Suggestions on mobilising additional Revenues by the Ministry of Finance.

My Suggestions on budget provisions aimed at hiking of Revenue are as follows. I invite comments on these suggestions from members of Local Circle on the desirability and feasibility of the suggested action-steps:
The Income of some individual dividend recipients (e.g. Mukhesh Ambani) though in Hundreds of crores of dividend has been escaping taxation, the ground being that the income stands already taxed in the hands of the dividend-distributing company. The ground is disputable. The Income of almost anyone and everyone would have been taxed in the hands of the payer, but that ground is not relied on to waive the taxation of the income of the recipient Hence there appears to be no justification for exempting dividend income altogether from income tax.. Dividend income above a certain level, say Rs.10 lacs or Rs.15 lacs may be taxed.
Many Horticulturists and Agriculturists (Apple Orchards, owners of large-sized farm owners) escape taxation because any activity going by the name of Agriculture has been a Holy Cow in India and exempted altogether from taxation, irrespective of how high the level of agricultural income. The surplus vis a vis the cost of living and the cost of living for self, family and other dependents is spent on avoidable luxuries, acquisition of power over others (whether justified or not). Morally or ethically it is not essential to leave such surplus of income untaxed. Agricultural income above Rs.10 lacs may be subjected to income tax.
Amongst various incentives given for exports is total exemption from income tax. Total exemption from income tax may act as incentive only in the case of small or marginal exporters. The export income (e.g., on Information Technology exports) tends to be wasted by way of unjustified payment of high salaries to their employees and executives. Hence all large exporters with income of, say, Rs.10 lacs may be subjected to Income Tax.
Nicholas Kaldor,a famous Economist from Cambridge University when requested in early 1950’s by Government of India to give suggestions on how black money can be minimised by maximising collection of Income Tax gave suggestion as follows.
Income of anybody and everybody is the Expenditure of some other individual or company. So the Report of Income filed by every individual or company may contain report of his/their expenditure. When such reports of all with income over exemption limit are compared and contrasted with such Reports of others, any misreporting comes to light. At the time this suggestion was given the type of computer software was not available. Now software for comparison of huge data contained in such reports is available. Individual expenditure and individual income may be reported in lacs of Rupees, as also source from whom or to whom.. Any expenditure not matched by income can thereby be identified warranting further investigation.. more  

View all 26 comments Below 26 comments
By
MANJIT SINGH MINHAS
I Manjit Singh Minhas age 63 R/O wadgaonsheri Pune. Joined Tata motors pimpri Pune on 3Nov.1979 .on 24 Aug.2003 Manager S SNaik for to sign me VRS i.e Early separation scheme with lumpsome amount Rs3.5Lac. This was reported to H.o.Mumbai because my left over service was 11 years . They told me that you will get response from Pune plant .on 9 April 2004 my service was terminated without any reason with one month salary only .that me they saved RS 3.5 lac..no dues given to me .In month of Jan 2007 I joined Weikfield Pune .in month of March 2007 Tata motors pimpri Pune filled false complain of cheque overwrite and was sent to yerwada jail so lost my job of Weikfield .Case heard in shivajinagar court acquitted without any charge .Now my case on Tata motors pimpri Pune is in Bombay High Court. Civil Writ petition 7041 of 2012 till today no hearing .How one can get justice in India.I am family members of three. I only earning member of my family .This is harassment on me what nobody care even though I contacted to Ratan Tata on phone..So poor person will die without justice in India .Modi will enjoy. more  
Rich Agriculturalists must be taxed. more  
Because fraudulent Businessmen encashing concentrating wealth more  
It is better to bring in expenditure tax replacing income tax to bring every one in to tax net. This suggestion came long back but not taken forward for unknown reasons. The expenditure tax may exclude some essential items like rice, vegetables etc., and levy tax at fixed rates of commodity. High end items like cars, air conditioners etc., can be taxed high and so on. Small items used by common people like bulbs, clothes etc., on lower side. Hope this will eliminate corruption in IT activity and people will know what is the tax amount and Govt. too can evaluate easily. more  
This is sheer nonsense. Everything cannot be done arbitrarily, especially taxation. Why only dividend income above 10 or 15 lacs should be taxed, why not 3 lakhs? The government should reduce taxes, simplify taxes, and fix taxes once and for all. Every budget, every year, you don't change the taxation system, as per the greed of the government in power. Reduce tax, simplify tax, and let every citizen be in the tax net. Let there be no black money. Let the Swiss Banks close down. Complicated taxation system encourages corruption and black money. more  
Wealth Tax shall be imposed Categorizing 3 Slabs on Individuals following Mandates of Articles 38 and 39 more  
Except taxation of ultra rich agriculturists, the suggestions of Mr. Sastry are retrograde and will not help the economy. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • The real Tsunami of Worklessness

      Crowds of men n women seeking work on daily basis, assemble outside Khar Rly Station And many other stations in Mumbai. Outside Khar Stn, those seeking work have more than doubled in las...

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
      /
    • Congrats Circles

      The Income Tax filing date has been extended - attached notice. Thanks for taking up important causes like this and escalating to PM FM and thanks to them for acting. My husband still awaits his fo...

      By Sarita Ravichandran
      /
    • India @ 72:Key actions needed in next 3 years before we turn 75

      In the past freedom polls in the circle, unemployment and social stability (communal issues) have been reported as key areas needing work. As India completes 72 years of it...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Good Initiatives of Central Govt: Inputs Sought

      With this post, we would like to seek your inputs on what have been the best initiatives of the Central Government in the last 5 years. Also, if you have examples of how work or initiati...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Request made to FM for Income Tax Filing Deadline Extension

      Thanks to several members for raising the issue of not receiving your Form 16 last week. Subsequently, we had conducted a survey in which many of you participated. The same has been submitted to t...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Enforcing Trade Margin Capping of Medical Devices: Inputs Sought

      Many of you may remember how NPPA, after LocalCircles intervention mandated the publishing of MRP on medical devices (attached order). The same LocalCircles ask was then accepted by the Department ...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Solution for Cross Border Imports via eCommerce channel

      Many of you are familiar with how LocalCircles in last 12 months has worked with various departments of the Government to stop misuse of India's postal and courier gift cha...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Further actions to remove VIP Culture: Inputs Sought

      Many of the members in this circle who were there in 2016-17 may remember how some of you raised the issue of eliminating red and blue beacons from vehicles which was taken up by LocalCircles (att...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Food Wastage by Hotels- Actions to be taken

      Many hotels in India have buffet food system and 60-70% food on average goes waste. Most hotels that had earlier signed up to distribute the left overs have now withdrawn from such programs due to ...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • LocalCircles Impact: Government removes MDR charges for large merchants

      Many of you who have been in the circle since 2016 know that since demonetisation, LocalCircles has been actively taking up the cost of excessive transaction charges for card transactions and been ...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Extending Price Cap from 3 to all 24 medical devices: Inputs Sought

      Those members who have been in the circle since 2016 know that LocalCircles was instrumental in getting a price cap put on stents and knee implants in 2017 and worked with NPPA on this cap and then...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)