Standards in Govt schools

Mr. Venkatraman of an NGO had shared in our Tamil Nadu circle about school standards in Government schools.

The highlights of the views expressed are given below.

Different standards amongst students
• While the government schools have mix of students of different level of capability and some students perform quite well, the standards of the large segment of students in government schools remain below par.

Students live in stressful conditions :
• Almost all students studying in government and corporation schools belong to lower income group and live in stressful conditions facing social and economic hardships due to variety of reasons including the head of the family being a liquor addict in many cases. The living conditions in the family and in the surroundings are certainly not conducive for the students in the formative age group . With parents often not in a position to guide and discipline their children, quite a few of them appear to be not having any sense of direction and tend to misbehave .

Teachers well qualified and cannot be blamed largely :
• While the teachers in government schools are well qualified and quite a number of them are dedicated, there are also teachers who take the job lightly , as there is no system of rewards and punishments for the teachers.
Anachronism of promoting all students :
• In the name of encouraging the students from lower income group and deprived families to join government schools , the government has introduced an all pass system upto 9th standard which has killed the incentive for the students to study and equip themselves with requisite knowledge.
• In the absence of any check for promoting the students to higher class , the standard of an average student has fallen considerably. There are some students even in the fifth standard who cannot do even two digit addition and sometimes cannot even write one sentence in Tamil correctly. Even the standards of some student studying in higher classes are no better.

Freebies to the students :
• The government has been showering the students in government and corporation schools with large number of gifts including books, note books, shoes and chappals, cycles, laptops etc. apart from noon meal, some of which are unnecessary. As a result, mind set have developed amongst students expecting everything to come free from the government, which mind set they continue in their life even after passing out.

While good students use the laptops well, there are also students who sell it away.

Lack of punishment as deterrent :

• With the indiscipline becoming a common issue amongst section of school students and with the teachers not being in a position to impose deterrent punishments on misbehaving students, teachers often feel helpless and weak. It is even reported that the students attend classes in drunken state in isolated cases and girl students are sometimes harassed. It is extremely disturbing to read in newspapers that even teachers in some government schools have misbehaved occasionally with the girl students. Such incidents reflect the type of prevalent climate in some government schools.

Unrelated assignments for teachers :
• Government sometimes sends teachers in government and corporation schools to unrelated jobs such as taking census. In such event when teachers cannot take classes, students are left idle wasting their time and they indulge in unwanted activities.

Political interference :
• There is often political interference by local politicians in the affairs of the school insisting on one condition or the other and the teachers are scared to resist such demands.

Lack of consultation :
• Government often takes decisions with regard to affairs of the schools without due consultations with headmasters and teachers who are the stake holders. Such decisions sometimes happen to be misconceived. The bureaucrats appear to think that they know more about the issues faced in government and corporation schools than the teachers themselves.
Some poor parents opt for expensive private schools
• Of late, even some parents belonging to lower income group admit their children in private schools, as they believe that the future of the students studying in private schools would be better. The poor parents do this, even though they cannot afford to pay the high fees demanded by the private schools and in the process, the poor families drive themselves into debt burden.

Sons / daughters of government employees rarely in government schools :
• Employees in the government rarely send their sons and daughters to study in government and corporation schools. What does this show ?

N.S.Venkataraman more  

View all 15 comments Below 15 comments
NABET operates a school accreditation programme which is based on school governance standard. more  
All the points are correct, but where is the solution.

All the parents should come up by discontinuing their children to schools irrespective of nature of the school. Untill unless:

Schools curriculum should be with Bharatam, Ramayanam and Bhagavadgeeta epics in their daily life with every aspect clearly explained.

Olden day subjects like Neethi Kathalu (Neeti stories) to be taught instead of today subjects without any knowledge.

Our technology is not higher or greater than Ravanasura pallaki which has flown from one place to other by airlifting Seeta devi and Hanuman flown to Srilanka in search of Seeta.

There are no wonders created than Pushpa Banam, Agni and others used by Arjuna educated from Dronacharya.

There wont be any more principles than Chanukya's Economics which we are going to introduce.

All that is like a Dosa rost, it is one side and now turning to another side.

Importantly every school be it International, National, Local, Municipal, Panchayat, Village school should inculcate with olden principles.

