GST on cars

Taxes on cars are almost in line with 'sin products' (those that are heavily taxed, like tobacco, to discourage sales) under GST. We have a cess on so many cars. No wonder auto sales are where they are(attached) more  

View all 6 comments Below 6 comments
On one side we talk that city roads are heavily loaded with vehicles and even parking of vehicles is practically impossible.On the other side we talk vehicle sales are dropping.As per statistics vehicle sales were contineously rising since 2003.Probably is this Good for roads and city traffic.On the contrary we should have efficient and fast public transport and that will reduce congestion on the roads. more  
Conclusions I draw:
Drop is minimum in
* Market Leaders in Budget Car segments (sole exception Maruti)
* Drop is lower in Commercial segment leaders
* Both the above have lower GST ( 5 - 18%)
Drop in premium segment is max - perfect implementation of progressive taxation - higher wealth / affording capacity should pay more.
I think Govt Policy is working perfectly ...
The Govt has no reason to encourage an Industry making unaffordable products. more  
It is high time that the GST on vehicles is increased as this will curb the use of individual motorised transport using fossil fuel. more  
All are wait for Electric vehicle. more  
It is good that sales of Automobiles has come down. This will save the country's expenditure on importing Oil from outside, apart from reducing pollution. In addition, I wonder what the lady, Naina Mittal really wants to communicate? Actually reduction in the sales of all items like Cars, large White goods, Costly TV sets, Jewellery, Designer clothes, Real Estate, etc. has come down since the sale of such items was based more on investment of Black Money, rather then real need. The lady does not explain how the sales have reduced due to GST?
Some people really say senseless things. more  
Right. Automobiles business is highly cyclical. There were times few years ago when auto sales were in the doldrums, even commercial vehicles sales were going down -- and there was no GST in sight at that time. For information of Ms. Naina Mittal, taxes on automobiles have always been this high, even more than the present numbers. So to try to find a correlation and cause-effect relationship based on rhetoric should be avoided. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • ITC denial

      This is internal finance ministry communication. Does this mean ITC is being denied to meet targets?

      By Rohit Jain
    • Abolish Input Tax Credit system

      Heading in Times of India 21 January 2020 “Trading firm director held in ₹10-crore GST scam The Thane wing of the CGST arrested Vinit Agarwal, director of Hemraj Devkarandas Metals ...

    • GST registrations getting cancelled

      Now the non-filing of Goods and Services Tax (GST) returns is leading to attachment of bank accounts or cancellation of registration and many are worried. According to the GST law, it i...

      By Vishal Khanna

      Who can do business as an unregistered dealer under GST. Thanks - Sailesh

    • clarification

      I would like clarification, whether a fund collected annually ,and spent on the benificiaries;which amount to roughly Rs 50 to 60 lakhs for our regular get-togethers be subjected to GST authorities...

      By Vadakke Raman
    • Bribery in GST

      I am getting reports that magnitude of bribery on gst related matters has gone up. The excuse given is “sir risk badh gaya hai” you need to pay more. There are man...

      By RN Chopra

      Can someone please clarify is GST is to be paid by the Property owner for premises given on rent for commercial purpose? If yes, is the owner required to file for GST as regular or Composition deal...

    • GST for aerated/energy drinks

      I recently downloaded the latest price list from Amway's newly launched website and was shocked to see all their energy drinks were charged @ 40% ( price list attached). Could someone please let me...

      By Neeru Sood
    • FASTag

      Double fare is only when you enter a fastag lane without Fastag as it will slow down people having Fastag. If you are willing to go on the cash lane then there is normal fare pay by cash or credit ...

      By Sreenivasan Sabapathi
    • fast tag

      fast tag is useful only when anyone uses the National Highways which are tolled. But can it be imposed by effectively requiring a prepayment for toll road facility which may or may not be used ? I ...

      By Suresh Gopinathan
    • Fast Tag

      How can the government FORCE users to compulsorily move on to a private platform or coerce them to pay double the normal toll? Why is Fast Tag mandatory for personal vehicles? Is it a w...

      By Sudesh Rai
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)