TOOTHLESS CONSUMERS PROTECTION ACT

Signed 7/3000
Online Signatures: 7
To
MP AND UNION CONSUMER MINISTER
minister-ca@nic.in
Consumer Courts are doing yeoman service. However, the biggest drawback is the lack of powers of contempt of court which makes them a "toothless tiger". A case in point is our three cases in the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission UT Chandigarh. The cases were filed in July 2009. The Accused (Aashish Goel and Sumita Goel, Directors of the defrauding construction company M/s Castle Concrete Infrastructure Pvt LTD) absconded and the case was taken up ex-parte after due publication in the The Tribune. The State Commission gave the verdict in our favour in 2010. As the Accused failed to refund our money in consonance with the orders of the State Commission, we filed a case for execution. Again as the Two Accused failed to turn up the case was taken up ex-parte after due publication. The UT State Commission awarded 2.5 year's imprisonment and RS 10000/- fine to each of the two accused with a provisio that in failure to pay the fine imprisonment to be extended by another six months. ((EA/35/2011, EA/36/2011/ & EA/37/2012 of UT Commission Chandigarh refer). The UT Commission is unable to get it's orders implemented as the UT Police is not responding adequately. They either do not turn up on the date of hearing or come very late thus keeping the complainants waiting. Their patent response is that they could not locate the convicts and thereafter plead to the complainants to let them know about the whereabouts of the convicts. It is obvious that the complainants do not have the new location of the absconding convicts and it goes on from hearing to hearing. However, in June 2014 the complainants, with great effort could find out the location of the two convicts Katni (Madhya Pradesh), their residential address in Katni, the school their two sons studied, the details of the car etc and informed the UT SSP Dr Sukhchain Singh Gill personally who called DSP Central Shri Ashish Kapur, who was responsible for apprehending the Proclaimed Offenders. Complete details were given verbally and in writing to the DSP Ashish Kapur and Insp Udaipal Singh, Incharge PO Cell on 2nd July 2014. They said that the complainants had done great service to the Police and now it was their duty to apprehending the two convicts and bring them to justice. A team of 3 male and 2 female police personnel was sent to Katni on 12 the July 2014, after a gap of 10 days of the information being given to them. On reaching the designated house in Katni they reverted that the house was locked and the convicts had absconded again. The complainants approached the CJM Katni through friends, who ordered cordoning and search of the designated house by the Katni Police. Cordon and search was carried out early morning on 15th July 2014 and they found the convict Aashish Goel and the 5 police personnel in the house as they had allowed the second convict Sumita Goel with her 3 sons to escape. On being confronted by the local police a message was sent by the UT Police Personnel that they had apprehended the convict Aashish Goel and Sumita Goel was not in the house. On 17th July 2014, the complainants we're informed by Insp Udaipal Singh that the Police Party with the arrested Convict were at Allahabad Railway Station awaiting train to Chandigarh. However, as there was no further news about the arrival of the police party with the convict the complainants effort to get in touch with the DSP Aashish Kapur and Insp Udaipal Singh failed as they did not respond for the next two days. Finally, the complainants we're informed on 21st July 2014 that the Police Party was bringing the convict Aashish Goel in his Tata Safari, driven by the convict himself, and in the morning the Police Party stopped to freshen themselves up at a Petrol Station on the highway at Mathura and the convict escaped driving his own car while they were having tea and freshening themselves up. Ironically, the convict wasn't in handcuffs as the Police Party had gone without it. Thereafter, again the same old sequence by the UT Police in each monthly hearing continues in the UT State Commission month after month. In December 2015, the National Commission Chairman Justice Shri DKJain had visited the UT State Commission and the President of the UT State Commission very kindly had spoken about the Complainants' case to him. The Complainant was given an opportunity to meet and explain his plight in person to him. Both the Chairman National Commission and the President UT Commission we're very understanding and sympathetic towards the complainants but expressed their inability to do anything further to get the UT Police or the Chandigarh Administration to respond and act as the Commission did not have any powers to make them respond and act. They can not summon the UT IGP or the Home Secretary. The Police is not responsive. Had it the powers of the High Court the Police and Administrative Authorities of UT Chandigarh would have responded to save their necks but now they care two hoots. The feeling of helplessness was writ large on their faces. They promised they would try and make it a test case and see what can be done. All their best efforts seemingly get thwarted for want of Contempt of Court Powers. Unless, they have these powers the Consumer Protection Act, in spite of their best efforts, remains a toothless tiger. Hence, it is most fervently requested that the Consumer Protection Act be given adequate powers to get the authorities to show respect and respond & act promptly on the directions of the Consumer Courts. Without these powers the Consumer Protection Act remains helpless in resolving the problems of consumers.

