Move to 2 GST rate structure

The survey of localcircles itself is saying that people want 2 gst rates 5% and 18% (attached)

https://www.localcircles.com/a/press/page/citizens-manifesto-2019

The present Govt's manifesto says they will simplify GST. Why did they complicate in the first place?

What is best for consumers? more  

citizens-manifesto-2019-5___20190410124643___.jpg
View all 14 comments Below 14 comments
The rates are decided with far more study , Such taking blind poll will not help, now Gold is having 1.5% GST ask in a saperte poll that how many are ready to pay GST on Gold at 5% or 18%. none will agree. Giving Slogans is very easy but practically its not so. more  
There should be 3 rates: 0%, 5% and 12% more  
And with the above services being personal functions, input tax credit is not availed. So the consumer or customer loses. more  
The services for GST rates also need to be looked into. For example: Fees to purohits for religious functions, catering fees for religious events etc. Most of them blackmail consumers by saying that pay in cash, otherwise we will charge GST @18% which it too high. Whether they pay the GST to the government is doubtful. Slabs of 0% 50,000, 3% for 50000 to 1L and 18% above would be helpful. Also a 18% GST for basic lodging should be reduced or avoided. A hotel with just ac rooms and no other facilities, is 18% GST justified.
Ultimately it is the consumer who gets burdened with the GST.
So, probably 3 slabs for GST - 0%, 3% (or 5%) and 18% would be reasonable. more  
I think max there can be 3 GST rates only, like 0%, 5%, 10% and 20% with selected basic n essential food items for exemption, 5% and 10% for poor and middle class, and 20% for rich class items. Rounding off can be minimised with these rates n easy to verify for the consumers/tax payers. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Expanding Tax Net - Sweet shops across India

      Most mid sweets/halwai shops of India are top tax evaders. They evade both gst and income tax on 95% of the sale they make. Will the members of this circle tell Government how to get the...

      By Amit Mishra
      /
    • CBI says GST officials taking cuts from transporters

      The Central Bureau of Investigation Monday told a Delhi court that there are various state GST officers who allegedly accept money collected from transporters through middlemen in exchange for not ...

      By Sudesh Rai
      /
    • Rule 36(4) of SGCT Rules 2017

      Can anybody explain Rule 36(4) of the GST Rules 2017 which restricts availment of credit to 120% now revised to 110% that deems credit claimed as inadmissable?

      By Ashish Agarwal
      /
    • ITC denial

      This is internal finance ministry communication. Does this mean ITC is being denied to meet targets?

      By Rohit Jain
      /
    • Abolish Input Tax Credit system

      Heading in Times of India 21 January 2020 “Trading firm director held in ₹10-crore GST scam The Thane wing of the CGST arrested Vinit Agarwal, director of Hemraj Devkarandas Metals ...

      By MOHIT PANDE
      /
    • GST registrations getting cancelled

      Now the non-filing of Goods and Services Tax (GST) returns is leading to attachment of bank accounts or cancellation of registration and many are worried. According to the GST law, it i...

      By Vishal Khanna
      /
    • UNREGISTERED DEALER CRITERIA

      Who can do business as an unregistered dealer under GST. Thanks - Sailesh

      By SHAILESH RAO
      /
    • clarification

      I would like clarification, whether a fund collected annually ,and spent on the benificiaries;which amount to roughly Rs 50 to 60 lakhs for our regular get-togethers be subjected to GST authorities...

      By Vadakke Raman
      /
    • Bribery in GST

      I am getting reports that magnitude of bribery on gst related matters has gone up. The excuse given is “sir risk badh gaya hai” you need to pay more. There are man...

      By RN Chopra
      /
    • GST ON COMMERCIAL SPACE ON RENT

      Can someone please clarify is GST is to be paid by the Property owner for premises given on rent for commercial purpose? If yes, is the owner required to file for GST as regular or Composition deal...

      By SHAILESH RAO
      /
    • GST for aerated/energy drinks

      I recently downloaded the latest price list from Amway's newly launched website and was shocked to see all their energy drinks were charged @ 40% ( price list attached). Could someone please let me...

      By Neeru Sood
      /
Share
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)