Cabinet Reshuffle Overview by R. Jagannathan

What appeared to be a tepid attempt at a Cabinet reshuffle by Narendra Modi in the morning of Tuesday turned out to be a significant shake-up with political and performance overtones by the late evening. The sting of the shuffle was in portfolio allotment, not in the numbers inducted or sent packing.

While the Big Four Ministers — Home, Finance, Defence and External Affairs — seemed untouched, at least two of them were indirectly impacted by the major changes or inductions at the Minister of State (MoS) level. The big bang impact areas included HRD, Telecom, Rural Development, Law, Parliamentary Affairs, Civil Aviation and Textiles.
It would have been easy to dismiss the exercise as being done with the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections in mind, but this would be an overstatement. With 13 ministers from the state even after the fresh inductions this time, UP is just about adequately represented in the Modi Cabinet, given its sixth share in the population of India and the BJP's overwhelming number of MPs from this state.

So, despite some ritual obeisance to political compulsions, the broad focus of this exercise has been towards performance. Just as well, for Modi has less than three years in which he has to deliver a performance which can be "felt" by the people. What people know is he is earnest; what they are not sure about is whether they will benefit directly.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi with his new Cabinet ministers. PIBPrime Minister Narendra Modi with his new Cabinet ministers. PIB

The NDA under Atal Bihari Vajpayee had many achievements to his credit, but growth revived too late for it to be felt by voters. In contrast, UPA-1 took advantage of NDA-1's growth surge to coast along for five more years and claim the credit for it. Modi's challenge is to ensure that people feel the change at least two years before 2019 for them to believe he has delivered. This is why this Cabinet reshuffle is important, being the last major effort before the electorate makes up its mind.

The problem areas for the Modi government have been growth, rural distress, tepid improvement in jobs, and an uncorrected mess in education. The last mess was created by the UPA's deeply flawed Right to Education Act, its poorly thought-out decision to ban detentions of students till the eighth standard, and failure to get more foreign investment and expertise in higher education. Smriti Irani, despite being a feisty and aggressive minister, was not up to speed on this. She also had a tendency to wade into needless controversies, something that was distracting, given the nature of the challenges at hand. Her replacement with Prakash Javadekar, a low-profile and hard-working minister, will ensure that HRD focuses on essentials and not on the thrills.

Given her seeming proximity to the PM, Irani's shift from HRD sends a very powerful signal that proximity is not a substitute for delivery. She was shifted sideways to Textiles, another portfolio close to Modi's heart, given its scope for employment generation and its importance to Gujarat itself. This is not a demotion, but a move to make Irani less controversial and more useful.

The same message got sent in Finance, where Arun Jaitley, one of the two people said to be close to the PM apart from Amit Shah, lost his I&B portfolio to Venkaiah Naidu. Moreover, Jaitley's articulate and suave MoS Jayant Sinha has been shifted to Civil Aviation, and got two new Ministers of State in exchange. The message seems to be: focus on finance without distractions.

The elevation of Javadekar is a subtle hint on what kind of ministers Modi likes: the diligent worker who understands what Modi wants and then goes about the job without making waves. Javadekar deserves credit for achieving a fine balance between being business-friendly and yet not sacrificing green objectives, as India's aggressive global commitments on clean energy show. None of Modi's job-creating ministries — Roads, Railways, Infrastructure, and Energy — would have been productive without Javadekar's constructive support.

The next big changes relate to Telecom and Law. The pleasant, but ineffective Sadananda Gowda gets shunted out once again, from Law to Statistics. If there is one change that had politics written all over it, it is Gowda's retention in a Cabinet just for being a Gowda. His presence is important for the Karnataka elections in 2018. Other retentions indirectly related to politics are Najma Heptullah and Kalraj Mishra, both of whom could have been dispensed with after breaching the age barrier of 75 set by Modi. The UP election is the reason for not rocking their boats. The other political signal is the induction of Ramdas Athavale, a Dalit face. Athavale is a concession to Modi's need to woo Dalits and also a message to the Shiv Sena, which has been fuming about being reduced to a bit role in Maharashtra. With the Mumbai municipal elections due in 2017, the BJP and Sena are getting ready to part ways at the municipal level.

The shifting of Ravi Shankar Prasad to Law and divesting him of Telecom sends two signals: one positive, and one negative. The positive one is that Modi wants a heavyweight in the Law Ministry, given the eyeball-to-eyeball confrontation the executive is involved in with the judiciary over senior judicial appointments. Modi wants someone who can both bare his fangs and shake hands with the senior judiciary and get the latter to accept some role for the executive in judge selection and rejection. Prasad gets to keep Electronics and IT as consolation for losing Telecom.

The negative message to Prasad is that Modi doesn't want the Telecom Ministry to be at daggers drawn with the industry, which is a major revenue generator at spectrum auctions. Prasad's regular beating of the drum over call drops, which ended up in a judicial defeat, did not help. Modi wants an effective minister who will listen to industry and help pluck the spectrum revenue feathers gently without hurting the golden goose.
Manoj Sinha, who now gets Telecom, also retains his old MoS position at Railways. This is a vote of confidence in his work, and an invitation from Modi to do even better.

