With no funds, can Jal shakti perform - Joydeep Gupta

It has been a week since senior bureaucrats fanned out over 1,000 districts in India to start projects in water harvesting and water conservation. Meanwhile, the union budget has come and gone with hardly a change in the allocation of the renamed – and presumably strengthened – Jal Shakti (Water Power) ministry. Now many of the bureaucrats are back in New Delhi, saying what they need is not more money but stricter implementation of existing laws.

Speaking off-the-record, some bureaucrats also mutter about the need to overhaul India’s water-energy-food subsidy structure, while admitting they will not make the “futile” attempt to recommend such an overhaul to their political masters. The subsidies – free energy, no regulation over groundwater withdrawal and assured prices for water-intensive crops like paddy – brought about the Green Revolution and made India self-sufficient in food grains. But with groundwater levels dipping alarmingly, bankrupt electricity companies and food grain mountains that lead to storage headaches the entire structure is well past its use-by date.

Despite knowing this, politicians are too scared of the big farmer lobby to do anything about it. These represent the interest of those that own farmland of 10 hectares (100,000 square metres) or above, which account for only 1% of all Indian farmers. More than two thirds of Indian farmers own plots of less than 1 hectare (10,000 square metres), and the average size of landholding is 1.15 hectare (11,500 square metres).

Instead, there is now an experiment to pay farmers to save water, being tried in three villages of Punjab by The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), a think tank based in New Delhi. The farmers are being told that if they use less than a certain amount of water, they will be paid for every litre they save. This, of course, requires a water meter in every farm. Many farmers have refused, as they see it as a sneaky way to install a meter and later charge them for the water they use. A few have agreed. The experiment continues.

The challenge of reviving traditional methods

On a larger scale, the Jal Shakti ministry is now abuzz about the water harvesting mission that Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced in his resumed weekly radio broadcast after regaining power in the April-May election. Suddenly, there are frantic searches for studies, reports and books on traditional water harvesting. Experts who have so far thought only of the width and depth of irrigation canals are suddenly having to find out how big and how large ponds should be, the best lining for the bottom of a pond, why a stepwell was built the way it was, and so on. Many are exasperated when they find that traditional water harvesting methods change almost every 100 kilometres, and only snort in irritation when told the changes reflect the varied hydrology of South Asia.

There are experts and policymakers who have got their heads around this and have experience of traditional water harvesting systems from the time they were posted at district levels. They do not scoff, but they point to a serious problem – traditional water harvesting requires space. A pond can be dug only if there is space for it. Natural aquifer recharge as practised traditionally in Rajasthan, and parts of Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh requires strict cleanliness in the watershed – the slope down which rainwater flows before percolating underground.

Since the 1950s, engineers – mostly from the Public Health Engineering departments of state governments – have gone from village to village effectively denigrating these traditional water harvesting methods. They have been saying that surface water gathered in ponds are full of bacteria, or there is simply not enough rainwater to really recharge aquifers. Instead, they have been installing handpumps everywhere to draw underground water, with the promise that this is clean and healthy.

It is now widely recognised that this system has also passed its use-by date. Groundwater levels have been dipping alarmingly in the south, west and north-west of the country. The Ganga and Brahmaputra basins still have groundwater, but over-withdrawal has led to toxic levels of arsenic and fluoride in the water that people use.

So going back to traditional water harvesting is the only way, and there is no shortage of good models to follow.

Mismanaged urban development

But there is a problem. After their initial foray all over India last week, water ministry bureaucrats have reconfirmed that ponds and watersheds have been ruined and encroached upon in village and after village, town after town. Most of these had been in common lands rather than land belonging to anyone, and once they apparently lost their utility, local musclemen moved in. In the last five decades, Chennai – still facing a crippling water scarcity – has lost over 70% of its tanks. The situation is similar in just about every urban and rural part of India.

The Modi government has promised piped water to every rural Indian household by 2024. To get anywhere near that goal, it will have to take on the encroachers, with all their political connections. In many cases, it will find government offices built on such land. It remains to be seen what the government will do about it.