NCERT, CBSE, ICSE etc boards should rework on the curriculum's with compulsory subjects with Ramanayam, Maha Bharatam, Bhagavatam etc to educate students and leave their carrier in their hands with coloring shine. more  
Self study and school curriculum, whether government or private,depends upon the pockets
If government schools are short of teachers ,so are teachers at private schools are more as show off and not learned
My own experience and watching grandchildren who are paying@ lakhs per annum for junior classes in best of the schools and these schools are brands and not temple of learning
Every kid has a private tutor,class 1 onwards
I believe that the mothers are the best tutors ,at least for junior classes more  
The schools have become commercial in nature. They only require money, but interest for educating the people. more  
RARELY EVER PEOPLE REALISE THE TRUE VALUE OF ANYTHING UNLESS THEY 'EARN' THE SAME. IF ANYBODY GETS ANY THING FREE - MORE OFTEN THAN NOT, IT IS WASTED. THIS COULD BE TRUE TO TAMIL NADU PEOPLE AND TO TN GOVT SCHOOL STUDENTS. RULING POLITICIANS SHOWER MANY FREE GIFTS TO GOVT SCHOOL STUDENTS AND THESE KIDS "ENCASH" THE LAPTOP, CYCLE, ETC ETC AT THE EARLIEST CHANCE. POLITICIANS MAKE SURE THAT THEIR KIDS GO TO A CBSE AFFILIATED SCHOOL AND BE PROFICIENT IN HINDI( for future.!.) WHERAS LESSER MORTALS SEND THEIR WARDS TO GOVT. SCHOOLS FOR WANT OF FUNDS. (It will be interesting to study 'how many of TN Ministers have sent their wards to Govt. schools' .!.) If the students in Govt
Schools are a pampered lot, the teachers are no better..!!.. Their main concern in school is about their 'seniority', their next pay revision, and others. MANY OF THEM ARE IN THEIR CHAIRS BECAUSE OF THEIR 'CONNECTIONS' AND ARE A TOTALLY DEMORALIZED LOT. IF AT ALL THEY TEACH, IT WOULD BE MOSTLY IN THEIR 'HOME TUTIONS' AS THEY FEEL THAT THAT THEIR PHYSICAL PRESENCE IN SCHOOL IN ENOUGH TO WARRANT THEIR MEASLY SALARY..!!.. more  
Reducing the number of holidays by 50% and linking salaries/pensions
to performance will improve the quality of education in all Govt. schools
to a great extent. more  
The agony stated are true. Teachers though qualified can't be blamed as
1 No of students are more so personal attention to each student is not possible.
2 The teacher cannot go out of the routine.
3 Much more other Official work they has to do.
4 Result oriented new technology cannot be used though they want to introduce
5 As the up and down of the students in regards with the economy, level of the parents which affects the students quality has to
handled.
6. Political interfere is also the cause. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Standards for Ayurvedic Products

      All kinds of products are being sold under the garb of ayurvedic products. People are buying them based on ads or a particular doctor pushing to them. Can the bureau of indian standards ...

      By Darshan Rao
      /
    • BIS STDS

      What is the mentality of BIS body. important issues like road life and pits ,road sigals requirement standards , where signals and road junctions are necessary to avoid accidents are neglected ...

      By Satyapal Singh
      /
    • Priorities of BIS

      I was astonished to read that BIS celebrated its standards day yesterday and the focus area was video standards. I mean, really? Can we please pay attention to instead far more important...

      By Nikita Merchant
      /
    • Standards for artificial sweeteners

      Friends, FSSAI has been an utter failure when it comes to their understanding of what artificial sweetners to permit and different thresholds. They are basically following whatever global companies...

      By Neelima Verma
      /
    • Is BIS a failed organisation

      I want to know what all has this BIS done in the last 6 months. What standards have they made. Atleast consumer department made 4-5 important policies in last 3 years and passed Consumer Protection...

      By Sanjana Gupta
      /
    • Standards for play schools

      There is a need to have safety and food standards for play schools in India. There are play schools in NCR charging 200000 per year for children but have no standards. Recently a friends...

      By Sandhya Agarwal
      /
    • Standards for Drones

      The BIS should now look at making standards for drones. The Govt of India has come up with a draft policy. Several Indian companies are trying to manufacture drones but the chinese will kill the in...

      By Amit Mishra
      /
    • STANDARDS IN HOME STAY

      I agree. Most of the home stays that are run are small houses converted from the owner's residence with no concern for safety, comfort or hygiene. They are only out to make a quick buck . We have p...

      By SUBRAMANIAN PALLAVOOR
      /
    • Urgent need for Grocery Delivery Standards

      Just had a bad experience yesterday with Big Basket where worm infested and way past expiry date sweet corn was shipped to us. Recently also came to know someone in the neighborhood rece...

      By Sachin Taparia
      /
    • Homestays Standards

      I dont know whether this has been taken up already but BIS needs to set standards for homestay industry. Companies like Oyo, Airbnb are currently doing whatever they like, multiple people just in m...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • BIS should test water of all municipalities

      11 tap water samples taken in Delhi by bis have failed the bis water standards. I bet Noida will be no different and same with Gurgaon Ghaziabad Faridabad. BIS to ensure they know realit...

      By RN Chopra
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)