women. This is one of the most uncivil...

      By N.S. Venkataraman

      Almost all section of Indian media and most of the critics have blamed the Delhi police for the riots for two days ,when many innocent lives were lost and many were injured and large scale propert...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
    • Someone get this chimpanzee booked

      He is openly challenging Delhi Police and Govt of India. "Trump के जाने तक तो हम शांति से जा रहे। लेकिन उसके बाद हम आपकी भी नही सुनेगे. सड़कें खाली करवाइए तब तक।" "Till Trump...

      By Rajesh Suri
    • Hiow to deal with motivated agitators and terrorists ?

      For the last several days, some members of the Islamic group have been agitating against CAA. Now they are blocking roads in Delhi, Chennai and other places, though the government has assured that ...

      By N.S. Venkataraman
    • Lessons for bjp

      3 lessons for BJP after Delhi: 1) Ideological issues must be supplemented by a solid governance agenda 2) There has to be a vibrant local unit with mohalla presence, & not mer...

      By Rajesh Suri
    • Divisive campaigns have no place in aspirationals

      It was बिजली, पानी, शिक्षा, सुरक्षा chunav till a few weeks ago & then Shaheenbagh became the centrepiece of BJP’s campaign.For weeks women of shaheenbagh were demonised.If exit poll num...

      By Sonal Das
    • Rahul Gandhi is an idiot

      Today Rahul Gandhi said; Ye jo Narendra Modi bhashan de raha hai, 6 mahine baad ye ghar se bahar nahi nikal payega. Hindustan ke yuva isko aisa danda marenge, isko samjha denge ki Hindustan k...

      By Shikha Jain
    • Shameful news 18 India

      You ask a CM in power to prove that he cares about Hanuman and ask him to sing hanuman chalisa live. Well handled Kejriwal ji. Fan of u again in last 2 years. Worth watching everyone

      By Rajesh Suri
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)