Jayant Sinha's transfer from Finance to Civil Aviation was a surprise, since he was seen to be on top of his job, but this lateral movement may have its own positive implications. Civil Aviation is now again in expansion mode, with the new policy allowing 100 percent FDI and foreign investments in brownfield airports, Modi probably sees airports as the new sunrise infrastructure sector over and above roads, shipping and railways. But Civil Aviation has a Telugu Desam man heading it, and shifting Sinha to the same ministry may mean Modi wants his agenda to be part of the ministry's growth focus.

The other noteworthy features include Venkaiah Naidu swapping Parliamentary Affairs for I&B, and Ananth Kumar getting Parliamentary Affairs as an extra portfolio.

The induction of MJ Akbar as MoS in External Affairs indicates the importance Modi attaches to diplomacy. With Modi himself leading from the front and Sushma Swaraj doing a low-profile but excellent job in the ministry, the addition of Akbar will add heft to diplomacy at a time when India is planning to play a larger role on the global stage. India has its work cut out both in the Arab world, now roiled by terrorism, and in Asia, where the China-Pakistan alliance is a threat to India's rise.
Modi clearly wants performance to be the guiding factor in his ministry. Despite an alleged premium on loyalty, he has not shied away from making changes even in ministries headed by people seen as close to him. The big miss was in Agriculture, a sector that needs very good stewardship given its myriad problems and poor past attempts at effective policy-making. This is a gap that Modi has to plug, for half of India is still dependent on agriculture. He should not leave all the problems to the rain gods to solve. more  

View all 38 comments Below 38 comments
Smirithi Irani has made the HRDE ministry alive.Talk about her qualifications from the start itself gave many people to comment on her.But she has stood firmly and faced it.No body has questioned Indira Gandhi/Sonia Gandhi about their credentials.When people are allowed to talk then they go to the extreme. In a democratic country one should be satisfied with dynamism and zeal to deliver good things in coordination with secretaries concerned.She has handled all the issues correctly. The media still have their bias to side along the blowing wind. more  
Very well analysed Mr Suri. By and large he has given importance to performance. Best part of reshuffle is removing Samriti from HRD. She has created too many controvercies. hopefully she does better job in textile ministry. more  
No doubt, Modi means business and that too in a jiffy. He has set his goal for 2019 General election. With time running out he cannot take chances with delivery of promises made. Mr Suri has penned down a razor cut analysis of the reshuffle. Jaihind more  
An Apt article written by Mr Rajesh Suri and throws a focused light on the event. more  
The improvements and the effective discussion about the bill, and the way powerful bills are passed in the house will tell the power of reshuffle in the parliament which people are expecting to watch in the current winter session. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Big Hospitals have been looting us

      CCI investigation has found that Max, Fortis, Apollo & other big hospital chains have been overcharging patients They've been charging excessive prices for rooms, medicines, medical ...

      By Naina Mittal
    • Can we get the Govt to take masking seriously

      India is making a grave mistake by taking Covid lightly. This Covid is a mass disabling event and T-Cell experts estimate that every infection reduces life by 7-12 years.

      By Nishat Khan
    • Again rising prices of vegetables

      As festival seasons comes, again: Tomato-Rs 60/kg Potato - Rs 40/ kg Dhaniya -Rs 500/kg Can we please take up this issue with the Government and can we all quickly g...

      By Radha Puri
    • Cap on excessive convenience fee

      What a solid report LocalCircles on reducing convenience fee levied on us commoners for every small thing. Train ticket to movie ticket, even sarkari national park bookings, utility payments, trave...

      By RN Chopra
    • Big kudos to Localcircles on medicine price control

      The Govt has taken Localcircles issue of high medicine prices to action. It has included Dexamethasone, Enoxaparin, Methylprednisolone, Paracetamol, Oxygen to the list essential medicines for COVI...

      By Sanjana Gupta
    • Stop advertising targeted at kids

      Some time back LocalCircles had conducted survey on whether advertising targeted at kids under 16 be stopped. Most of the ads that use kids to advertise are selling ultra processed foods...

      By Dipali Yadav
    • Removal of all convenience fee for digital transactions with Govt

      Can LocalCircles please escalate this to the Govt at the earliest. I saw the other post on convenience charges by IRCTC PVR and many others and none of these are legitimate in these digital times. ...

      By Sangita Baruah
    • Problems in succession and inheritance transfer

      With the covid pandemic, sudden deaths have become very common and it is still so difficult to transfer land to blood relations. The whole process is ridden with corruption. I searched i...

      By Radheshyam Gupta
    • Adulterated Milk

      Like there is so much fruit vegetables adulteration there is a lot of milk adulteration that is taking place in India. From detergents to white paint all kinds of substances are added in what we dr...

      By Sangita Baruah
    • Covid compliance during travel

      I know atleast 5-7 people in friends and family who got infected with covid on flight (very high certainty) The LocalCircles survey below says 45% people will travel in just the next 60...

      By Shikha Maheshwari
    • VIP culture experience

      Recently I visited a Central Government office in Delhi. There were some toilets with a code there. They will open only if you key in the code. These toilets are super clean and well maintained. On...

      By Vijaya Nair
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)