Lift accidents-My take

This refers to the post by Mr. Suri and polls on electric lifts following a recent accident. It was mentioned in the post that we should have a Mandatory lift Act and a body supervising all the lifts in India. As an electrical engineer having some knowledge of this type of equipment, I can say that there is already a comprehensive Indian (BIS) Standard 14665 in 4 parts (2000 and amendments) which supersedes several older standards and includes a LEGALLY BINDING part on the maintenance of this equipment. The Chief Electrical Inspector (CEIG) of the concerned State is responsible for enforcement and inspection along with all the other electrical installations of a facility.

As usual, the problem is not about Acts/Rules. There are enough rules and BIS constantly updates them in line with international (IEC) codes. As stated in the post, the problems are corruption and lack of oversight. Even if all requirements are met, there could be some graft involved. But in case of violations, the amount may increase substantially for ignoring them. No amount of laws and Acts will ever serve the purpose of ensuring safety under these conditions.

In addition to prosecuting the owner of the premises, there must be strict penalties to the maintenance agency and inspecting official who inspected and last certified the lift, especially if the failures involve safety provisions being overlooked. There must be proper records of inspection and photographic proof of each inspection to pinpoint the responsibility (because it is possible that in spite of the best intentions components can and do fail between inspections) even when everything is done by the book. This is where the additional fee charged by the manufacturers would help because they know their equipment best. Proper records of work done must be maintained and must be available with all the parties.

In short, there is no substitute for professionalism at work. more  

View all 11 comments Below 11 comments
A no. of societies are being run by a handful of individuals and their coteries, who not only lack in basic technical of housing equipment, but also extant rules/ regulations. They are guided by their whims and fancies, relies on mistiries for technical advice.For example: 1) flower tub (watering) was put inside the lift, 2) doormats of micro-fibre was placed on the floor, 3) emergency (rescue) key hole has been almost blocked, while putting wall tiles, etc. more  
I have not seen any inspection on lift being done in a particular building for the last 27 years...yes that building owners have AMC with Karnataka government approved electrical contractor... government employees knows that nothing will happen to their jobs, it is safe. In private sector now a days OTP link services are provided to confirm whether work done or not because private sector employees have accountibility... more  
In Mumbai the lift inspectors plight is that even if they inspect 10 lifts a day (which they dont) they will be able to visit a building once every four or five years. Mechanical/Electrical equipment like lifts require preventive maintenance and safeguards on a regular basis. A comprehensive overhual which includes replacing ropes, cables, switches is needed every 7 to 10 years. The pulleys, brakes and safety holds need physical inspection and replacement (not repair) once a decade. The carriage way and the cabin also need overhaul. People tend to take a casual view of this but neglect and disrespect of equipment is the recipe for disaster waiting to happen. Having new laws are not going to help. We need the private sector to be empowered to carry out inspections and wok on behalf of the regulator. more  
Authorized persons only should attend from recognized service providers registered under service and maintenance agencies act, These persons shall be on paid rolls with points to credit for quality contributions and timely deliveries. more  
@Balachandran S: Import of lifts should be allowed subject to the condition that authorised service agencies who will supply genuine parts must be are there in India. After all there are many imported equipment (Laptops, Train sets, Aircraft to mention a few) operating in India. Imported lifts should be certified for conformity to IS or IEC equivalent standards by official certifying agencies). more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Motor Insurance Claims are messed up

      Did you know that over 10.46 lakh motor accident claims worth Rs 80,455 Crore are pending across India? Data suggests it takes an average 4 years for disposal of 1 claim. Li...

      By Bharat Lal
    • State of Fire Safety in India

      This saturday and sunday was depressing news of gaming zone and children hospital having fires. Glad LC has released its survey on fire safety and i am shocked that only 2 in 10 of us ha...

      By Seema Shah
    • Excellent assessment of power outages in India

      So the below LocalCircles survey I read on Bloomberg International says 38% households in India are still facing daily outages.

      By Mukul Puri
    • Full ban on Gutkha and Pan Masala - action needed

      The Commissioner of Food Safety Telangana has issued a notification (attached) prohibiting the manufacture, storage, distribution, transportation and sale of

      By Venkata Lukka
    • Spices Safety Survey

      Though fssai has come out and said that spices sold in domestic markets dont have ethylene oxide carcinogens issue (6 tests awaited) the problem is credibility of fssai as an institution.

      By Shailesh Deshmukh
    • Airport charges getting ridiculous

      Travelling to Bengaluru airport has become more expensive. BIAL has imposed an entry fee for both private and commercial vehicles. Cabs to pay Rs 150 for up to 7 min, Rs 300 for more.

      By Ashima Gupta
    • Underage Drunken Driving

      2 people killed day before here in Pune after a Porsche car, driven by a 17-year-old minor, crashed into their motorcycle in Pune. Accused granted bail within 15 hours. Look bail conditi...

      By Asha Rathi
    • In life threatening situations can one counterattack a dog

      See attached video where a Cop shoots at dogs trying to maul a person in Philadelphia United States. What is the legal position in India for police in such scenarios? Didn’t find ...

      By Nikita Mehra
    • Lift safety issues persist

      Yesterday in Noida a lift went through the tower roof because of maintenance negligence. See attached.

      By Radha Puri
    • Hallmarking of Gold Jewellery

      This latest survey of LC is good as it helps consumers in not getting cheated or misled https:...

      By Aditi Mitra
    • Why no red label on brain damaging products like Coke and Pepsi

      Why is the Government not putting front of the pack red labels on drinks like pepsi and coke. 10 year olds are drinking 5-6 glasses in a birthday party. Drinking Coca-Cola or Pepsi: This...

      By Shikha Chhabra
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)