Inputs on Penalty for not carrying identification

As outlined earlier, to minimize agent/tout misuse Railways has decided to make carrying of identification mandatory for all adult passengers. Here are some of your key inputs on penalties that can be imposed:

1. Penalty of Rs. 1000 may be imposed for travelling without an identity card
2. The penalty could be equivalent to the tatkal fare of that segment
3. Penalty could be 3 times the price of the ticket
4. It could be charged at a flat rate of Rs. 500 per incident
5. The fine could be based on the class in which the passenger is travelling like equivalent to the fare.

If you have any additional inputs on penalties that can be imposed which will not inconvenience the valid passenger but address the misuse by agents/touts, please share. Also, if there are any solutions that will minimize the added TTE discretion in such cases, please share your views.

We are also reviewing some additional inputs from members on other ways to address this misuse.

Thanks for your inputs. more  

View all 438 comments Below 438 comments
I agree with @ dharam jee, & Why can't Railway be penalised for the offences & lapses? @Harish Jee, will tell as how Airport is enforcing the same ID-System? Have any one penalised by them ? more  
Carrying an ID card is prevelent all over the world to keep a vigil on terrorist activities and must be strictly implemented in India like it is for all flights . A person travelling in public transport ( Flight Train Bus) must have a valid ID to board the public transport. more  
I feel minimum fine has to be Rs 2000 for travelling on fake tickets and Rs 5000 on TTE for failing to do his duty . Two armed constable must accompany the TT in the initial phase may be up to 6months. No fine No improvement . We Indians have in the last 68 years destroyed all institutions by this Chalta hai attitude. more  
Rlys are acting very arbitrarily in fixing the penalties for various
acts.....carrying ID's,cancellation of tickets......let the Rlys justify such atrocious penalties for cancellations.....it is time a Users Orgn is formed who can seek redressal in courts with PILs etc more  
I have travelled a number of times.Most of the occasions,the TTE
is not interested in verifying my ID,though I volunteer to show my identity.I am now 82+.ID of other younger people are also not verified. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • So now at the end Railways wakes up

      Says mask is mandatory in trains and on station otherwise 500 ka challan katega. Attached circular. I think India Railways coaches must be deployed now in all impacted areas to serve as...

      By RN Chopra
      /
    • Now you cant charge your phone at night in trains

      Rail passengers will not be able use charging facility in trains between 11 pm and 5 am anymore. The latest attached order of the Railways comes from a 7 year old study. Problem is that why did the...

      By Bharat Lal
      /
    • DFC (Dedicated Freight Corridor) in India

      Dedicated Freight Corridor: Recently there was so much news regarding the DFC project connecting between Mumbai & Delhi (about 1500 kms in length, project costing $4 Bn, land acquisi...

      By Sivagnanam Duraisamy
      /
    • Increase in passenger fares by 2-3 times

      पैसेंजर ट्रेन का किराया 2-3 गुना बढ़ाने का निर्णय इस दौर में दैनिक यात्रा करने वाले छात्रों, नौकरीपेशा लोगों समेत गरीब परिवारों के लिए बहुत बड़ा झटका है। कोविड काल में कमाई कम हुई, महंग...

      By Arjun Singh
      /
    • Farmers and Risk to Railways

      The farmer unions are saying that about 1,000 farmers had boarded the Punjab Mail on Sunday night at Ferozepur, Punjab to join others at the Delhi borders. Railways saying 3 trains were ...

      By Shirisha Kumar
      /
    • Corruption rules, cityzens pay more for corrupts

      It is universal truth that a minimum of ten percent o all tenders go to railway babus before issuing the work order and every one in Railway from Peon to Chairman share this loot. As a result cost ...

      By SUBHASH PARAKH
      /
    • MAKE RAILWAY BETTER

      Railway has stopped senior citizen concession in upper class, (1st class & executive chair class) This must be revied. Leaders enjoys full concession in all class. Hence citizens who paid ...

      By Bahadur Sanjana
      /
    • Railway Subsidy for every person to nil

      I would like to say that the government employees who are on the railway should be retire after a further limit so that the new generation gets a chance. And the railway tickets that are being impo...

      By Sanjiv Pathak
      /
    • Railways need to cut cost drastically

      Railway Ministry earned Rs 3322 CR from passenger earnings till Oct 2020 due to covid19 pandemic; 90% lesser than previous year revenue generated from passenger services Chairman railwa...

      By Ajay Mittal
      /
    • RPF guidelines for travellers (attached)

      Railway Protection Force has issued guidelines for travellers as the festive season is approaching. The general public is counselled to desist from the following acts or omission while being in rai...

      By Ministry Of Railways
      /
    • New Trains Starting and Peoples Experience

      Here’s the full list of 39 new trains that are starting soon friends. I would like to know your experience in last 4 months if you travelled in train. Will be useful for me to decide if we sh...

      By Amit Mishra
      /
Share
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)