GST on cars

Taxes on cars are almost in line with 'sin products' (those that are heavily taxed, like tobacco, to discourage sales) under GST. We have a cess on so many cars. No wonder auto sales are where they are(attached) more  

B1700474-5A6A-4A17-8290-7A910C6067D8___20190805024447___.jpeg
View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
On one side we talk that city roads are heavily loaded with vehicles and even parking of vehicles is practically impossible.On the other side we talk vehicle sales are dropping.As per statistics vehicle sales were contineously rising since 2003.Probably is this Good for roads and city traffic.On the contrary we should have efficient and fast public transport and that will reduce congestion on the roads. more  
Conclusions I draw:
Drop is minimum in
* Market Leaders in Budget Car segments (sole exception Maruti)
* Drop is lower in Commercial segment leaders
* Both the above have lower GST ( 5 - 18%)
Drop in premium segment is max - perfect implementation of progressive taxation - higher wealth / affording capacity should pay more.
I think Govt Policy is working perfectly ...
The Govt has no reason to encourage an Industry making unaffordable products. more  
It is high time that the GST on vehicles is increased as this will curb the use of individual motorised transport using fossil fuel. more  
All are wait for Electric vehicle. more  
It is good that sales of Automobiles has come down. This will save the country's expenditure on importing Oil from outside, apart from reducing pollution. In addition, I wonder what the lady, Naina Mittal really wants to communicate? Actually reduction in the sales of all items like Cars, large White goods, Costly TV sets, Jewellery, Designer clothes, Real Estate, etc. has come down since the sale of such items was based more on investment of Black Money, rather then real need. The lady does not explain how the sales have reduced due to GST?
Some people really say senseless things. more  
Right. Automobiles business is highly cyclical. There were times few years ago when auto sales were in the doldrums, even commercial vehicles sales were going down -- and there was no GST in sight at that time. For information of Ms. Naina Mittal, taxes on automobiles have always been this high, even more than the present numbers. So to try to find a correlation and cause-effect relationship based on rhetoric should be avoided. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Looters being empowered?

      There are only two kinds of really rich Indians. Wealth creators and looters. The Prime Minister declared his respect for wealth creators in his Independence Day speech this year, acknowledging the...

      By Ruchika L Maheshwari
      /
    • GST evasion by traders continues unabated

      See attached this chain called kabliwala in noida sells dry fruits and lots of food items but doesnt give pakka bill with gst number. They have 4 stores computer yet kachha bills. Shame.

      By Sudesh Rai
      /
    • GsTR9

      GsTR9 If a dealer has availed ITC based on physical invoices and same not reflected in GSTR2A for 17-18 financial year how to rectify in GSTR9 now ...My Ans..Nothing to worry just fill all col...

      By Krishna Prasad
      /
    • GsTR9

      If a dealer has availed ITC based on physical invoices and same not reflected in GSTR2A for 17-18 financial year how to rectify in GSTR9 now

      By KAMESWARA RAO MYLAVARAPU
      /
    • Govt considering increasing GST rates

      Because of all the shortfall seems like Govt is considering increasing GST rates. It is looking raising rates on goods and services attracting zero tax to 5 per cent, and to 12 per cent from 5 per ...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • GST collections dipping why?

      GST collection was supposed to be 110,000 crore in September. Instead it is at 92000 crores. Indicates slowing economy to me. What do others know, think?

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • Make gst pct display mandatory for hotel sites

      Travel sites like makemytrip are not mentioning GST rates but only amount in booking processes. GST rates have been reduced on various hotel room categories and if % are shown mandatorily ppl will ...

      By Amod Agarwal
      /
    • Help needed related to closing company having pending GST penalty

      Hi, I am looking advise/suggestion on the following problem. I had started a tech startup 3 years back. I failed to create a sustainable business and now moved back to corporate job. I have filed G...

      By Santosh Shet
      /
    • No GST return no eway bill

      Starting 1st Nov unless returns are filed , e-way bills cannot be generated .Alerts will be sent to non- filers after which they will not be able to generate e-way bills if still returns are not fi...

      By Naina Mittal
      /
    • 22 corrupt officers shown door

      Good work Modiji!! The Centre has once again struck corrupt government officials and this time it has forcefully retired 22 senior officers of the rank of Superintendent. The ...

      By Bharat Lal
      /
    • Role of NSIC

      I wish to know the role of NSIC in providing service to MSMEs. As I have seen the only help it renders is to to issue a certificate that the concerned industry is a small scale one and based on ...

      By Sukumaran Nair
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)