Rule 36(4) of SGCT Rules 2017

Can anybody explain Rule 36(4) of the GST Rules 2017 which restricts availment of credit to 120% now revised to 110% that deems credit claimed as inadmissable? more  

View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
It is very well stipulated in the ACT itself.
The Point is "credit claimed as inadmissible" for the reasons, grounds is not stipulated so to challenge the very order.
Mere academic discussions may not suffice any fruitful purpose.
Hence the request. more  
This restriction is on self assessment basis and GSTR 3B can be filed even if you claim more than 110%, but after wards you may be called to pay interest etc.
However if you want to restrict to claim ITC upto 110% as per rules then this 110% is on consolidated basis and not supplier wise. Rest unclaimed ITC may be claimed as and when ITC is uploaded in 2A.
Inward supplies for the month of Jan 2020 involves ITC of Rs. 100 GSTR-2A of Jan 2020 reflects Rs. 70 ITC that can be claimed in GSTR-3B of Jan 2020 is as Rs 70+7=77 Balance ITC of Rs. 23 can be claimed as: if invoices of Rs. 15 gets uploaded by the supplier in Feb 2020 then ITC to be claimed in Feb 2020 in respect of Jan 2020 would be as 15+1.50=16.50
Now you have claimed 77+16.50=93.50 out of 100. To claim remaining ITC of 6.50 you will have to wait for other months.
This way every month one will have to reconcile and track until and unless full ITC is claimed. more  
better gnore unwanted emails ... Jab GSTR 1 sab ka file hoga than the concerned issue will be past.. more  
Whether the rule can be legally implementable is a matter of issue. As per ACT there are certain conditions stipulated for availing Input TAX Credit .If the buyer satisfies all the conditions stipulated in ACT then then ITC can be availed. So this notification is against the ACT unless the ACT is amended. I am not sure of any amendments in the ACT.Someone may help.

If the Rule 36(4) is legally enforceable then the calculations are as follows.

Example 1.
Input Tax Credit as per buyers book Say Rs.80
ITC as per GSTR 2A say 100
ITC eligible as per Rule 36(4) say 110 from 01.01.2020
ITC that can be used = Rs.80

Example 2

Input Tax Credit as per buyers book Say Rs.150
ITC as per GSTR 2A say 100
ITC eligible as per Rule 36(4) say 110 from 01.01.2020
ITC that can be used = Rs.110 more  
your reply is much appreciated sir..
Apparently in this case the ITC claimed reflects in full in GSTR 2A & GSTR 3B was filed 10 days from the scheduled date, but the claim has been declared inadmissable, requiring the dealer to deposit the amount equal to ITC with interest to department...
Thank you for your input & guidance more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • GST update

      Now, Businesses with an annual turnover of up to Rs 40 lakh are GST exempt. Initially, this limit was Rs 20 lakh. Additionally, those with a turnover up to Rs 1.5 crore can opt for the Composition ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Rampant GST evasion in service sector of India

      90% of the service providers are still issuing invoices like the one attached. These guys are providing services to companies like bajaj electricals and these companies shake hands regu...

      By Ajay Dutta
    • GST rates for Covid-19 items

      Hand Sanitizer : 18% Medicine : 12% PPE : 12% Ventilator : 12% Mask : 5% Should such Covid 19 essential items attract tax during a pandemic? Why can't GST be ZERO on ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Coaching Classes big evaders

      I want to let GST authorities know that most coaching classes in India are big evaders of gst and income tax. 95% of them dont pay gst and 80% dont pay income tax as they take money in cash. ...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Need information on GST Registration

      Hello members, I plan to register myself as a Seller on an e-commerce website and hence, need to register for GST Certificate. I have some doubts and hence would request you a...

      By Sabhay Tandon
    • Crashing gst collections

      Extremely worrying signals on Govt revenues. It is likely that there will be a drop of >85% post lockdown in GST collections. April collection May be less than 30% of plan and huge worries for M...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • COVID-19 - Tax compliance dates on GST

      FM has just extended the GST returns filing date for march, april and may to June 30th 2020. If the annual revenue is less than 5 crores, no interest, no penalty and no late fee.

      By Aditi Jain
    • Share details of fraudsters CBIC

      wrongful claims of ITC run by a web of firms in Noida. Fake ITC credit was passed on worth Rs1892cr. Attached Can we please request GST authorities to share details of what these compani...

      By Sudesh Rai
    • Expanding Tax Net - Sweet shops across India

      Most mid sweets/halwai shops of India are top tax evaders. They evade both gst and income tax on 95% of the sale they make. Will the members of this circle tell Government how to get the...

      By Amit Mishra
    • CBI says GST officials taking cuts from transporters

      The Central Bureau of Investigation Monday told a Delhi court that there are various state GST officers who allegedly accept money collected from transporters through middlemen in exchange for not ...

      By Sudesh Rai
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)