Modi is wrong about Zuckerberg

This visit is not about an ashram or finding inner peace. Facebook's founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg is coming to India for one sole reason - to push the agenda of free basics, much to the chagrin of IT heads, which he describes as "Internet.Org".

Critics claim that Internet.Org strikes a dagger straight into the heart of the very fabric of the World Wide Web as we know it. They say it breaks the sanctity of net neutrality. The idea that everything on the internet should be offered to everyone in an equal way.

If you Google the term, you will find a more elaborate and sophisticated definition: "The principle that internet service providers should enable access to all content and applications regardless of the source, and without favouring or blocking particular products or websites." basically breaks net neutrality by offering certain services (apps), which Facebook describes as "free basics for free", while other service prviders will be charged for it.

Here's what makes it a potentially a brilliant but manipulative move.

Say tomorrow, if a new social network comes up and has the potential to usurp Facebook, it will never get the opportunity because Facebook will now be available to all for free, while the rest of the people will need to pay for data for anything that competes with it.

Earlier in the year, multiple media houses tied up with, but after a massive furore was created over Airtel breaking net neutrality rules with its "Zero" programme, all of them had to take to a step back, to not invite the same scrutiny.

Mark Zuckerberg is here to host a Town Hall session at IIT Delhi, the breeding ground for India's brightest engineers, and he's sure to riff on how Facebook will be "providing free connectivity to rural parts of the country, helping educate people as they get access to essential services and websites..."

Don't be fooled by this.

Facebook is right now battling with Google to take control of the internet. It has designs that one day people will use Facebook for everything, not just social networking. It wants Facebook to be the gateway to the World Wide Web, just the way Google search has been.

For the same, it is now boldly makes two billion posts public, which also includes things shared with friends of friends searchable. All this while it is dabbling with drones to provide cheap internet to unconnected parts of the word, just like Google's Project Loon, which strives to do the same with balloons.

This a battle to become the new internet - it ends the free nature of things Sir Tim Berners Lee invented 26 years ago out of CERN on a computer made by the company Steve Jobs founded after being ousted from Apple.

If you don't believe me, read what the guy who invented the World Wide Web, Mr Lee, had to say in the Guardian, earlier this month:

"When it comes to compromising on net neutrality, I tend to say just say no. In the particular case of somebody who's offering... Something which is branded internet, it's not internet, then you just say no. No it isn't free, no it isn't in the public domain, there are other ways of reducing the price of internet connectivity and giving something... (only) giving people data connectivity to part of the network deliberately, I think is a step backwards."

Need I say more? more  

View all 51 comments Below 51 comments
Hi Amit,

Ranvir More has left you a message on WAYN.

Read the message:

All the best,
The WAYN Team

To stop receiving invite requests from Ranvir More, click here:

To stop receiving any notifications from WAYN, click here: more  
We are going too far. Net-neutrality will continue in India till peoples' pressure is there. Facebook will not be able to throttle everyone. There will new innovation. Facebook is not the last one. more  
Facebook is worst. Should be immediately banned in India. more  
Well said. It is time to boycott Facebook. Present day political managers tend to bring and help Americans to control internet. Net neutrality will be in danger. more  
Indian Government Beware!! Compromisinf on Net Nuetrality for a few dollars for rural connectivity will jeopardise entire free access to WWW. the offer from Zuckerberg is loaded more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Budget 2021-22 Suggestions Invited

      Government has invited suggestions for the Budget 2021-22 from public. I have given following suggestions: 1. Raise income tax exemption limit to Rs.10Lakhs without any deductions. 2. No ...

    • Bhopal and Indore worsening

      Our govt and us the people have just messed up again. Covid cases again rising in Bhopal and Indore. Self inflicted pain. Why are major cities of India not going into a lockdown. LocalCircles ...

      By Aditi Mitra
    • Appreciation

      I want to share a few words of appreciation to all circle members and esp LocalCircles management for the wonderful work you all are doing and not refraining from asking tough questions on many Iss...

      By Ajay Mittal
    • Managing post festival COVID-19 surge with localised shutdowns/lockdowns

      Many of you have been actively sharing views on lockdowns and Unlocking and managing the COVID-19 situation and LocalCircles has been escalating them to the Government. Post festive season surge in...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Fantasy Gaming being brought under regulation

      Heartened to read that the Govt has accepted our suggestion and fantasy gaming is being considered for regulation. See attached.

      By Shikha Jain
    • Covid Warrior concept supported by research

      Some time back there was a survey in our circle about issuing id cards to covid recovered individuals which hasnt been implemented by Govt.

      By Harsimran Kaur
    • Consumer Festive Spending on Made in China products declined

      Thanks to all members who participated in the survey on chinese products purchased during the festive season. The survey results (link below) suggest that only 29% consumers purchased Chinese produ...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Draft Advertising Code: Inputs Sought

      Many of you are aware that with your participation, LocalCircles has been single handedly fighting against Misleading Advertisements. Though the Ministry of Consumer Affairs issued draft advertisin...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Solution for Cross Border Imports via eCommerce channel

      Many of you are familiar with how LocalCircles in last 12 months has worked with various departments of the Government to stop misuse of India's postal and courier gift channel by Chinese ecommerce...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Insider Trading Violations in Indian Financial Markets: Issues

      Some of you over the last 1 year have raised the issue of insider trading norms violation in Indian financial markets. Insider trading norm violation may mean company promoters or board members tra...

      By LocalCircles Manager
    • Happy Diwali 2020!

      Many of you have regularly shared your posts and comments on various issues over the last 10 months. As a result, via our efforts together, we have worked with the Government on lockdown, unlocking...

      By LocalCircles Manager
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)