Review of VIKALP option by IRCTC

While IR advertised the VIKALP option as a crucial aid for passengers getting waitlisted tickets, I, after many experiences, have found it almost useless & just a scam to earn money.
Take my last journey for example. While booking tickets from Kanpur to Ghaziabad, I opted for VIKALP & chose all trains in the post 4.30 hrs. The train originally booked for was to depart at 9.00pm and charting got done at 5.00pm, showing 'Waitlisted'.
Now, anyone in such situation would decide to buy general ticket and travel in the same train or he may choose to travel in any train before or after it, because waiting till the charting of all VIKALP trains is a risk of still not getting the ticket confirmed. but now, the problem is that he has opted for vikalp option so IR may allot him a seat in any alternate train departing after 9.00pm and in such case, IRCTC will not refund the person's money because they have given him a confirmed seat while that is now, useless for that person as he has already taken his journey in another train and also bought a separate general ticket. so for that vacant berth, IRCTC will earn the reservation amount and this is a proven scam by IRCTC. so, I want to ask what is people's opinion and their past experiences regarding the vikalp option....
have they ever got the confirmed tickets using that option or they travelled in general class having a fear in mind that what would happen if the get a seat in an alternate train after they have taken their journey. more  

View all 20 comments Below 20 comments

On Tue 28 May, 2019, 11:32 PM Abhay Mittal, <>

> more  
VIKALP is useless. I may not be allotted even a RAC ticket, because I have opted VIKALP for confirmed ticket and not for RAC. It is the shortcoming of VIKALP. Please never opt for VIKALP. I have never seen success by opting VIKALP. Better to book second ticket in other train, if there is doubt of confirmation. more  
In Vikalp You have to Select the Trains which suits to your Plan. Or Else wise You can take Current ticket & start Journey. In Vikalp In Fact You are getting Confirmed berths. It Is not Scam But efficient use of available Infrastructure. Not To blame railway. more  
If the scheme is not suitable for you, you are free not to opt for it. You may ask for information from Railways about how many Passengers have opted for "VIKALP" and how many of them have been offered alternative and how many of them have actually utilised the option duruing last six months or so. You wold have better data to put up your argument.
RYK. more  
VIKALP option never works. If you have opted for VIKALP and your existing ticket is waitlisted, you can check availability in alternate trains selected by you. If alternate trains are also showing waitlist then there is no chance of your VIKALP ticket getting confirmed.

Reservation window of 4 months is also a very big scam. If you are traveling in 1A, 2A or 3A classes big amount of money gets blocked. e.g minimum average ticket price of 3A is Rs.1000 and if we are family of 4 than Rs 4000 gets blocked. Now a person will also book return ticket as well, so another 4 thousand get blocked. So total Rs 8000 blocked for 4 months. If ticket is waitlisted many people will try booking in alternate trains as well, so there additional amount gets blocked.
Railway issues waitlisted tickets in huge number so imagine how huge amount they are keeping and on top of it if ticket does not get confirmed they will not refund full amount and deduct some amount as clerkage charge.

4 months advance reservation should be immediately stopped and reservation window should be opened only 2-3 days in advance and present tatkal scheme should be shut down. Some 10-20 tickets can be kept reserved for emergency and should be issued at station physically only 2-3 hours before departure. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Coolie rates

      Never pay coolies 400-500 type rates which they demand at new delhi nizamuudin old delhi typically. Attached are the actual railway rates for coolies. Everyone pls share experience. This

      By Harsimran Kaur
    • Make SMS and Web systems real time

      I have repeatedly observed that there is a significant discrepency between train position reported at stations and via the sms and web systems of railways. It is very misleading for those receivi...

      By Ajay Mittal
    • Unsafe Practices at Stations and in Trains - Inputs Requested

      Dear all: To make Indian Railways more safe it is important that we understand what are all the unsafe practices of today. Please share everything unsafe you have observed when travelling by Rail...

      By Ministry Of Railways
    • FSSAI in Railways: Course Correction

      FSSAI has started some campaign where it is creating awareness about Eat Right Station and trying to do ranking certification for stations. I humbly suggest that FSSAI stop wasting everybody's tim...

      By Manju Patel

      1. Booked one 1st AC tkt from DADAR-CHAMPA by 12809 HWH Mail on 13/07/19 PNR 8217815147.I am a sr.citizen. I was allotted upper birth in cabin H. But can anybody imagine that the remaining three b...

    • Railway Needs to improve...

      I think Railway must try to improve the following things as soon as possible: 1. Train Delay control. at present train means 2-3hrs late is common. 2. Announcement system must announce platform n...

      By Amit Kumar
    • Displays in trains/stations - additional issues

      Below are the key issues as outlined by you in regards to displays in trains and stations. Kindly review and share any specific additional issues you have and root causes for these issues. We look...

      By Ministry Of Railways
    • रेल्वे स्टेशन बिसलेरी प्लांट

      Railway Station Mineral Water Plant: 1. I feel before throwing empty bottle one must remove its label and then crush it as much as you can. 2. Railways must not allow such vendors to enter and se...

      By Pritam Sharma
    • Monsoon Preparedness - Your inputs, Our action

      Last year, after the track flooding in Harda, we had received your inputs on what can be done to proactively prepare Railways during monsoon season. Below are the key actions through which Indian R...

      By Ministry Of Railways
    • express train time schedule

      Yesterday (29/06) I (pnr 8442749147) took 11301 Udyan Express to come to Bangalore from Mumbai. Boarded at DADAR. The train starts from CSMT next station DADAR (arrived 20mits late); next station K...

    • Ticketing Touts - Inputs Sought on Root Causes

      Below are some of the key issues as identified by you in regards to touts involved in Railway Ticketing. Kindly review and share your inputs on Root Causes of these issues. With the assistance of ...

      By Ministry Of Railways
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)