Brig. Devender Garewal
Chandigarh
+91 99885 29930
The Petition was also marked to:
MoneyLife
 - editor@moneylife.in
 -  news@moneylife.in
 -  sales@moneylife.in
 -  mail@moneylife.in
S.C. findings ordering strict actions on Government Servants in neglect of their Duties ALSO ARE ALSO SET ASIDE by Political Rulers. It is shame on the part of the Governments becoming unable to carry Court Orders and Directions even on such issues of Finances and Goods . more  
Feb 20

Related Petitions

    • Boycott flipkart

      Flipkart sent me.a dead phone and I have been trying to replace it but they are not helping me in anyway . Even their technician have checked the product and approved the request. Still they are no...

      By Abhishek Mishra
      /
    • Malicious Candy bars

      I have been gifted Cadbury Celebration packet worth Rs. 150 on Rakshabandhan, when I opened the bar I was shocked when I saw molds formed all over it and white tags. The consumption of that bar can...

      By Akarsh Mittal
      /
    • Online Fraud shown Honor 5 Health Band in Advertisement and received M3 local Band

      I have ordered Honor Band 5 from Facebook Market place which cost paid ₹1900.00 and received Local Band cost approximately ₹300-₹500 Max. So I tried to connect with Mr. Aman Bakshi The Gadget Shop ...

      By Habib Shaikh
      /
    • Misleaded by builder

      Earlier phase 1 and 2 were developed and society also registered then builder has handover phase 3, now issue is who can collect maintenance charges for phase 3 if society caring for phase 3 like w...

      By Manish Kishor
      /
    • www.goibobo.com cheating passengers

      Hi Ashish, As I explained over the phone, the original booking was from Trivandrum to Jakarta on 20th June 2019 and based on my request to reroute the ticket to Kochi - Jakarta, Goibobo...

      By Gigi Abraham
      /
    • IRCTC iMUDRA looting.

      IRCTC iMUDRA is looting general public by not providing the obliged services.

      By Ravi Varma
      /
    • byjus is cheating with students rather then a proffesion they made education a bussiness .

      byjus charges a great amount for its educational products. They sales policy is very bad at the time of purchase they promise many things but after they breach that contact and many of students rem...

      By Team Endurance #
      /
    • How to stop Corruption

      Presently bribe system is a major headache for the development of the country. All individuals have to face and suffer at least once in their lifetime. So it is important to s...

      By Pradeesh Vilakkupadam
      /
    • Cheating gullible consumers by Bharthi airtel

      Airtel pack only talktime recharge shows as validity not applicable but after you recharge they send SMS stating validity is for 28 days when enquired many times they said it is applicable only for...

      By Suryakala Jayaraman
      /
    • Online shopping injustice

      I ordered a laptop from flipkart for rs 3571 they shipped my order and now flipkart cancelled the order without any reason it is only consumer injustice

      By Karan Goyal
      /
    • Unprofessional Movers & Packers

      Now a days for profession , people quite often move from one city to another , where they would need the services of reliable and professional packers & movers . But if the goods are received i...

      By Baldev Mamtani
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)