States mandating reservation for residents in private companies: Inputs Sought

Recently Andhra Pradesh announced that state residents will have 75% reservation in all jobs including all private companies. Subsequently, MP announced a similar 70% reservation for locals in all jobs including private companies. Other states may follow this trend too for political mileage. We would like to seek your inputs on whether this is good, ok or a dangerous trend that will keep businesses and capital away from such states. Also, if you have additional inputs on the current Caste based Reservation or the newly proposed 10% Economic States based Reservation, kindly share the same as well.

For reference, below are the issues that some of you had outlined with how reservation works in India. We look forward to your inputs!

Reservation System:Key Issues
1.Caste based Reservations are the biggest enemy of meritocracy
2.Caste based reservation system leads to breeding of corruption
3.Beneficiaries under this system are taking advantage of it
4.It leads to undeserving people getting jobs, promotions, admissions in schools\/colleges, etc.
5.On the other hand, it leads to deserving people being left in a state of lurch
6.This also leads to brain drain and capable people looking for jobs elsewhere
7.People with caste based reservations get an upper hand when it comes to jobs
8.Selection criterion for them are set at low standards
9.People get good government jobs through their quota but are not able to do justice to their work
10.Families who are financially pretty well off also use the quotas and try to rake in as much as possible
11.This reservation system propagates politics and causes many demonstrations leading to violence. more  

View all 884 comments Below 884 comments
1. Reservation to locals by few states for vote bank, is not good for national interest.
2. This will open the floodgates for reservation in other states.
3. Most of the jobs are concentrated in state capitals.
4. Peoples of Punjab and Haryana will be the sufferers as both the states have no state capitals and can not reserve jobs for their peoples in Chandigarh being UT.
5. Even 60:40% quota promised by Centre to the peoples of Punjab and Haryana while Chandigarh was declared a UT, has shrinked to11:9 % respectively.
6. Therefore Centre and judiciary should stop reservations or limit the job reservations for locals in all the states/UTs. more  
RESERVATION IN PRIVATE SECTOR MUST BE BANNED at National interest more  
Apart from this threat of local another new proposal from Karnataka politician has been to reserve jobs for Kannada speaking local only.
Where are we heading in70 it was Marathi manus in Bombay ,now Telengana, local non local, now Kannada speaking?Terrible feeling !
We find a mid way to assuage Local needs.
First survey local residents ,find suitability of qualification for the required job ,then take them on internship/trading/ probation and after six months either emploidpf suitable or send themback if they are not suitable.The rule must be made by industry and prior signature of candidate to agree to this stipulation taken.
Mostly caste based reservation in recruitment and promotion must be removed for the private job sector.This will give impetus for the industries.
Learning local language by employees working should be encouraged to avoid alienation of locals . more  
I already reiterated that 6/7 States are following JK AND HENCE Schedule 7 shall be Regulated for Strict compliance of Part III AND IV as guaranteed by Preamble of the Constitution. IT IS A MUST TO MAKE STATES BOUND TO CONSTITUTIONAL OBJECTIVES. more  
Reservation means an inefficient person is getting a job over and above a more competent and merited person.This should be totally stopped,otherwise a time will come when country will be ruled/controlled by most inefficient people and this may lead to brain drain as brilliant people may migrate to other countries. more  
3 decades back SC UPHELD that a more qualified person can best deliver the output. MANY OBJECT ORIENTED ORDERS/ JUDGMENTS since 1963 were set aside by Politically empowered Legislators.
Constitution must be amended to Authorize JUDICIARY AS INDEPENDENTLY RESPONSIBLE FOR PROMPT IMPLEMENTATION OF CONSTITUTIONAL MANDATES. more  
This is extremely dangerous. Besides, efficiency & employer freedom, worst damage will be more & more divide amongst us INDIANS on linguistic or regional lines in addition to various fault lines already existing. more  
If this is a new political trend, imagine the Global ramifications if each international country starts this type of reservations, what will happen to the cross country working citizens..
This ominous, dangerous trend must be nipped in the bud itself.... more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Insurance for Bank deposits

      Recently read in news papers that two persons died because of failure of PMC bank. One by heart attack and another by suicide due to apprehension of losing their hard earned money deposited in the ...

      By SN Sitaram
      /
    • Content of Online Platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hotstar, etc- Inputs Sought

      Recently some members raised the issue of lots of objectionable content and language being used in movies and more so in video series run by sites/apps like Netflix, Amazon...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Fixing the functioning of NGOs: Inputs Sought

      NGOs in India keep coming in lime light regularly for the wrong reasons. Be it the recent honey trap case in Madhya Pradesh where contracts worth hundreds of crores were being awarded to NGOs in ex...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Issues with various Insurance Services in India: Inputs Sought

      Below are some of the key issues listed by you in the past in regards to insurance in India. Kindly review and share any additional inputs you may have on the same. We look forward to your inputs a...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • What should the Government do to improve GST collection?

      As you may be familiar, the GST collection in September was at a 19 month low of 92,000 crores. The Government is looking at various options including increasing GST rates on some products, as wel...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Sensitizing Inspectors and Officers to facilitate EODB: Inputs Sought

      Many of you have been raising the issue of continued inspector raj despite some of the good governance initiatives being rolled out by the Central Government that minimise human interfaces. Below a...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Buying Groceries Online: Inputs on issues faced

      Many of you who have been in circles know how LocalCircles worked with Legal Metrology Department to make best before date disclosure for food products mandatory on ecommerce apps, sites....

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Is the black money back in the economy? Inputs Sought

      Many of you may remember that this circle was the first collective community to call for demonetisation Oct 31 - Nov 8, 2016 before it was announced by the Prime Minister on Nov 8.Per the...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • #MeToo - Sexual Harassment: How have things changed in the last 12 months?

      Exactly, a year ago, many of you participated in the polls on #MeToo Sexual Harassment at workplaces and shared your or your family member's experiences on the subject. The survey suggested that 78...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Need for Hotel Services Standards in India - Addl Inputs

      Last year, many of you participated in the consultation of issues regarding the Hotel industry in India Below are the key issues, root causes and solutions for the state of hotel industry in India...

      By LocalCircles Manager
      /
    • Article 354A make it bailable

      Dear Sir, Please note for grabbing land property and money in the house women in family plus in neighborhood are hatching plans and conspiracy to make fake cases on their blood relatives. Plea...

      By Pankaj Bansal
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)