Politics of Pollution by IP Bajpai

It's petty politics and not fighting pollution. That is why Delhi NCR and much of north India is struggling to breathe. And all the players are equally to blame as they try, cleverly (or so they think), and pass the buck. Add to the cauldron a Delhi election around the corner and you can be sure it isn't concern for your health that is driving the politics of fighting pollution.

While Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal has tried to position himself as the man trying to save our lungs, with claims that pollution in Delhi is down 25 per cent, his odd-even scheme is completely fake. It only targets cars, leaving seven million two-wheelers to spew their dirt. That two-wheelers are responsible for 25 per cent of vehicular pollution (twice that of cars) cuts no ice with him, nor does the fact that two-wheelers intrinsically create more pollution per horse power than cars. But who can blame him; there are more two-wheeler-owning voters around and he needs those votes, come 2020.

The simplest way to deal with this crisis would have been to declare public transport free, including our much cherished metro system. That with an odd-even ban on motorcycles, would have helped. But that would need to overcome not just objections over subsiding the metro from the DMRC, but also the central government and the Supreme Court. The court had warned the Delhi Government against tinkering with the financial health of the metro system when Delhi wanted to introduce free carriage for women. The Supreme Court has much concern about pollution in the capital and needs to take a more holistic view on the DMRC and not just its finances.

Arvind Kejriwal has hit back at allegations that his government is playing a "blame game" over the air pollution crisis.

The fact is that the metro is overpriced. At Rs. 60 each way on the longest journeys (doubling since 2017), it means the traveller from Noida to Gurugram must spend at least Rs. 150 (including last mile) a day. Which means it's much cheaper (door-to-door) for two people to share a ride on a two-wheeler than take the metro. Its ridership has stagnated under the 3 million-a-day mark despite a doubling on the network. This is actually a financial disaster given the investment in the additional lines. The lack of ridership is clearly linked to the fare, but both DMRC and the centre (co-owners with the Delhi Government), are against subsidising metro fares even though worldwide metros are subsidised.

Then the state and the centre are fighting over the lack of machinery provided to farmers for removing the stubble. This was meant to be the centre's job and the state claims that the 63,000 odd machines given so far by the centre are not enough; with Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia claiming that at this pace it would take decades to meet the needs of 26 lakh farmers. He is right. But given the centre's lack of concern (they really aren't an environment-friendly government) couldn't the state have paid the Punjab farmers the Rs. 100 a quintal they were demanding as subsidy for not burning the stubble? If they can subsidise buses for women, electricity and water for the poor, isn't this a worthwhile goal? Or they could have at least offered to split the cost with centre and the Punjab and Haryana governments.

Pollution in the National Capital Region was declared a public health emergency on Friday by the Environment Pollution (Prevention & Control) Authority.

Similarly, the centre has been hugely generous to farmers with the PM Kisan scheme -- would another Rs. 100 per quintal or a part thereof really upset its financial apple cart? The winter paddy here is about 11 million tonnes, which at Rs. 100 a quintal would have required Rs. 1,100 crore; that's only an additional Rs. 500 cr from what the centre says it is already spending on stubble reduction. In any case, Rs. 500 crore seems a paltry amount to spend on saving the health of citizens in this polluted belt. If the government has the money to build a new central vista then surely it can do more for pollution.

Nor does anyone seem to have looked at the larger agricultural issue -- that the rice grown in the north is extremely environmentally unfriendly. It uses huge quantities of water and cutting the stubble is a major issue.
Pollution rose to the worst levels so far this year on Sunday, prompting Arvind Kejriwal to issue a fresh appeal asking residents to follow the "odd-even" rule.

Strangely, as Delhi was choking on Saturday, what would it have cost the state government to declare Sunday a holiday and have all but emergency services closed for the day? Votes maybe? Votes from traders, shopkeepers, and those intrepid Delhi shoppers.

Of course, we continue to ignore the dust problem in Delhi. The state claims to have got state-of-the-art road cleaning machines, but obviously they are only used sparingly, since they haven't made any real difference. Nor has the complete failure of the people of Delhi to control the fireworks on Diwali helped. Delhi Police and all the 340-odd elected officials (state assembly and municipal corporations) have failed to work with communities to reduce the firework menace. Nobody wants to upset any religious festival, even though gunpowder wasn't around when Lord Ram was.