Will the nearly-static budget allocation to the Jal Shakti ministry hinder these efforts? “The Prime Minister has said this has to be a peoples’ movement, and our minister has said a peoples’ movement does not need money, it needs people,” a bureaucrat wryly points out. more  

View all 19 comments Below 19 comments
Today need is for sustained support structure and not the RURAL TYPE short time support system.
Our Ministers and Govt Officers have very intelligently thrown the cause back to us to debate and fail and go silent thereafter.
India is cash Stripped now.
Like any Public ltd co. when funds are needed , public issue is brought in with lot of advertisement.
Similarly Sovereign bonds are being launched to collect money from outside India for national growth.
Try to study from all angles , we are being pushed to LOTA and LANGOTI days . This is new India. Think Like an ordinary Indian waiting for water and food - tru realisations will not take time to arrive.
May wisdom prevail.
12th July 2019

From: Harsimran Kaur <support@localcirclesmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 9, 2019 7:36 PM
To: chaturvedi_anurag@hotmail.com <chaturvedi_anurag@hotmail.com>
Subject: "With no funds, can Jal sh..." more  
The traditional water harvesting like digging of ponds, wells will help. The underground water is being misutilised by mechanised borewells. Water supply by government should be sufficient, so that private boring should be banned. more  
Yes it can happpen only with peoples movement. The tanker lobby is mostly owned by the political class.will that be ended? Unless , there is a revolution, and all the people stand united, the water bodies can't be restored. Does the PM have the courage to take action against those who have encroached on water bodies ? Just announcing a scheme is another Jumla. Leutens Delhi has ample supply. The Government has to stand up with the people and get it done.
Indian courts , take a century to complete a case. It's with the help of the law enforcers that itan be done , if they mean buisness. more  
Without peoples' involvement this program is not going to succeed. Therefore huge awareness campaign is necessary and good models should be suitably rewarded, including at individual level as well as collective community level. Also there should be proper legislative intervention to prevent misuse of water as well as augment the water resources. more  
Article is eye opener .During last decas of time we experiment Western model .I give one example of traditional water conservation in Jaipur Rajasthan . Here in jaigarh fort there is very large covered tank in which rain water was stored . First two three rain water was used to clean roads from where water came in tank, afterwards water was directed to tank.This tank water is sufficient for year to used. But now every where encroachment lobby is so strong politically and economically that even High Courts order are helpless.If in reality target has to be achieved only with strong politically will as well as society awereness. thanks more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • What single use plastic items can India ban effective Oct 2, 2019?

      For the first time ever, Government of India has pledged to conserve environment by taking a strong stand against use of single use plastic. As a ban on single use plastic is considered, we seek yo...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Swachh Ganesh Immersion : Action Needed

      Based on your inputs, attached are the key tips on how Ganesh immersion can be carried out in an ecofriendly way. Do save and share the image across your whatsapp/facebook/email contacts even if yo...

      By LocalCircles Manager


      By Jayakumar Daniel
    • 5 years of Swachh Bharat: How are things on the ground?

      The Swachh Bharat Mission will complete 5 years on Oct 2nd 2019. On this occasion, we would like to seek your frank and honest inputs on what has changed in the last 5 years. Is garbage getting pic...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • eCommerce package recycling survey and addl inputs sought

      To address the excessive waste generated by ecommerce platforms, members of LocalCircles including many of you have been suggesting a model to recycle the boxes and plastic packaging. Below is the...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Finding replacement for single use plastic water bottles

      Given all the efforts by this circle, India may ban single use plastic as early as Oct 2, 2019. With this post we would like to seek your very specific inputs on what could...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Enforcing ban on Single Use Plastic: Specific Inputs Sought

      This morning, the honorable Prime Minister outlined the importance of environment conservation, especially minimizing single use plastic. Enforcing the single use plastic and polythene ban is extre...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Ganesh idols from clay - my last years doing

      Ganesh Chaturthi is just around the corner, and if you are planning to invite Bappa into your home, you would be thinking of buying an idol. Being the environmentalist that you are or should be, yo...

      By Seema Mehra

      VOLUNTEERS Cleaning the dirt , collecting litter thrown by some irresponsible /arrogant / imbeciles . No doubt there is a possibility of emulating the volunteers by public . This Cleaning drive has...

      By Jayakumar Daniel

      THE MOST APPROPRIATE TOPIC TO DAY IN INDIA AND SWACHH AS WELL . Some excerpts from the attachment that appeared in the Hindu today . P.M. also highlighted India’s extensive effort...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
    • Manual Scavenging

      While a lot has been talked about and small steps are being taken in terms of building toilets, practically nothing is being done to reduce/stop manual scavenging. I recently happened to watch a sh...

      By Padmanabhan G
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)