An attack on citizens/democracy

In the local circles I remember participating in discussions on data protection and our privacy. With what has been reported with pegasus, i feel that there should be a judicial enquiry and truth must come out. The below editorial by HT is a good and honest perspective by a newspaper who these days are generally shy to say anything against those in power. Do share your views.

On Sunday evening, an international network of media organisations, assisted by a network of international civil society organisations, broke a story about State surveillance as a part of a series called The Pegasus Project.

They reported that the phone numbers of 40 journalists (including three from this newspaper), two ministers (including the new minister for information technology, Ashwini Vaishnaw), three Opposition figures (including Rahul Gandhi), political consultant-turned-politician Prashant Kishor, officials (including former election commissioner Ashok Lavasa), a Supreme Court judge, and business figures were on a list of potential targets for surveillance at different points in the last four years. The phone devices of some individuals, subjected to forensic analysis, indicated the presence of an infection or an attempted hack. If the allegations of widespread surveillance are true, they represent an unacceptable and illegal invasion of the right to privacy, right to liberty, and the right to dignity of all those targeted; the series also throw up deeply disturbing questions about the source of the hack and represents a subversion of India’s constitutional democracy.

Developed by the Israeli firm NSO, Pegasus is an extraordinarily sophisticated technology that can, once it infects a phone, gain access to calls (including on encrypted platforms), contacts, app passwords, browsing history, microphone and camera which can capture off-line conversations, and even plant evidence, as alleged in the Bhima Koregaon case. To be sure, the mere presence of a number does not indicate a hack. The list is only of potential targets. Forensic analysis has been limited, and also inconclusive in certain cases. The Government of India (GOI) has denied allegations of illegal surveillance, and claimed all interceptions are as per law and due process — though it does leave room open to ask if GOI has purchased Pegasus and deployed it. NSO, which maintains that it sells the software only to “vetted governments” for countering terror and crime, termed the allegation baseless, and claimed that the 50,000 listed numbers (internationally) may be for other purposes. But its chief executive, Shalev Hulio also said that allegations of misuse were concerning and if true, violate the relationship of trust with customers, ie governments.

The gravity of the allegations and its implications for Indian democracy are enormous. If the Indian government has done this, it is a betrayal of the constitutional compact with citizens. If another government has done it, it is a cyber attack on India and its citizens.

Either way, there must be a truly independent judicial enquiry to get to the truth and hold those responsible for this violation of fundamental rights accountable. more  

View all 21 comments Below 21 comments
Such allegations had been made on the governments in office in the past as well. Merely reading a story published in a news paper, we need not to be so irritated to the extent of asking for a judicial probe. Such acts are not new and happening all over the world. more  
HT is seems to be biased paper. more  
It is simply an attempt to keep busy in fake informations.they don't let govt to work productive.govt.should not give any weightage to such people but such people are required to be taken to the task more  
The prime post above, though not reeking; carries a faint smell of purpose to agitate people's minds. Seems to be a step towards upsetting system that otherwise is on the right path. It's hoped that this isn't a ploy to force govt & the nation to waste costly resources after handling some quixotic affair. more  
HT does not appear to be a non-political paper. more  
It is just a political propaganda to remain in news by politician. Masses have nothing to secure. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Whats going on with airlines

      2-3 spicejet incidents, go first incident then now Raipur Indor indigo flight and then vistara flight engine fails after landing in Delhi. Hope its not a set up as jhunjhunwala launches ...

      By Ankita Jain
    • What airlines are you wary of from safety stand point?

      Excellent subject of survey from LocalCircles. Everyone may please vote and share. So many incidents in the last 3-4 days itself

      By Shivani Batra
    • Too many spicejet safety incidents

      In last 6 months several spicejet safety incidents have come to light and todays flight to Jabalpur SG 2962 Q400 incident where smoke came inside aircraft was another one. Attached video.

      By Aditi Mitra
    • Giving right of way to emergency vehicle

      When traffic comes to a halt in Germany, drivers by law must move to the edge off each side to create an open lane so emergency vehicles like ambulance, fire brigade can pass . This type of road ed...

      By Sarita Ravichandran
    • Masking in flights or on no fly list

      Great work circle members and LC manager in getting Govt to act against people who dont mask on flights. Attached notification has been issued and if anyone is not masking on flight and at airport...

      By Vinita Agrawal
    • Our daughters on instagram reels

      Of late, I have noticed a very disturbing trend.. Girls, barely 10-12 years old are posting videos (Reels) on Instagram of them gyrating to Bollywood numbers making lewd gestures.. Thei...

      By Amod Agarwal
    • What to do if Your Car is Flooded

      Since the monsoons will soon be upon us and LocalCircles is doing water logging surveys, I will today share some steps to help you get through the process of resuscitating your flood-damaged car. I...

      By Anita Chaturvedi
    • Children developing hepatitis post Covid

      Over 300 children around the month have developed hepatitis which Doctors suspect is post covid condition. Hepatitis is simply an inflammation of the liver that can result in a variety ...

      By Sarita Ravichandran
    • Ola scooters are plain dangerous

      Please see attached. If anyone in your family has booked them, sell them second hand or junk them. I dont know what authorities in India are doing if this was in USA OLAs factory have been shut by ...

      By Shirisha Kumar
    • Exodus of Anti social Elements in Ahmedabad

      I am being lured by some anti social elements in Ahmedabad with the help of their counterparts near my residence in Bodakdev. Earlier since 2006, here was severe harrasment, now they are luring me ...

      By Rajesh Iyer
    • women-fashion 154 /customer -care /number⑨①⓪②①②④⑤③⑧

      women-fashion 154 /customer -care /number⑨①⓪②①②④⑤③⑧ women-fashion 154 /customer -care /number⑨①⓪②①②④⑤③⑧

      By nnuu Kumar
Enter your email and mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

All My Circles
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)