Meanwhile the number of stubble fires this year has crossed last year's number and schemes on the ground seem to have failed. more  

View all 13 comments Below 13 comments
Its funny that subject of this post is "Politics of Pollution" and its blaming the only person who is doing something about this. more  
Is there any developed country which is not having HUMAN, INDUSTRIAL & AGRICULTURAL WASTES? Answer ? Accordingly try to find out the root cause(s) instead blaming and politicizing one of the major issue from which no one will remain unaffected in coming days. more  
Huge 4 wheelers running on diesel are responsible for pollution. The original message is about ideal - theoretical, while Mr. Kejriwal's solution being optimal and doable. Ideal solutions have implementation problems, and then we are back to situation doing nothing. Beg to differ on equivalence of motorcycles with cars. Firstly the former all run on petrol, much cleaner than diesel. You want to equate a two-wheeler owned by a relatively poorer person running on petrol with a sports utility vehicle emitting diesel fumes. So please, should we criticise him for the sake of criticism? He has done his research in offering exemptions, so please respect him, and his solutions. more  
Rising Numbers of People in Delhi are Adding to Pollution,but they are the voters! more  
is only the govt to blame. what about suv loving delhites. We want action against farmers. growing crops is their livelihood. is suv a livelihood. it is nothing but showing off and in most cases- my dad is rich showoff. is burning crackers at wedding a livelihood. no just another show-off. the baraatis shall walk and dance in lights powered by diesel gensets behind them. burning crackers depite ban on diwali in guise of Shagun and Hinduism.Problem is everyone wants things to change to tackle pollution but not for himself, only for others.
Odd-Even is a symbolic scheme to send a message that time has come that you start sacrificing some slice of normal life if you really want to tackle the issue. i agree two wheelers should not be exempted. All Saturdays should be declared as holidays for educational institutes.
problem with delhi metro is not fares but last mile connectivity and the status symbol we attribute to cars. a college student facing no health issue should be clearly told he has to pay for parking the car (free parking is the biggest car sale booster) or else he/she can use public transport.
In London people have to pay congestion tax. This is how Europe tackles the menace of cars. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Delhi water worst in India

      If it wasn’t enough that Delhi air is among the world’s most polluted, a new study by Govt itself has now shown that the city’s tap water is the most unsafe among 21 State capital...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • Odd Even useless says Supreme Court

      Wait didnt the citizens say that in the circle poll? Where is the link to your survey LocalCircles Manager? Last 2 days odd even was there, zero impact pollution worsened. The Supreme ...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • Delhiites - conceive babies only in Dec Jan

      And Deliver in August September. See attached. Doctors say there is an increased risk of miscarriage with the pollutants in Oct Nov reaching the placenta. So basically what it means is y...

      By Vinita Agrawal
      /
    • Childrens day run in 550 AqI

      On a day when AQI is 550 we are making children run in the morning. Book whosoever responsible for crime.

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari
      /
    • Schools shut Nov 14 and Nov 15

      Attached EPCA notification. Keep the conversation and the eacalation going circles! This is a war like situation.

      By Shikha Chhabra
      /
    • Failure of Governance

      A ground report reveals that there is hardly any breather at many of the 13 toxic hubs of Rohini, Dwarka, Okhla Phase II, Punjabi Bagh, Anand Vihar, Vivek Vihar, Wazirpur, Jahangirpuri, RK Puram, B...

      By Ragini Sen
      /
    • action againt stubble burning

      When we have a 24-hour average of 625 microgram per cubic metre (µg/m3) levels of PM 2.5--polluting particles 30 times finer than one human hair, that can enter the bloodstream and sicken or ...

      By Sneha Goyal
      /
    • Toxic Foam in Yamuna

      Helpless devotees on the occasion of Chhath were forced to offer prayers by immersing themselves in the toxic foam. Is there a plan to clean it up? This is on kalindi kunj side. Also, se...

      By Mala Sehgal
      /
    • How stubble burning became ‘a question of life and death?

      • It’s serious: The Supreme Court had some strong words for Punjab and Haryana governments on Wednesday due to their failure to stop stubble burning that's behind the air emergency in De...

      By Sunil Dutt Agrawal
      /
    • SUPREME COURT SHOWS THE WAY TO PUT AN END TO STUBBLW BURNING AND ALL THE WOES OF POOR DELHIITES ::

      S.C. has asked who is responsible Stubble burnig and went on to answer , the State Governments . The entire state Administrative and Police mechanism of Punjab, Hariyana, U.P. from the C...

      By Jayakumar Daniel
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)