Why GST council giving builders an option

To choose between whether to charge GST rate of 12% and claim ITC for Apr 1 2018 to Mar 31 2019 versus mandatorily having to use 5% rate which is way forward.

What will happen is most of the builders will charge the high rate to home buyer but will not give ITC benefit.

So whats happening is Govt not trusting these builders like restaurant owners to pass gst benefits to consumers. So why give them the option for even 1 year. more  

View all 11 comments Below 11 comments
This should have not been done. However, keeping in view that the said period has already elapsed, the concerned authority should now ask the builders to submit details of such GST recovered from the buyers, benefit of ITC passed on to the customers and the amounts paid to the government. Stern action should be taken against the defaulters. more  
It is for avoiding legal hurdles as well as to avoid applying law from pre change. Unlike hotel business construction of housing project is long process. So to give equitable opportunity to all concerned stockholders the option is given. And has to abide by the option. The Home buyer can not claim ITC as he is the consumer. It is a fair implementation of the law. more  
Housing sector is now a prime sector, which is being encouraged by government, as it gives lots of employment to cross section of the society. The GST should be reduced or removed. more  
The restaurant ITC is difficult to calculate.
This does not mean the restaurants are not cheating, they do cheat and on a massive scale.
A restaurant typically prepares upwards of 50 snacks, if it also serves meals the preparations are more than 100. And the same ingredients are used in multiple cuisines
Let us consider simple case of MASALA DOSA. Here you have ingredients with GST rates of 0% to 28%, later being dry fruits. Typically there are about 8 ingredients for this, may be mor or less.
In order to calculate input GST they must know the quantities of each ingredient used and the purchasing prices of all the ingredients, which vary with the season.
Just imagine how a restaurant will standardise these inputs and GST.
The simplest thing would have been having a single GST rate for all food ingredients, say 5%. And it would have been possible to arrive at a reasonable Input GST.
Remember, in India the cost of goods vary widely from place to place. more  
Builders lobby is very strong and have attained expertise in arm twisting of buyers and
the Govt. The politicians can ill afford to ignore their demands as they need huge funds
to win elections and have interest in many projects. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • GST rate rejig

      I have been told by my industry association friends that Finance Minister listens to localcircles and takes interest in collective asks of this platform. I am not sure if this poll is be...

      By Sridhar Mohan
    • Govt to reward receipt taking and reporting

      I am so glad that the Government is so actively taking up complaints posting in this circle. Yesterday they fined Nestle 73 crores for profiteering, I believe was reported in this circle and they h...

      By Garima Sharma
    • GST

      already we are blocking the working capital by paying the advance GST for all imports, to get back from the market it takes minimum of 5 to 6 months. If further increase all small scale industries ...

      By Anonymous Circle member
    • GST Rate Increase

      Reading in the news that the Government is considering increasing gst rate from 5% to 6% for items in this bracket? Issues - Since the difference is small, will be very difficult to catch profiteer...

      By Ajay Dutta
    • Saving due to GST 320 per month

      Finance Ministry’s attached calculation is showing that due GST every household on average is saving 320 per month. Can everyone please review and share their feedback. Is it more ...

      By Sridhar Mohan
    • J and J profiteering of 2.3 Billion caught with circle efforts

      The National Anti-profiteering Authority is investigating Johnson & Johnson Pvt Ltd for not passing on the reduction in goods and services tax on a range of its products to customers, a governm...

      By Garima Sharma
    • Why are NAA profiteering orders getting stayed

      Why NAA is not being diligent on how hearings are done and orders are passed. 3 people do the hearing, 4 people sign the order. The Mumbai High Court uses that as basis and stays the NAA order. Sho...

      By Sridhar Mohan
    • Maruti acts after our circle post

      After announcing they wont reduce discount Maruti announces Rs 5k cut in car prices to pass on benefit of reduced corporate taxes but only on select models : Alto, Celerio, ignis & diesel varia...

      By Anil Mehta
    • Auto Companies Profiteering

      All auto companies are saying they will not pass benefit of tax cuts to consumer. this is just terrible. Isnt this straight profiteering? Hows this different from govt reducing gst and t...

      By Varun Bhawnani
    • New GST rate reductions

      A uniform GST rate of 12 % will be levied on woven/non-woven polyethylene bags GST council cuts tax rates on job work in diamond industry to 1.5% from 5% In a major boost to gems and jewe...

      By Anil Mehta
    • Tax cuts - corporates must reduce prices

      The attached tells u how much they can. All fmcgs can reduce price between 0.5% -3% Remains to be seen if they profiteer or pass on.

      By Sudesh Rai
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)