Laundering Model, Why Disclosure Scheme will fail

Assume person X approaches agent Y to change a stash of Rs 10 lakhs in old currency notes into new ones. Agent Y has a clutch of bank accounts that he operates. He deposits Rs 2 lakhs in old currency notes in the account that is in the name of A. Since the amount is below Rs 2.5 lakhs, A will not be asked to explain the source of his money.

Agent Y uses RTGS to transfer Rs 2 lakhs to the account of B, and also deposits Rs 2 lakhs in old currency notes into that account. This Rs 4 lakhs amount is then transferred to C’s account, into which another Rs 2 lakhs in cash is deposited. The Rs 6 lakhs that has accumulated is now transferred to D’s account, which is then replenished with a cash deposit of Rs 2 lakhs. The accumulated Rs 8 lakhs is transferred to agent Y’s account (or for that matter, in E’s account) where another Rs 2 lakhs is added.

Agent Y now has Rs 10 lakhs, which is the amount person X had given the agent to exchange from old to new. Y transfers the amount to X. He shows in his books that Rs 10 lakhs has been given as a loan to X.

A few days later, X issues a cheque of Rs 10 lakhs to agent Y, or electronically transfers the amount to Y’s account. In his books, Y then shows that the loaned money has been returned. He will withdraw Rs 10 lakhs once the limit on withdrawal is lifted in January 2017. The amount he will receive will be in new currency notes.

It is considered safer if X and Y are relatives or have had business relationships in the past. After all, nobody lends Rs 10 lakhs to an unknown person.

It is very unlikely for income-tax authorities to become suspicious of such transactions, let alone track them, as the amount being shifted from one account to another is not high.

But it is also because the accounts agent Y operates will have no past record of having been served income-tax notices. It is well known that once an assessee comes on the radar of income-tax authorities, they are routinely served notices for at least five years – and their transactions are scrutinised.

Agent Y will then take a cut, say, 30% of the Rs 10 lakhs and hand over the remaining Rs 7 lakhs to person X. Thus, Rs 3 lakhs is the hair-cut person X took to convert his Rs 10 lakhs in old currency notes into new ones. But X’s Rs 7 lakhs is still black money.

For person X, the transaction makes economic sense. In case the government’s legislative proposal of November 28 is accepted, he would have to pay 50% of Rs 10 lakhs as tax, that is, Rs 5 lakhs, and deposit another 25% or Rs 2.5 lakhs in interest-free deposits for four years. Therefore, all that he gets in hand is Rs 2.5 lakhs, though it would be deemed as white money.

Since no interest accrues on deposits, inflation would erode the real value of Rs 2.5 lakhs that X is liable to receive after four years. Given that he is habituated to hoarding cash, he is likely to prefer keeping the Rs 7 lakhs he has received in cash, or divert it to buy property, than disclose his concealed wealth to the government. more  

View all 60 comments Below 60 comments
People bent upon breaking rules will always find innovative methods. In all type of medicinal systems, there will be side effects but that does not detract need to administer medicine for the decease. Black economy and corruption are a canker to the economy and the government has bitten the bullet sacrificing short term goals for long term gains. Only time will tell the success or failure of the scheme more  
People should be forced to bank online or through cheques.At an appropriate time it is better to withdraw currencies of Rs500 and above which are mostly used to hoard black money. more  
Why should the Income tax department allow person A to give loan to person B and to C and so on. The IT act should be changed so that such loans have to be given at the bank rates and not free. and all beneficiaries have to declare and file such income (however small) and pay tax on the interest earned. This will curb the practice of the Loan channel for money laundering. Remember the 2G Scam and other cases where large sum of money was given as a loan and some of the recipients never paid any interest or declared such receipts. If proper accounting practices are maintained then flow of money and cash can be tracked and the paperwork makes it difficult for any one to plea ignorance. more  
In order to improve the transparency in the Governance - 1.Demonetisation is one of the major method that is adopted first time.This should be followed by discontinuing high value denomination currency such as Rs 500 and Rs 2000as a next step 2.On line payment/payment by various bank instruments should get a big support,and,should be made mandatory 3.Tax laws should be simplified and Inspector Raj should get discontinued.Let there be an surprise audit by expert team periodically inspecting various businesses,which would get signalled,through the system 4.With in a year or two,we will lead the world. more  
I think as a routine all large notes should be demonetised every two years. Say these 2000 Rs notes be demonetised and only 500 Rs notes may remain. Next two years the 500 Rs notes be demonetised and only 100 Rs notes may remain. The cost of demagnetisation may be the penalty we have to pay for removing black money. Slowly over a period the black economy shall vanish. US demonetised ALL high value currency during Nixon and have now only 100 $ bills. There is no problem as all high & low value transactions are through bank/credit cards.... I know we take coffee also by card. We have to reach that stage. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • TCS rules on foreign expenditures is a mess

      The new TCS rules for foreign expenditure in force from 1st Oct are a massive mess! No one knows what is to be followed. Instructions are not clear; there seem to be so many interpretations resulti...

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Convenience fee being charged for digital

      You use any ticket booking site app they are charging 4-10% as convenience fee for making the booking digitally. How is Digital India working then. Has the Govt not acted on localcircles...

      By Sneha Goyal
    • Service Charge needs to be gotten rid of

      Some of these restaurants owners are really dumb people who despite such strong consumer sentiment against service charge still want to levy it

      By Naina Mittal
    • Mobile Number portability problems

      Glad LC Manager took up this survey on mobile number porting

      By Shikha Chhabra
    • Cricket World Cup Tickets Scam

      BCCI or whosoever is selling online tickets via bookmyshow and other websites you are likely doing big scam. Ahmedabad match, capacity 135000, ticket was sold out within minute. However ...

      By Dinesh Shah
    • Regulating child access to social media OTT and online gaming

      Is the need of the hour. I am amazed at the fact that many of the mainstream media channels and papers are refraining from talking about it. Perhaps there is vested interest. Super glad ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Junk consumption soaring only bad to follow

      Varun Beverages sold 480 Cr Litres of Pepsi and other Beverages in FY23 Dominos India sold 6.7 cr to 7.83 cr Pizzas in FY23 Pizza hut India (Sapphire) sold abou...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Are we going to have a rabies and dog bit epidemic

      LocalCircles Manager and members are doing excellent work in sensitising the Government to take dog bite menace seriously and on the other hand we have officers like District Magistrate Noida who a...

      By Radha Puri
    • Banking difficulties of people

      Thrilled to see LocalCircles banking difficulties survey in multiple english hindi news papers yesterday.

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Appeasing minorities by giving vehicle subsidies

      Is a really wrong policy that is being deployed bh Karnataka Government. The only way such subsidies must be given is based on economic status (basis tax returns) and not caste. We all r...

      By SN Mittal
    • Kudos LocalCircles

      Great work on bank malpractices and escalating this issue to RBI. All members who have a loan need to save the attached notification in their mobile/computer. Your bank will now have to...

      By Shikha Jain
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)