Good explanation of profiteering...

Since the goods and services tax (GST) was introduced in India, the GST Council has reduced tax rates on many items over time to make sure the household costs of consumers come down. In different discussions on LocalCircles, which hosts an anti-profiteering online community for National Anti-profiteering Authority (NAA), several consumers have been reporting that even after the GST rate reduction, many manufacturers as well as retailers have not been passing on the benefits. For instance, though GST rates on regular household items like shampoos, cosmetics, groceries, etc. were reduced from 28% to 18% in November 2017, only 27% consumers confirmed in the January 2019 LocalCircles survey that they have actually seen maximum retail prices (MRPs) being revised downwards. Similarly, for items like appliances, fragrances, paints, etc., where GST rates were reduced in July 2018, only 26% consumers have confirmed experiencing lower MRPs while 38% confirmed that MRPs had not been reduced, 36% didn’t know or did not have a need to buy such items.
Now, consumers can easily submit a complaint with evidence of old and new MRPs to outline instances of profiteering. It can be an invoice, a screenshot of product listing with MRP from an e-commerce site or a picture of the actual product. In cases of restaurants, one can submit invoices or even pictures of the old and new menu cards, which many times have a date on them. Once the complaint is received via the anti-profiteering online community or the NAA complaint form, it is forwarded to the Standing Committee within 24 hours and is taken for evaluation. The entire process of evaluation, investigation, hearing and order currently takes anywhere between 9-12 months from the time a complaint is registered.
Based on complaints received, it is apparent that majority of the brands have not tended to revise MRPs on existing stocks at their warehouse and at the distributor or retailer level so till these stocks are depleted, the consumers don’t actually experience the benefit. Same is the case with e-commerce, where in many cases, the sellers are still listing products with the old and higher MRPs. When a consumer submits a complaint, not only is that particular SKU (stock keeping unit) questioned but many times the entire product category is evaluated for profiteering.

What is required here is that the manufacturers or the brands take a proactive approach to passing on GST benefits and a supply chain communication mechanism is implemented which is electronic and fast, so different players in the chain know the price revision by SKU and understand that these benefits are to be passed now, rather than when they get the new stock with updated MRPs. In some cases, the brands may even have to issue credit vouchers to retailers to compensate them for selling the stock at a lower price than the MRP.
The math of profiteering is rather simple, where once a GST rate is reduced, the base price for an item is calculated from the old MRP and the new GST rate is applied to the base price to derive the expected MRP. The difference between the brand’s new MRP and the expected MRP is what classifies as profiteering.

https://www.livemint.com/politics/policy/brands-must-take-a-proactive-approach-to-pass-on-gst-benefits-1551808808899.html more  

View all 16 comments Below 16 comments
Could not find a proper forum. Also since you claim to be in consumer protection this topic should interest you more  
Most of the time business man reluctant to reduce the price. Who want to cut their profit. more  
Law implementation wing must look in to the matter and act accordingly. more  
This article is not written by Sanjana but Founder of LocalCircles. more  
Tnq for the post. more  
Post a Comment

Related Posts

    • Nivea’s potential profiteering

      MRP of nivea shower gel stays at 349 whether gst rate was 28% or as now is 18% Need for enquiry please

      By Anil Mehta
      /
    • Anti Profiteering term extension

      Super delighted to read that term of anti profiteering body has been extended by 2 years. I really hope now all the complaints filed by me and many other members of circle will be taken on priority...

      By Garima Sharma
      /
    • Profteering off the farmers

      Had one of my uncles who is a farmer in andhra visit me yesterday. The price at which he sells mango is 10 rupees a kg. Big basket sells same mango for 110 rupees a kg. So much so for being fair...

      By Anshu Saxena
      /
    • Great news - Term of anti-profiteering extended by 2 years

      'Thumbs up to the consumer, thumbs down news for profiteering companies esp builders. Also good news that if the profiteering companies dont pay the amount 20% penalty will be enforced. \ud83d\ud...

      By Venkata Lukka
      /
    • Is ITC profiteering

      Fiama di willis brand of ITC cool burst men shower gel. MRP before rate reduction 199. Same after rate reduction. Yesterdays screenshot. The MRP should have been reduced to 185 or so. If ITC type...

      By Garima Sharma
      /
    • Adidas profiteering more example

      Something is definitely wrong. 2 screenshots of nov 2017 and one recent of 2019. 190 MRP should have been 175 after rate reduction but instead 200.

      By Garima Sharma
      /
    • Unilever clearly profiteering

      Here see how unilever has been profiteering. The product in 11/17 pre gst rate reduction on cosmetics was having MRP 199. Even now the same product (ydays screenshot) has MRP 199 while gst rate has...

      By Garima Sharma
      /
    • GST by OYO

      I had booked a room through OYO ROOMS. while checking in I had asked hotel that I need a Tax Invoice with our company's GST number. They had confirmed it to be Fine. While checking out I had been t...

      By Desh Malhotra
      /
    • Biotique company may also be profiteering

      See screenshot of product made in 09/17 had MRP 180. Despite gst rate dropping from 28% to 18% on cosmetics the mrp in 2019, this morning - big basket is 180. The mrp should have been around 165....

      By Niharika Jain
      /
    • Is this profiteering

      Himalaya anti wrinkle cream earlier had price of 250 MRP and i thought gst rate on cosmetics was changed by finance ministry to 18% Should the mrp have reduced from 250. The first product is 201...

      By Niharika Jain
      /
    • HUL short film on water scarecity

      HUL is now airing a rather derogatory short film about their concerns for the rural poor. Water scarcity is severe across the country including urban centres and remote rural areas. But this film...

      By Ramesh Muthya
      /
Share To
Enter your email & mobile number and we will send you the instructions

Note - The email can sometime gets delivered to the spam folder, so the instruction will be send to your mobile as well

Please select a Circle that you want people to invite to.
Invite to
(Maximum 500 email ids allowed.)